| Show MinqM Hit n right M in f fuirtalnel 1 Mr 1 CIcMon H Klnwy of Halt Lake City hpnibaldy one of the last orated I lawyer on Irrigation Ww In fhb cane Iry Mug lice niilhor of Irrigation late noel IWtltf I recngnlretl nil thority on thu ubjTt llenw anything any-thing hn may my touching on Ihn present pres-ent California dhlrlet Irr lira tlon law will eomiiHind n rnpertfnl hearing In a recent curilrlbulkm lo the PrM M Ir Kinney advanced lb following cplnln on Iho connlllultooatlly thu W right nth A great deal of Interest la I lueIng miilfcotcd 1 throiighmit the western laltw nee In whelher the upnino salve of lice United Mate will decide the Wright law to Im I r lHullunnl or therwliw Not only It the Intercut nnnlfoted In the Mate of California nun which Halo Ihoca 111 to the iipremn court tint aloe tlinnighont ho other ulalraof thnnntwhlch hnvo tuplnllnsanrarly I tlmllirto tho ono f ii < iucllon I and ahxi In lhra + slates > diern legMnllon IIIKIII ware rlliU It x > lngcoiilrmplaU I i < d t The law In iiiiettlun hi I been held 1 to bo roiiktltultinal by eke tiiprrma court of California In t number of atta but by the United Male circuit court In which lodge It Ions prenlded ho law wn held to lie I un > n tlllillon ill In another mar An effort Scat Wen iindn by which nil throe raw tnvolv h ng the cotiktltutlonnllly of the Into Lora been toiiMilldaleil Ihe ttiprctno court of the Unltrd fit lit en The prlnclpiil tinttlont In the cave ire bras lice property taken fnini tics irlvnto owner by inenntof wmcnt and win of Morn with or with or wltl tlllt dun pnitiMiif Inn and Ihnloro In i vlolallon of the foiinreath oared burnt tll lice federal mil > tltullon and l Meond I won or w ns not tin properly MI taken for public urn or purpw Ma arc of tics opinion lhat the ruling of the supreme I court of lallfurnla w na nirntl In the prvinlwu awl aslant t ng llit < M > ctlon polntnilliuylhalthera Ix I no aucli thing as drawing a clear I and lellnltn linn nee dlottngiilidiliiir Lrtntcn purHien of n miblle slid of Ilhl prlvalo l nature Piiblle I unit UI private Interest are MI commingled 111I many rasa Hint It U tlinicnlt to determine which pre I ilonilnaltH I Iliitwhon the leirUltture i knee time tteclantl I that n rrrtala nee In I a public one salt did III the law In ii nllin the court ua u general rule will kiipport It when not MtUfleil that B grtnl uninif bias tech cummltledl and when there 10 I any doabt solo tint purpoMit the eg lallvitdnt k > nthnuil nlwnpa sided Ilea Iho suprenso ourt et the tuilcd Slate will derlda tics iiieitun rriiiulni lul Iw I wen lluttaklnir lute amrldcro that the nettl I rued nevewltlrt of the nrld carat hlci reiille I In change front the ioiiiinon law doctrine of na tenth Ihn doctrlnn of urpniprlatlon which icon already been tutltlned by tlmt court and nlito tho nowla end nun MtJtlc for tlio orguntzulim ul tics ilUlrt tlninurtloii nrti letter i1 vrlopinentoflhtirnuntry at large It serum to ua that the court glll kuttatn lice decUlon alnndy glvin by the tu prune court of fallfornU |
