Show 1 i r VALLeY FARMERS I Court ol of Appeals Appeal Smelter Smoke Case Caws I At St Sf Paul I SUSTAINS JUDGE MARSHALL Maik IU Ih tI In l 1 ni If 4 a and of If Ot rs le suit 11 TK Iy r UI Tint not no be i t I Ift operate of their act cu In Ii a manner that bt tb will rl In itt Inthe I I tin the rollon of fl 0 dic and nd lead Ia and c W par and nd will to b lie forbidden 1 In tn melt mft It I er contain t COl a In ID 12 e or of o lu I 0 i Ir r i cent Wita th Phi war Tn at or w ordered dered y W Jr M In th Ih fed rd eal epI M Iii IW t oUy alt lit kt t th Ih time tim tin th h I nM ww weT we ht A I 1 v or ni l hIM a M lite bae l In IA thi Ihl flU y I l til Ih elKs tt Nt the tM n hm hl I by I a decision of or r tIr TUn TUnIt N It T to fl I CO rrt o rt r tr r ap P l in int at t BU 1 Paul PaMI 1 t hith tribunal al Mi the Un sa e waa taken tk hy by thi th hc 1108 litter the th Ih of f 3 van pa a h 1 I th Ih ln r The Th Injunction I d ng th railed J II gh I uI Hj Ii nl I oi u ii h I l ht 11 ni It r nt III Murray ami 1101 th Ih hr ai I d in inI I r 11 iu In HI HItI tI brought In lot I farmer In the thO th dI il y ih th M Icing UI an II a HI I Ill Ii a Mt t th he ht rutted I I III I 1 I lA I 8 it ug c 1 pan and anol others The ull w s r t hy iy h th Ih ft a on an H fili II which wan WIlK to tn t the th rl r money t ti rry ruma the Ih curI urt J n I L lu itt William H King Kloe the tite oa calM ce f for tur r the farmer fm and l 1 BUll Ri I ill Ho aU a fut Van Vain Coli itt A on and el A Uram 11 The Th llIn A Refining H Ha a party y 10 th ft hut I u t a was w and ut I 0 qt was waa by b th Ih arm MANY pJ In la th the I tt no itt no claim for tr damage d ma maU WM w th U Ika farMon r holding thun th m mt t b bi be A bond band at o 5 00 Vaa Aled hy by h th c n Ihen h hn n their appeal w tn No Now W It Ith i h Ii believed thU Rm v ill tU do Ie nor lito tha th ver the tilt list There rere or r ia now flow no pending tib UL t tt U of farmer Ute the Ui 10 MAY MA NOT The 4 n 0 of f Ju J u ta full 11 KM hu hot keen bi Hi thin lh city and andt ou et t the Lb Un o 0 m ni de df d I the pr effect of or M tl uttI their thop attorney have ia v MM Hd Ute UIo iTt opinion In full Mining men meny My y that the will 11 I II sum ue tic Ung the thi lh ores ore or trout tN th the Utah Uth mine mineto In Th a t wiy Sy to prevent pret farther In bl o rn r from froit the fume c ere 18 to the th t that thet the thO m I I I to en move 0 in hi of tt i In the th court an al i r te to W bi unfounded from fr m ad hi II i t Iter operator a con conW W et t the problem will not 01 u be bun until the ha hee h been b en reed read d Una tit explained to t the tta IRIA by bythe bythe the attorney fur for ItI various JIJI In n UtI etty dt TWO PLANTS PLANT WILL tIone MY d defendant In b the molts uli 1111 brought iK them by tanner fanner were tr the Ihen n Smelting ton om Consolidated a Mining 4 tUng ll h c United emitting 4 Mining company COlli The be t that Ihal tin th tt plant In lit I soon noon on t I na lIw operation of It II Iti pi cut entirely and und t t Utah Itah IK i it to 10 build a new In h To Tv i next Jear er r thi thu e tor ur from further ion In tit Inthe hith I the th fight with the Ih I nan lug Ing the Ih down don to the two Iwo remain remaining ing with the Ih A UI I tig 1 I i I i i tot U Judge in Ia hu lint hi rn rm dera I m 1 Minth II gt Id ui iii trout n w 1 K from Iram their sand and 4 tea is WW fro from treating Una ore ON ion on laming re to than Lan 1 11 pot per cent I in III the charge cha but bUI f weri trin t U to continue to tu url ui t under pending tn uit I to H higher court T AM t The or Ark It II I later m I In in n I with It ii t lit fur mem it n the tI lall in I join nh ih Ito i lug hi III In nuking MI t tu a ii t o I II i 1 wf tit the Ilie I hut lut it II ih h atri I It v tai H ii i t h i I II i liiK I in in UKI tit Ii i i t j jil il lOr I H li ir I I I I Mil 1 ing In ur hd h i i I arr i f I ih II L j n 4 I ue tle Uni 41 il iii I s n ii t i t I IM II lile It uc in I I n II l ni iu of ut I t h hId i I HI i i ranted Id all the thi te III u a i M t I t I 1 4 punt pun of ot r i r j na l I pen tu the Ih finn fain U h i rr r N i Tv l iK k down dt 11 to 0 48 4 today hut bUI tin Ini I 1 tr tm rn i 1 that thi Ihl this 1 not Mt ot mal the iTC lii i Ihl fo 1 it void on nil tT th h open Mart bIr I IThe t It U K The Til cloning 1011 quotations and a were TITU HT TO HK tk tike 1414 IA I Aked I Albion I TK Alice Alke All IHil I a I 2 ju i 8 as tl I union tIk It a II IIa farina a 2 o I I 1 tl all allM i n M Mi ir 1 fro I I n fl 2 ItO n I Z n 1 i t DK fi iti 3 4 i Ih 1118 1 ET Fr Ii le N t I W 4 IHil 11 I 1 n 2 ni 12 Morn lion I Mv I I r t 2 n 1111 ii 7 l w M I im ini nn n u h hL I 1 K 12 I 2 I 1 I ILu L Lu n P ri 11 M MN t I I 1 1 TL 7 4 N nl ii i TI X ii i io 4 N P r nl r I it 1 o 04 g 1 1 I I II t i T 1 TO 1 I III t fl I j l 1 1 I Ml 1 II I 1 I a aI I I 1 I c n i 1 ti 1 tn 11 i 11 I fl 2 i utI r LIidI 1 4 I It i rII ri 41 4 1 11 ILu k kI 1 J j I I I 1 iii 1 I If i n I s ti p Il lr w ri ii 4 41 fn 1 1 4 2 Fm ral 1 Ingot J I Ir HI HIa HOTTI m 1 ti I I I nv n nI 3 Joe I r r 01 d King Kin IH IHn I LItI hIe n 0 I lak Iki i iN I 3 31 7 N w York Tork 1 I IO Nev O H FIn f fUlch I 1 Itch I I 1 5 uth ii Wu fon 0 Oi 1 I It 1 M t ven Trough H 44 I 44 14 1 IH t I Ito Victor to Con Cin C n I 1 M ni 11 1 III I U If Yankee Yae Con 1 Iii U UNITED t tik k 1 Rid Akl op 1 q la 1 t 1 4 1 4 1 I IEl Kly El W WIth It h I 44 41 Ohio rr 1 5 aft 11 a 3 HI uit i I r I er i I ti R RN 1 N I I On Ohi II Mu on V alley al I 1 I 1 1 0 O OI CALL I Ln L Mammoth at t 11 at atley LIZ May ley a Day at I M A at nt 3 UI Ham lit fit 65 5 B ck It Tunnel 1100 itt III t 4 49 flack BIk Jack Jak I on 1000 at ut 21 1 OO at al 21 MO Gee at It 22 2 at I 85 Cr ra Ii Vi nt II 32 II 1600 1090 1 IO at al 14 TO at 25 35 MI Ml Lake at al 3 37 C GOt MI at itt 31 17 n Trough at al t l 1660 1 ai CL ala 44 a 1400 at 81 41 44 at al 43 Victor WO at a 8 6 H OPEN IPEN B n AHO ARO fI AIE T AJax at 27 7 2000 at al K 26 BEck Berk rk Tunnel at III 49 1000 at 4 48 H M 10 0 nt at 2 31 8 K I III 0 Mk SOt at 2 25 65 O n ul itt 22 U B M 30 3 fit iO at ut 1 at 2110 2 ft S R 81 80 U crown 0 Point MO at t 31 sa 3 0 fl at t UH 83 crown row In I SOo at t 1 00 Mi i at UH 33 Ual laly I v i at a 1 26 Iron at t 33 Mammoth SIMI SOO nt ut KU tt I Km at al alI ati I 1 1 I H o i Columbu Con TOO SOO at It M 1 lOll at et atI etU 1101 U HI nix i on 00 at nt 33 3 L o 1 at III a 44 Mm SiN ul lt 4 H H 10 Ham 10 at lit lit et K II t ii it I at al alI 6 1 f 4 it at I 67 61 7 70 t ul ut I itI 7 tI ti 60 0 I MIJ oliO 5 l I lii v O nt at I I W ti tiIt I It I ITt a Value I l Igil iII S 8 then I I i II 1133 I KOI I t on 8 I I 1 ik d b s total I 20 i |