OCR Text |
Show 17 SPRING VI LLE HERALD, Section 3 Thursday, December 20, 2007 Mapleton land case done with testimonies Janice Peterson STAFF WRITER After several days of testimony, the bench trial between Friends of Maple Mountain and Mapleton city heard final witnesses Friday. Wendell Gibby, who owns and plans to develop property in Mapleton, testified tes-tified briefly, as did representatives rep-resentatives from Rocky Mountain Power. Although Al-though the final witnesses gave testimony Friday, a decision will not be made in the case for another month.: "All the testimony is now concluded, and what remains is for both parties par-ties to give an exchange of their closing briefs," said Bob Bradshaw, Mapleton city administrator. The main point in the case, Bradshaw said, is whether the decision to grant a planned development devel-opment zone on Gibby's property may be contested in a referendum vote. ;. Bradshaw said attorneys attor-neys in the case must submit sub-mit briefs of their closing arguments by Jan. 11, at which point all parties will be heard and a decision may be made. "It's possible, technically, that the judge could give a ruling from the bench on Jan. 11, but we anticipate that in practice it will be the end of January, early February before we get the judge's written ruling," Bradshaw said. The case came before the court after Friends of Maple Ma-ple Mountain obtained a restraining re-straining order, restricting Gibby from working with the city until a referendum vote had been taken. The court has been asked to decide whether the zoning decision was administrative, administra-tive, which cannot be challenged chal-lenged by referendum, or legislative, which can. Bradshaw said the city also asked the court to decide de-cide whether enough signatures sig-natures were obtained for a referendum. The number of signatures necessary is determined by the number of votes cast in Mapleton in the last governor's election. elec-tion. Bradshaw said a legislative legis-lative action would need enough signatures to equal 35 percent of those votes, while an administrative action would only need 15 percent. Only 864 signatures ' $$ With a little concentration and a will to help others less fortunate than themselves the students in Mrs. Wheatles 1st grade class at Art City Elementary set to making blankets for the Juvenile Justice Center. They made a record seven blankets this year and hope they warm up the bodies and hearts of those who receive them. s f t. , .tjr v .x dk fee '.. r ( "fl ' were collected by Friends of Maple Mountain, which is enough to pass the 15 percent mark, but not enough to pass 35 percent. per-cent. If the judge rules that the zoning was an administrative admin-istrative action, Friends of Maple Mountain would have enough signatures for a referendum. However, How-ever, Bradshaw said the point is moot, because an administrative action cannot can-not be challenged by referendum. refer-endum. "It dies either way," he said. Jim Lundberg, who is involved with Friends of Maple Mountain, said he believes the number of signatures will be enough whether or not the issue is administrative or legislative. legis-lative. The main issue, he said, is that the residents of Mapleton should have a say in how the city is developed. de-veloped. The ability to challenge a decision on the way the city is zoned, Lundberg said, is a right guaranteed to the people by law. "The referendum process pro-cess is a constitutional right under the Utah State Constitution-," he said. Lundberg stressed that Friends of Maple Mountain Moun-tain does not oppose Gibby's Gib-by's right to develop his property, they oppose the rezoning of the property. The group simply wants the right to contest the city's decision, he said. Gibby said he hopes the issue moves through the court system quickly to save himself and the city a good deal of money. The longer the case goes on, he said, the more costs pile up in attorney's fees and hours of manpower. "It's time we put this behind be-hind us," he said. "We're going to have development, develop-ment, and we might as well do it in a reasonable way." Gibby said the restraining restrain-ing order obtained by Friends of Maple Mountain Moun-tain is simply an llth-hour attempt to stop him from building on his property. The effort is wasted, he said, because even if he loses, there will eventually eventu-ally be development at the location at an even higher density. Although Friends of Maple Ma-ple Mountain say it is their constitutional right to have a referendum vote, Gibby said, it is not prudent that zoning decisions were every decision be contest- made by referendum, we ed with a referendum. would have a very chaotic "If individual property government," he said. WVlhrishnas') n I from f V4 Randy and Calvin anrl tha rack Ai of the Guys! P j i mm fr 1 ' V, 872 N. K!2:n SgisnisSi Fork f 794-C377 cr 793-C077 HtMAllWliiiil - g yW 'miilOTWi)iiJlllli;wil''il'MlMtii i.illii J J i I. II III Ul J. HHimi ' U I - . 'II. I . ! ' . . . I iff, :t I 8 i - : I' I . - i . - 14 ft.-- T " - s.;y-" i-' i ,. i I TopTai c!M:y 7b Sencf Vot Our Very Best: lTis the season. & We're grateful for your friendship. J-We appreciate your loyalty. 4 You're such good neighbors. 5, It's a pleasure to serve you. You make it all worthwhile. 7 We couldn't have done it without your support. & We look forward to your continued business. We know you've been good, tik It gives us joy! With warm isltv$ from all of us for a merry caid bright holiday season. :::: : -r:':--: - PHOTOnO t. O t, A, i. CDDD 80 West Center Springville, Utah 84663 (801 ) 489-321 8 www.snelsonphotolab.com 1 4. |