Show mm ISM A m 14 0 CRIME declares tho the two have no relations THE SUBJECTS WOULD REBEL V monco declares the moral im ila th the victim cannot B be ove ota raddin by the th it three in lr r lne it BO 0 counted to prove hla theory theor y its use in dipsomania th statement made by sli it i li II id i a gizi li ill in n hot anni i I 1 in 0 t 1 1 ti I all a b v u d f flit tin tho ar i it 11 of if crair h it 1 1 0 a i b it i allt in til tb it it i dr A r it t i to cn c ro ton aon th doc all i 1 11 too i operated upon ali 0 iry ary irly arly ly ual 1301 i to th lor for all it 1 l ind for 15 alij J 1 purpose d b ht demon r 1 I 1 or 0 in the bl all latr at imp tinb nil anit lie a arr ti 11 al a all euba b t ti r ip p sd ad I 1 i the su BU inn 1 n of 0 c n i i bubli mon n ot of mr 1 at it li 11 li 1 1 i lii ill kloct t lut ill of et I 1 lh am all n 1 j ut tnt it hi ik i A ir I 1 c ciuti toll on in a I 1 i I 1 11 I 1 atla cot eudice abgill fill ahli a i it if tie tit cine n b 1 I ir kl 1 pt pi lii ili not 1 i 1 r I 1 th b ia ill all III 1 nir ant nl c nl at 11 hiim UP ma if 11 hi 1 he i lit lc r n iilma amab til I 1 v i dl I 1 n in i 1 i in lr 1 i al II 11 al 1 1 i i 1 ili the e c i ii 1 i 01 0 n A 1 h 11 ro he 11 i 1 h I 1 I 1 i if 11 a ai 0 tf i f i inal u pr 4 al I 1 i ir W wc C rl a c t aich i i an A n I 1 iiii 11 1 I 1 ap pp 1 r it il P pi i ith M 1 is 8 if f I 1 1 I 1 inaho n at ila Is if I 1 i I 1 I 1 I 1 N inc n I 1 i y r culini r 1 I li I 1 i AA tun i r SIT i I 1 1 il I u 11 II i r 11 T n it i i writ nt I 1 thi th li ig it i sull cup 1 it tt it to 1 i of not 1 I at R U it 11 IY y llad and A 1 tit lit nl ib E lilun throw throna I 1 d J rj ri r 11 of 0 nv talut it and li it f ir lii 1 I 0 in ti t end th bun bif I 1 rde dr r D mo if tatem 11 it a rl 1 i it 11 la afa 9 in n hla his aalt tit rr in n the ieves i it s of do bi i is 3 whom i i ne K 11 i AV I 1 i bt an uni lud n it II A 1 n h i 0 man i 4 11 nt at I 1 1 it fine conot at r 0 n or lis ili tl if i to t th putli T t 1 if ins ing paz par I 1 i ph ar i tit til r 11 i aito h I 1 tf 1 1 m nit mt t 11 II 13 1 i 1 1 i li it ui III ou in 1 i 1 chilla nh illa ur fit an ia ill 11 II 11 a LAIN ini cruthi truth i 1 t them th i i it 11 one ine shot sh alad i kid ild i pr ti tor to ton teti h ill h b i to 11 1 11 I i 1 it in it I 1 ui d adlaw law should p filat 11 of ii rill nil ti should III n tu to I 1 i tl ALI 1 n i it L k th ib law lam T u A it i il int ini ih vh I 1 kund ku nd it ja III it 11 ill tl I 1 ti ft A uld love intaj tl bl i A in iti um nt nl of 0 a de li fi air at noi R BY suggestion 1 l ImI who works tb u h the an thin hypnotism Is safe ro fit its selca itam i one on village life lie he vh j f fi end he then elk bh it his m in n the weapon Is no hj ti i it a knit th instrument of 0 the old time BU iiii ho worked rold with crude directness this ll 11 fin n do dc alec e dumerer choose choos lie picks out another nn mon a woman a little jle child ife HP my choose the lct let ms mg bt fric nd ild he may choose his very an acet A ti 11 1 I 1 II if i P I 1 r I 1 i I 1 b I 1 I 1 i 11 rn i 1 i I 1 I 1 h t I 1 tini lot I 1 1 I 1 in ba n v 1 h n li 1 1 in i 1 1 lr i iq 51 1 i 1 1 li r i lom lo m r jw at it li it dr ir I 1 TI t J I 1 in 11 tal rn ri und and tk t k arni the upper shelt of nc A 11 I 1 i 1 1 I 1 i i i n i 1 ID i v ill I 1 r t i I 1 r illi 1 1 tit i to 1 I al 11 1 i L alin an i I 1 i thi r I 1 hi it I 1 i it h b ciman nd J I 1 1 A i re ll it i i i ii hi III I 1 hi ignorant ot of tio ini am i n hit trim dy iby after tho tina fhe h ait if I 1 hr the E A 1 f liate no it or of hain hi ilni been nini nini at i a it IA i 1 tt 11 1 i a 1 pir iri a i A t i n i hut I 1 t to of if i 1 U 1 i ii 1 ind id Is i i 1 I nitus 1 i r th ih mail mah 11 1 1 til th ill bl d of th hi mur mitt i a m 11 1 11 r 1 ni b uro ure t i i ill inn i n nt r 1 fiilus ly y ln ind d 1 11 r i i it I 1 jali if c n nt an t I 1 v ith till n I 1 i h hi A nHim IN ill ff 11 ia in antl I 1 vi I 1 I 1 i ruth cuth ru cu th I 1 i intuit antum to s say A th 11 it I 1 f 11 ll it 1 ilist thi luthor of 0 tit tin artl 1 1 I ili id nn ni bitnes ed ait nc ac ilind eav in ril at li it rm 1 or a I 1 irson 1 baon 11 i 1 i E i flitt hi it kondi condition tion 1 p fl ilni i hn he I 1 i it ln i and conditi knit ind it ii ab I 1 1 1 1 1 tini niblo to mi it ii A blass tl 1 I ni it in 11 it IT non t plat p ia c i p ti ii ia ta n un li ill 0 of h za ill join at r go it in i t it too of ribs tit un i n clot 11 I 1 I 1 ir one like to ION lie at a i i un a li 11 th air fr er sug suggested geste 1 i I 1 y mr 1 I shall li it ali I 1 fr 1 ty y to lia an it r ill brition of tile ilio norin it net nat f tit i ulfat an aal 1 that I 1 zt infalt ri r tr t i place in la V hian i i it in n 1 r er to effect it th sug to ti i i abject th it he do tah Truth li i it in 1 li I ii li ii matui lly aly ini at ai hlo i i lii ill h lie he hw hart a natural ilon ion 1 11 ni r freo than tho i no I 1 I 1 sul KUI 11 m 1 i i under conditions i I 1 natal I 1 1 n 1 tn t n 1 1 list hat I 1 have I 1 jr I 1 to tr myself from ex CK lant in niro ahrn th n at a thousand intel I 1 1 T TING IN G EX experiments A few hi linfa will illustrate in the ho city ID ir r in ill 1 7 1 I had al a I 1 king la in i i it n nui U I 1 I 1 i it ct IN ito wait very i th I 1 1 i irtle tic suggestion and who her r i i tit 1 I I 1 tit very remark 1 la 11 1 real feat i in it A lill under the inabu i no nc B i i 1 ti it i of my bor ii fr ali I 1 1 I 1 to ill my own satis In incisi antin tin n it t i 11 I 1 n I 1 0 ii tu voli li ethor ether ovll evil be I 1 i i I 1 1 hi hi I 1 in the I 1 n nice qa t ian sees I 1 com cam minced c V i it 11 in I 1 licit hen she was in 1 in 1 non on ill arti ill iii tn in tu to undress she A tl 0 i nn in I 1 look off hir her outer i i ip p T r h it lifted and I 1 urged A ahr h nolan dmn ill it hr again she rei real uil ui 1 I lio ila tu ail make another move I 1 romill I 1 i I 1 again very sternly till nral she ahe refused and finally she bho il ii i I tillit 1 if I 1 did not cease trying to L oil nip I 1 her she would awaken seeing all tit was waa useless I 1 brought her ut or of the sleep and slip sho then told mo me A 1 i it andor no circumstances lances could she eho 1 i I 1 r I 1 submitted to my will iler her first tri ln alln ithon we was to follow the aln but immediately her own normal rf piL mance began to assort assert itself and erli ef lually counteracted the force of n MN command ii tin in another occasion with this same tiu lat I 1 placed a broomstick in one rr r nir and told her ber that it was a tramp coming toward her with no good designs de slena then I 1 placed a glass of water in her ter hand telling her it was a lighted lamp amp and bidding her to throw it at the it giamp amp with all her force sho she did as aa she was hidden bidden presently I 1 put her own brother in ili tile the place where the broomstick had stood placed it a burning lamp in her hand told her her brothers clothes were on tire nrc that she had bad a glass of water in her hand and ant that she should throw it nt at him to pu put t 0 ut III the tire fire the woman hesitated laughed went into hysteria hyster liz ind and finally into an epileptic nt fit from which it took me halt an hour to rouse HIT her W i li it i ird ruy 0 mon inn a 11 I 1 do id i i u e h b A 1 ti ILI t h n i 1 1 i it n i i 1 i 4 1 n I 1 r tr fr on ni J I 1 at I 1 t 1 I i 1 aftel adf I id id knife in to tn ll 11 hi tn 1 n 4 11 it I 1 I 1 fill an I 1 I 1 i I 1 lonii A it lr A r I 1 A 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 1 14 I 1 b 1 I hr mi vi 1 it fall 1 1 w kcf n 1 r r thi hirt she bv d th ahn n I 1 placed nl irad i r reil 1 steel knife in her hand and gave B S it to t 1 i I 1 i r ro rn n III H T r il VOLT ith th ahr i i rim hill nt ii tra TB in th ab in 1 ii 1 i 11 in me i 1 ti ii tit in r uhl u hl i 11 I 1 IA I 1 i tried led n n ali t it I 1 I 1 i t i ti in it I 1 i i 1 h I it alit reinli t t iiii in h 1 I 1 I 1 i I 1 i rii int lu here hen it 1 Is vr NII kin ki kl ti n inilla i 1 ili who are convi amm at N with ith IAN ps allian alliat a por per so arn if he e 1 I or c controlled nt rolled must tic be fully dwarn IN azerli that hr he or she in to bo be 1 ni nt 1 tl k 1 must give full fuh con nt it it I 1 i r till the concentration 1 i mind a i to produce hypnosis N hile hila th ill III II in of hypnotism Is a t i N I 1 i unit I 1 I 1 in it hits has been thor 1 atil Kt il dern deni on in rated that the hie only zabi I 1 1 1 t t of 0 it upon EL a person pernon who la 10 brought under its influence Is to be numb or temporarily render inactive till th voluntary portions por tlona of the brain so that a subject does docs not proceed ot of his big own oti original ginal volition that fact act won nvere enough in itself to tc dIr disprove dl prove the possibility of 0 the sexual crime arinie the tha moro more important ot of it ho however mever Is that an a it roana mans natural actions are governed yo verned by his previous or eff ul for or them so BO in hypnosis when for or the time being the hypnotist supplies the voluntary direction for or the subject tile the mans action stilt cannot RO go beyond his big own nornia normal equipment and predisposition just as a machine which Is constructed construct el to run in one manner cannot be made to run rina in another so 0 o with tho the human mind while the doctor was waa reading ncr this portion at 0 his big manuscript one of 0 ills hll subjects entered tho the statements of 0 sir mr Mars marshall marscall ball and ot of dr do de monco were read to him and hewan asked it lie ile thought ho he could be made to commit a crime while under tile of f hypnotism ile he replied ill promptly in the negative paying emphatically 1 I guess fuess not A hypnotized person still has hag all ills his lorail sellers derosen about hinn him at least I 1 do and knows tho the difference between right and wrong up mr marshall further pays that a person committing it a crime under hypnosis would have no recollection ot of the action I 1 deny that statement in toto for or na as sald said above I 1 have yet to met find my first patient n whom consciousness Is completely abolished also I 1 have yet to find my first patient who did riot not remember all that was said bald and done each act commanded each suggestion made the more mora I 1 experiment tho the more I 1 am convinced that there them la Is no ouch euch thing under hypnosis as complete unconsciousness I 1 am aware that the memory of what has occurred may be rather hazy or faint but a total non recollection I 1 deny sextant Sex tu the great chicago hypnotist rays bays the th Is in not a mere automaton to be moved about at pleasure to io make the hypnotic suggestion otherwise it cannot be carried loutit must not be forgotten that the execution ot at the tion alon depends entirely on the disposition of 0 the subject which does not alter but remains tile the same asleep or awake 1 I cite from statements made by the tha well known professor mires of prance france when ordering hypnotic andl ideals to lo execute certain sets acts after their awak ing is disagreeable to them or causing their heir displeasure they would simply re fuse use to obey and would not bo be awak enod enca till released should the hypnotist remain firm or insist upon the belne being carried out it would become impossible to awaken them while professor subjects ni lie doubt acted as above I 1 have always had exactly opposite results sly MY subject have always and without exception refused to comply or rather to accept my suggestion they have answered me that they would not do as aa ordered would awaken it 1 I 1 insisted and nil one in particular said my power d did III not reach so BO far r as aa that HAVE A DUAL consciousness hat at shown to mo me car conclusively inclusively that III III subjects subject hay have a a dual i u n ro BO to speak peak I 1 have i 1 1 i t nil in it alnut out to fifty other sub j binl 1 I it in it ii mid vory one tho the r it it v r rj I 1 hi to t imi tit to place it pd on under hypnosis Is you yen must hilt his undivided RL attention nl nd the environments must be perfect h must do and think precisely as you y ical it him bilm without mental reservation and na even then aou ou cannot succeed in 1 more titan than four cases camps in ten fill hard work at that A tiernan person readmit reading tho 11 bicle of if mr lr Af amarshall arshall anti not cidne conversant with hypnotism would think that all a person had to do wit was to single out some ono one most moat applicable to his purpose and then by his big uncanny power poirer compel that PC pernon roon to commit any crime on the calendar let us tie suppose ft caw case A person conversant with hypnotism desires it to commit a crime with the laid of oc bilm as allf kal by mr air marshall in what manner would lie he be compelled to proceed first hi he would have to select his victim second select his a subject bill and right there then endless fr trouble ble would occur third tha th subject will mill it be a compelled to geve 51 IS consent to belne being hypnotized while in a normal condition this act alone on the part ot at the subject would mould make him the subject a party to tho the crime or rather nn na accessory before the fact the th sub subject j beet under hypnosis must then be criven the so called post stiff clift by this thin 1 Is meant that the hypnotist commands the subject to commit the c rime crime at a certain date in the future eleven years practical experience per peri fence ence has taught me the fallacy of this assumption let us analyze first the hypnotist or the person who ife siras to commit the crime must get the tha willing consent of the person to ho he made the tool that Is 1 difficult AS aa only about one person in live who mho gives IAN or her tree free and milling consent can be hypnotized hy by the most expert hypnotist secondly the subject must be placed under the influence several times in a preparatory way ivey before the final or compulsory suggestion I 1 la made maae immorality iny thirdly it if crime anil and immoral immorality wie not a part of the subjects normal character the suggestion to lo commit it a crime would startle and strike the subject as a severe blow and a decided recollection of the suggestion will remain when the subject Is awakened and let me here repeat my own ideas and belief ones more that absolute unconscious does not occur no matter how flow deep the sleep or for what trivial purpose produced pro duwa fourthly tho the posthypnotic acts only at its best twenty tour four to thirty six hours after the hypnosis at aich which it was made and at al a eel certain tain time mind this a certain time riot not a certain week or ft certain day that will not answer and when the set net time arrives the subject will go eo under hypnosis although the hypnotist Is 13 riot not present the pupil of tho the eye will ivill dilate respiration will increase and the subject will chink and act no aa an automaton all movements win will be b machinelike machine like in character and should the subject be on the tha street or public thoroughfare the people meeting him would consider him inebriated or crazy tind and the first patrolman would escort him to the police station 2 mr fr Mar marchalls marshalls Marsh aUa representations representation are based largely u upon on dr luksas nn an au the g best qt evidence I 1 have that the authority to la unreliable Is at a recent incident in the paris charity hospital in which dr luys became the laughing lau 9 h stock block of 0 hl hla 9 f fellow C ila doctors I 1 in n a an n experiment which he voluntarily produced as a phenomenal evidence of the clairvoyant power of hypnotism taking several drugs like ipecac strychnine lobelia lo belli and others and sealing them hermetically in bottles he placed them upon the foreheads of persons under the influence of hypnosis end and called attention to the tact |