Show i COUNCILMAN PAINE ALSO FOUND GUILTY rl Jury I. I Sustains Charges of Collecting Col Cot r Illegal Fees and Ous Ousting Will m Fol Follow ow NOT DERELICT IN DUTY l r r J j Did No Xul i t ern lo to Perform 11 Work I tk f Scores cn s 's A noil KM- KM I Ic Victory Victorya O I a n at I Junction J f. f I J fri lIt Republican 1 Bureau ill th U l Og Ogden elt Sept Councilman Robert Rob noll- i ert B. B Paine Paille of or the First ward arii like Councilmen CI Chambers s and Craig was if tonight found guilty of at charging and collecting af fees from ruin the Iho cli city as alleged In III the hc complaint brought i against them by Attorney J J. J I D Skeen a. a tt and will vIii receive c the sentence of the court on Oct 10 which will undoubtedly un Un- 4 be he removal Ilmo from office ontee s The cafe CRill eaino 1 to 0 a sudden termination tormina- tormina tion this morning when the attorneys u. u for for the plaintiff and ancl defendant agreed 1 r upon a n. statement of fact facts which aret are arc t practically the same samo ns as tho the t h. h brought out In th the tho Chambers and Craig oases cases and t Iho court tool took t th Lii h. h t- t matter under advisement m nr until 4 oJ o'clock when it delivered Its Us Instruction uc tion to lo the jUl- jUl jury The fhe jury jUf In III tho the cas caAl t consisted o of the following Collo David Javid s Farr hoary Newey M. M B. B Richardson B. B S 'S S. S Stone Ston W. W T. T 1 Stoker Ambrose AmbroS i. Hill F F. W. W Foster and A. A E. E Shaw I list run to The fhe courts court's Instructions to to the tic jury f ore tero to the l guilty of ch charging r and collecting illegal fees feos as asti ti all g ged 11 in n th the Iho complaint and accusation C lIsa lIsa- tion non flied filed Further thier Instructions w were cre rc to find th the tho defendant not guilty guilt of oC re refusing reo re- re the tue theIo o fusing and neglecting to perform Io duties p pertaining to 10 hl his I of oC councilman The Tho court furnished furnished fur fur- th the tho jury JUI a blank verdict and fk till that was n necessary cc ry to make moke it corni comi complete com corn i i pleto was th the tho election Ion of a foreman olman 2 1 by by- bythe tilt the jul jury and antI the tho affixing of or his sigI sig- sig I J which was complied with after jt i the Iho jury JUI had been out for or only a a. few ow minutes The verdict of or the Jury Is as follows We Wc 0 tho the Jury Impaneled nelll In the above e cut entitled I tied action find the tue defendant Robert Robert Rob Rob- ert crt K R. Paine guilty of charging and amI collecting from Ogden elt City Illegal fes as aa alleged In the complaint and ancl sat patton Ion sled filed heroin herein we find Hi th issues Joined as Ill to the chat charges o ot of charging and collecting from Ogden CIl City illegal fees foos In hi favor favol of the tiLe Ji plain plaintiff tiff and against the tue defendant that r charges cs of oC charging and collecting ii 11 Il Illegal legal fee fees as us alleged in the complaint and accusation filed herein have ha been the llio defendant Ve e e further find 1 Robert Hobert II n. not nul guilty lIllIy ut of lefus l-elIs- ing irig arid and neglecting to 10 perform the tue official of ue- duties to his office of r j ell councilman of or O Ogden Llen CIl City us ns 11 ii JQ Jeg d ll in Ill the lite complaint and accusation 1 Jl 1 herein we wc find the thc lueil Imoh in Incur i i defendant and lh the tIl plaintiff plain r tiff suit ami that ibal the thc r charges charged contained In Inthe inthe the complaint and accusation filed f. f herein of refusing anil neglecting to the tue official duties pertaining p perform 1 j 7 l to his office of city councilman of Ogden City have not Deco sustained W. W Foreman tr r. r P P. Foster Similar In to Other Ca Cn cs tS The ease case was similar to th the tho Craig anti and Chambers cases caKes in every respect o that Mr Ir Paine resigned from rom 1 the thc council shortly after charges had f been preferred against him by Attorney 4 nd nc ney Skeen n in order I to circumvent enl the time h. h allegations and was Immediately rei rc- rc i J f appointed by the council to succeed himself the thc remaining Councilman Moyes foyes councilman against whom charges 8 V wore were rc also handed In his c resignation al at the tho same time as 38 did thU thUL t. t Councilman Paine Paine- and anti wa was also alKo re- re J. J appointed Ills ii case uro will follow the tho ii 1 Paine case as Attorney 1 has al ali already al- al i ready remy tiled filed Information against him |