OCR Text |
Show TIIE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE, SUNDAY MORNING, AUGUST tincuon between British and continental feeling. Therefore it U totally impossible now for the British government, at the moment when actual payment must-begito interpose a refusal or even to ask for a further postponement. There Temains only the moral road. If British statesmanship can succeed in establishing In the eyes of the world and In thq eyes of the American people ths conviction that the course pursued by the American congress Is ungenerous, oalculating, even rather Immoral, then the pressure of world sentiment and, of domestic sentiment may yet avail to persuade ths American people to lift from Brit sh to American shoulders the weight of the burden that must be carried. If there le to be a return to normal condi. rtione in the world, When the British undertook at Washington to coerce the French Into acceptIs ing their view of the submarine matter, &reat their first step was to achieve the isofj must lation of France. Now everyone skillfuve that the Balfour note very Cancel, Hoping perce, I' the lly-but yery completely Isolates are United States. TVe, and we alone, because Follows for evil, everything Lead, responsllde f wiiile generous Britain would cancel in a moment, ehe cannot because we won't Now. I am not discussing ths merits of the cancellation question at ths mo1 am trying to make clear the ment. Lloyd cleverness with which British diplomacy is attempting to achieve Its ends. What as Meaning the British owe ua Is real monev, because It can be collected and wilt be paid, if ask It. What Britain's allies owq here of All Slates. Iswe confederate .Wiping money, or rather no money at all, because her allies neither can nor will pay It ever under any circumstance. As for her German and Russian claims, BY FRANK H. 61 MONOS. . i' does not want to collect ths one, ' she and knows she cannot collect the other, llvrtirf- - I The Tribune. Washington, Aug, 12. no American U, S. Would Hold Sack. vptt followed closely the prepress of th You ran put the thing quite simply If V'mhlngton conference should be epy. say that, bv offering to cancel all PH bed at the character of the recent you owes her, if we will cancel that Uatfnur note. The maneuver here I what F.urope she owes ua, the British are petirpvlsqly that used against the French ting up nothing and asking ua to put up almost five b'lJons of dollars. And And against the American naval since the disparity Is pretty patent, they In the matter of the submarine, are undertaking to cover the thing bv an t;1b an effort to coerce the American appeal to morals and to sentiments. They administration and the American con- are holding up to the United States the cholee between accepting responsibility gress by an appeal over their heada to for world chaos which Is materially much ' tjijf; mass of the people. worse for the British than for us, and the eaae of The aubmarine, the Britt canceling a'debt of five billions when the British can pay,, have promised to pa jar 'objective was plain. The war had but quite obviously would like to av bhoin that Great Britain waa vulnerable; paying, Note, again, however, the ' singular Fht; had almost lost the war as a re. fashion in British the which in employ fnlt: of the undersea attack and might case the argument they have steadhiw lost it had the United States failed this criticised the French for employing ily 1 Intervene. But, aside from Britain cannot cancel in EuIn snother. British mastery of European waters was rope because ehe has to pay in America, tnidenlable. ths burden of ell the French was necessary, then, to forbid the but there is France tU .cannot agree to a reargument. tine of the submarine by all nations to In Oerman reparations because Insure British security and European au. duction States. Moreto the has she pey Both our naval experts and over, while she doesUnited jeemacy. not intend to pay , th"ne of France took a different view of Britain, her claim upon Germany ia- -a pat tonal ofinterests, therefore all the Br.tish propaganda waa turned auppoa tltloua one as ' set against this lobse to stampede American opinion and auppos.tttloua liability, rouse American sentiment against the America Singled Jrftnch. I Now. note what the situation la today, If rhe Balfour note hears the name of The British have some eight or ten the former prime minister. It t ciearly of dollars owed them from their in spirit a Lloyd Georgian work and Balthe British jslUes and around seven billion owed by four la merely employed,-a- s Germany a little less than twenty b press suggests, because Ms recent visit In all and they owe the United In Washington has given him access to rtigtes upward of five billions. There Is the American public, who wlU accept hla not! the smallest chance on earth that word more easily than that of any other thef can collect from Russia, Italy, Briton. But Lloj d George has always Brahe or Belgium, and every sensible believed from the da of the Baris coniKngiishman admits tills fact in private ference onward that sooner or later IctuiVeraatlnn. London and would meet Washington from Germany, the cancellation would come. If you go back I AS to collecting whole desire of British statesmanship Is to the original Keynes book, which creto. Avoid collecting German ooligatlons, ated sueh a stir at the time both In both because these could only be met by America and Europe (but for different porinents in goods which Britain cannot reasons), you will find that at the botafford to accept, and because Insistence tom of all hla reasoning was the ason payment would tend to postpone the sumption that the Unted States would restoration of the German market, which cancel what she had lent to them and Hu Vital to British industrial interests. then go on lending again. If you had followed the British LibCancellation One Point. eral press and Ha piore distinguished British policy, therefore, had three ob- writers, you would have found that at jectives' To abolish the burden of allied bottom they, like Keynes, have toalways solve relied upon American cancellation debt which postpones general trade to accomplish this without Brlt- - the riddle. You m'ust see the thing from canwe If dont British the standpoint. a expense, thing only possible if Afakrlea-ahould pay. Thcf payment will cancel the British debt, cel. they must awkward alto manager, be exceedingly procure the sweeping reflnHy no pains Therefore possible. duction of German reparations. The key though ua ' 'whole situation, moreover, was must be spared to persuade , British ability to persuade the United Views Opposed. States to cancel allied debts, and, above all, the British debt to us. ' .And, after all. this Is only a repetition 'th British situation In this of the maneuver over reparation. Brit!put was rendered a bit difficult bv the ain' want reduced because, reparations ri tuple-fathat, while no other Euro- unt'l the problem ie eliminated, the Brit-i- h pean oountry can pey. not only Is there must eufifer erueUy from unemploytvo .doubt as to British capacity, but that ment. But France instate that ehe mint capacity has been steadily emphasised in be paid end this means that Britain ft wit months and British atateamen have must either find a way to coerce the merit In America French or else must make such concesby proclaiming that Great Britain would sions to them as would be embarrasPUT, thua establishing a valuable die- - sing and expensive, perhaps as embar- Britain, It Would f America Argued, Georges Interpreted Attitude 1 ' 'fti , thla-deta- ll, ry . Out 51 ct ct Wt rasslng and expensive as the payment te us of the five billions. British diplomacy, as Is its right and duty, must, then, seek to get out of piesent difficulties by putting tbs largest possible share of tne burden upon the shoulders of the United States and of France. This would be accomplished if France, without other compensation, should, agree to the reduction of German reparations and the United States should agree to the cancellation of the BrtLeh loan and The rest of the allied loans, as well. It will be clear that this is a pretty stiff dose to persuade France and the United States, respectively, to swallow. It can only be achieved if It can be established that morals are involved end if the moral sentiment of the world can be aroused. Yet this has not proven an Impossible task. American opinion has been successfully aroused against Frepch militarism, now ths Balfour nots, quite as obviously, undertakes to rouse European sentiment against American- And it is not a difficult thing, aftnr all, to a rouSe' debtors against a creditor, since even under the best of must seem creditors otreumstanoes, exigent. Maneuver Designated. As I see It. then, the Balfour note represents a characteristic British maneuver, It places the United States In a difficult position. It makes us Appear to the world almost Immoral that ws refuse to cancel a British obligation to pay us five billions of dollars, which, be it always understood, the British ere ready to pay If we ask, because It puts us In ths position toward ail ether European Slates of preventing them from obtaining a remission of debts from Britain, as well as from ourselvea in all this cleverness, however, there IT is all very well for Is one limitation. Itord Balfour to shake h s head sorrowfully and say that the Atnertean attitude makes British cancellation impossible, but this does not make French, Belgian os Italian payment, let alone German and Kuaslan, one bit more likely. You have to remember that ths only real money In tbs whole transaction from first to last is that which the British owe us. Neither we nor the British ere going to get anything (com the other nations associated with ua In the war with Germany. Therefore, as e practical matter, the BaWour note changes nothing and advances nothing. It would not have been Issued, I believe, if there had not existed In England and precisely in Lloyd Geodges mind, a lingering hope that the American attitude could bis modified by an astuta attack such as wss mads by Mr. Balfour upon the atand of our. naval experts and advisory committee on the submarine during the Washington conlerenca. Some Hope Nourished. If you glance at the comments of those newspapers which sneak for Lloyd Georgs In Britain, you will perceive that they all cherished the same hope. I have never met an Englishman who did hot. In the back of his mind, cling te this notion, which had its origin, in the private conversations of Paris. Cancellation was precisely the thing that Europe expected of ths United States, because Paris gave Europe a certain notion of ths United States, and Europe In general and England in particular has been wait-Ip- g for that gesture ever since. Conceivably, the response in thlw country to the Balfour note will destroy this Illusion. At all events It will erase from the present calculation any reliance upon America In this respect. Once this is and it must be Elsin to Lloydhe George will have to make a new time, combination, and the only possible combination Is the erasure of the allied debts owed Britain. Of course, the difficulty Is that once these are gone there disappears the only argument which cnuld be used to persuade the United States to cancel the British debt. That Is the sole value to the British of the existing obligations. Yet In practice It is going to be very difficult for the British to maintain the Balfourian thesis that similar liberality must be displayed toward German debtors on the one hand and allied on the other. To propose to cancel what Ger many owes Britain, but to hold France, Italy and Belgium to pay to Britain in the aggregate enough to enable Britain to meet her American obligations, Is not to excite enthusiasm in Paris. Rome or Brussels. Such a gesture is all right for a an Inconceivable, British d plomacy first Isolate its opponent. then mobilise world sentiment against the culprit, snd finally awaits which carries or defiance a repentance with It precisely that condemnation which overtook France ae a consequence of her attitude on the submarine In Washington. Much less than a year ago all of the United States was foaming with indignation because the French refused to consent to the total abolition of the one navsl weapon which might conceivably make attack upon Great Britain possible. Today moat of Europe Is equally furious with the jnited States because It refuses to agree Wo forgive the British debt of five billions of dol.ara which Britain can have intimated pay, since the British that, if America would cancel, they would cancel what Europe cannot pay. What the American people did not perceive during the submarine episode In the Washington conference was that they were being maneuvered, that ihq.r Idealistic emotion over submarine warfare waa being capitalised to serve the very material interest of Brittah security and supremacy. But now they perceive that precisely the same machinery le being employed to put them before France as was employed over here to put France before the American people. British Art Excels. AH of which is perfectly fair playing, according tef diplomatic traditions. If you hav. a lawyer gad a lawsuit you expect your counsel to make the best of your cose before the Jury am the worst of that of your opponents. The supreme art of British diplomacy is that it can always find a moral issue to hang on the other fellow. No matter If the thing at issue Is the most material of considerations, In soma odd fashion a moral principle will sooner or later appear and invariably coincide with British interest. W a are not blng ta cancel the British debt or the continental debts, but we hall have to take the responsibility for all that happens In Europe now, because the British have solemnly deposited that burden upon us and lefLthe single mean of the transfer from British to our shoulders of five billions of debt. Ail we have to do to regain moral standing is to accept the burden although now, thanks to the Balfour an note, tom of the credit would naturally belong to the authors of that revelation of our moral obliquity which brought us to repent. ance. Forecasts are pretty futile at present, but my guess is that when the British have demonstrated by the present note that there ia not the smallest chance of American cancellation, they will settle down to paying us and at the same time they will undertake the wiping out of the mass of interallied debts m Europe with acorreepondu.g reduction In the German leparatlons. There iff nj other solution, snd this Is only in part a solution. Ultimately the United States will have to deal with hor loans to countrlti which lave no other way of .paying u . . save In German bond. esi-ap- coouv i X Second Week yuci Nashua Woolnap Blankets at Less Than Last Years Price The standard of quality, these famoiia blanket below usual price for thle sale. (All cotton.) Plaid Woolnap Blankets . priced wav . At $4.00 Pair grey and tan wool nap blankets, with very attractive colored border. Size 60x70, pair Size 66x80, pair Size 72x74, pair Sise 72x80 grey wool nap blanket wUh Uret' Ire?1 . to r $4.25 ....,$5,00 Fixe 88x80 At $4.25 Pair 1 -- In broken plfld effects; sise 70x80; different color combinations. X. Plaid Blankets, Pair, $14.40 TF you intend buying clothes, for fall and want them at cut prices, now is the time-t- he end is drawing nearer and hearer. GRIFFITH ESCAPES CASEMENTS FATE satln-boun- J REDUCTIONS TERRY - DRAPERIES 28 inch reversible heavy In material charming designs and color com-- binatlone suitable foe windows, floor hangings and art work "regular i.00 yard CERTAIN 8CRIM The toned heavy quality 28 Inches wkle made in white, cream and 'Arabian shades suitable for long ' , pnd short -- old-fas- furtains, yd,., r - Your Clothes for Fall Will Cost You Less Mill-tori- Bise 70x80; have blue, rose, yellow and lavender plaids These are cut singly and finished with white d ends. Drapes AT SUMMER I hs. FANCY CRETONNES Broken lines and part bolts from our regular stock 31 to IS inch.s wide a'i underpriced for a clearaway a splendid assortment to choose from regular 88c to 79c 1 yard, yd. CROSS BARRED SCRIM 81 inches wide strong, serviceable for long and short curtains IvC whit only, jd ifl. x ed ST. MARYS BLANKETS Plaid Wool Blankets Pair, $8.75 J art pdallr The most attractive plalda many different combinations from which may choose. .,...$3.50 18.75 COUipaTiy of tlie original items continued at sale prices .nslicre quantities were sufficient to carry over 'and with many new specials added. a11 Si Now Gardner Adams i'ti - Suits Greatest August Sale of Blankets At f Our Regular $25 Suits ,Hats, Shoes, Shirta, Hosiery, Underwear, etc., of quality, at exceptionally low cut prices await you here. Better come in make it soon. here are new opportunities for the 4 K if you take advantage now of the few remaining days of our SALE. It has been a great Blanket Sale and i Last Gall for. aie ii If we decline to do that, then the situation may drag Indefinitely, but one that the only thing is certain, and that money which will change hands will ba what the British pay us and some little, which the Germans under menace, may I pay the French and the Belgians. shall return next week to the discussion of reparations and the European aspects of the recent British declaration of policy, but In the present article I we anxious to make clear precisely what British diplomacy la aiming at wjith respect of the United States and how similar thl maneuver Is to the treatment Pf France In the Washington conference. For a long time to come we are going to suffer as a consequence of our failure to measure up to that moral with the standard which the British, Interested approval of the rest of the world." has set for us, unless by chancs we shall see the evil of our ways and cancel In which case we may divide with the British the credit for this generous action, by the rimple device of paying all of the cost for, as I have said again and again, save for what Britain owes us, all other international accounts are Juet uttermost farthing. stage money to theIndication of the true The best single British attitude in the matter of their debt to us. which I have ever had. came from a distinguished Englishman, who. In tbs course of a lecture in this country made declaration to his audience th. familiar "Of course we shall pay you every cent we owe, every cent. And do you know, he told a friend Others Have Ideas. In tones of amased In this situation you can well imagine afterward, In the hall lust got anguish up and everyone that Baris. Berne and Brussels will say Cheered!" Whit he had quite obvlouahly quits politely that the British should can- hoped for wss a spontaneous outburst on cel their obligations and mark down ths ths part of the audience against any such German reparations that U, the British transaction. Yet although he made many shars, to the point where It balanced the . tetec Trials b ne'er failed to rouse the American debt. enthusiasm.What the British have got to do, aonoer gamh positively devastating or later end perhaps It Is already too (Copyright, 1932. by the McClure News-pap' late Is to face the fact that they must Syndicate ) pay us, and that they can only bring about a reduction of the total of German reparations by procuring the consent of the allies to write off the ambunt which would correspond to their debts to Brit aln. In a word, the British have got to pay America and cancel the debts of their allies. In Europe they will here to face the fact that their allies regard the questions of reparations and debt as inseparable. In America they will have to ap that we see no .eon predate the fact neetton. So far I have discussed only the practical side; there remains, of course, still another aspect. If we insist on payment, Csattnoed from Fag Oa the British are going to pay. Since we do Insist, ths payment will come, and Utah will now Clothing Store be probably arrangements mads with very little delay. But the effect of culminated en December 5 with the signBritain between Great our Insistence will be felt for a very long ing of th treaty time to coma. I do not believe that It is and Ireland. possible to exaggerate the amount of unbetween difference fundamental A expressed reeentment which will result. Eamonn d Vafcra and Griffith In their Given the present British situation, political views has been marked since the nothing on earth could Justify a quarrel InrerAion of th republican movement. beor anything approaching a quarrel While De Valera has stood uncomproSALT LAKE CITY WARNS BUILDING tween the two nations. The British ne- misingly for absolute Independence, Grifcessity for friendly relations with us Is fith, with Collins, held to the view that too obvious to require discussion, and the rvatem of Irish freedom typified by this necessity will remain unchanged for the Free State treaty was the beet for tong time to coma. Yet the kind of the Irish nation. The two factions worked friendly relations which would have been together In all matters until the Ango-frist- v ore!bie under other ciroumstancee will conference waa cAlied, when their tardly be conceivable when we have col- divergent view came into open conflict, lected our debt in a spirit which is st the with the result that even with the treaty . least uncompromising. ratified by vote, warfare against us execution continues between the republicans U. S. Refuses. and th Free Staters. Griffith was never a republican In the strict meaning of the periences ag s youth Iff th South African 1918, in s pamphlet bearing th title and other European countries win be Two week ago In writing here I pointto Irish politics. "The Slav Mind," wss; gold min'ng country. dragged in with her. and Franc will not ed out that the American iioalttnn would word aa applied "The slave mind has been th ban of eecape, it compels th conclusion T certainly ws fool," he ws a r that shortly become very unattractive, when Grieved. In Is for men tne It the root of Ireland, th for fng, camp mining very George every Europe is prepared to sacrifice everyit was demonstrated the! our refusal to Joyd which has reduced thing to annihilate Germany, to have the knack of making s lack of .armed cancel the debts of our associates was LONDON, Aug II (By the Associated the stateliest race In Europe th Gaels . Tb English press hsa carefully avoidexcept myself. On man " largely responsible for the failure of Eu- press) The prime minister Mr. Lloyd fortune this point two rowdies darted from to what they are today. It has destroyed ed retaliation to th aggressive ton of rope to liquidate the German problem. George, MuhaeF Collins, theAt shadows. has telegraphed our moral courage. We are Irish- th French newspapers. Tb men At of One of them doliberately Confirmation of this forecast is suppl ed head of the Irish provisional government, men. Our to our off his demands into French country the Griffith, knocking duty bv ths Balfour nots, which was a plain recogpolicy is hi deep distress on learning bumped word. He us to regain Ireland's national and po- nised. In view of th universally hat Orifi.th never said effort to exploit the situation and coerce expressing rejection by th of the death of Arthur Griffith. hie hat and put It on again. litical liberties, snd 'until England ha experts of the French proposals, up us by arousing against America the senpicked can the s Mr. LJovd George telegram said; The rowdy knocked It off the second restored them England remains Ireland's entente survive? It Is not a question of timent of the world and against congress ' and uttered an insult. Still Grif- enemy." My admiration' for hla single-mindtime a of difference but the idealistic sentiment In the United patriotism, whether procedure, his ability, sincerity and cour- fith held his tongue. He removed his the comity of European nations can be b tale.. age, has grown steadily since I mstriilm eve glasses, tucked them In A poo It -- t and restored or Europe, beyond the Rhine, be What has been amusing about the first lees thaw a year ago. His character a the rowdy came back the third time, administered as a subject territory. The present episode ha been American be- made a deep Impression upon the British Issue is nakedly apparent,' and th hour wilderment, growing in the main out of ministers who shared with him in those atiuck but. squarely on the clun, sendOf compromise is past. the fact that we have regarded the whole unremitting labors In which he was called ing him sprawling In the gutter, Griffith then placed his glseseg on hla If Franca now enforces her will she question of cancellation as settled and upon to play aueh a tasting and difficult snd as If there had been aj InAs in th occupation of have refused even te consider the posMfts alone. rt. HI toes will fall heavily on Ireland, nos, to his Of addoi. Duesseldorf A cancellation. story, and Duisburg, she out her Irritaterruption certain sibility tut I trust his work will go on to com cleaned up 10,000 pounds in n single and embarks on an adventure the tion there has been, ever the obvious plot success. painter fact that we were being placed In an unseek. end of which none can foretell. sh is strong and powerful. Her attractive light. On the whole, the average American ha felt, quit correctly, army, especially in Afrioan troop, Is YORK NEW, In some or lea more enormous. Her equipment of airplanes obscure fashion tint an attempt wa being made to maneuver gives her practically a monopoly on the him against hla will and to make him continent. She has spent large sums for glv up something which wae rightfully military railways sine the war and has from Pag Oe Conti. NEW YORK, Aug 18 (Bv Associated NEW YORK, Aug. 12. New of th hts own or else stand convicted of a aU declined disarmament overtures. Press ) Arthur Griffith would have been death In Dublin today of Arthur Griffith, se'fUh and even immoral act. Through her diplomatic activity she haa t Sir with la Roger Casement, executed one of the founder of Sinn Fein and shown that the In general, this country feel that th a of network states under secondary policy of bludgeoning had It not been for the fact that president of th Dali Elresnn, was retroubles of Europe are due to the delib- said, waa a mental Sinn ceived with dismay by Irishmen In New Germany is fatal to the recovery of French Influence snd her effort, In All considered erate refusal of F.urope to follow Amer- he are directions astounding. not did and advocate publicly York The belief was expressed by many debts. French financiers know this as ican advice and to abandon policies and Felner Franc in Europe Is more domibelieved in th prlnt-n- g that his passing had taken Ireland well st th English, Amsrican snd Ital- nant than today ambition which make war and postpone thyslcal force. Hothan any power since th days of the machine gun. one of its greatest fighters from pres rather for freedom recon.tiuctlon. Therefore It is not only ian. Insistence on more bludgeoning in- Napoleon. England is anxious to avoid Griffith was taken Into custody after and from the Free State government one dicates novel, but a little provoking to have th that th political motives grp in an appearance of suspicion, hut th faots. and th physical of Us most courageous leaders. Balfourian not proclaim to th whole th arrest of Casement are assuming a disquieting significance in th sscsndancy. who had a port In The force advocate of both the republican and world in unmistakable language that th Advocates the face of th present proposals. affair. He wa triad and Free State movements Joined In expresstesponslhilitv for Europe e present and gackvin street W await th developments of the next Threatened. Rupture court believing It not proven ing sorrow at Griffith demise. They prospective misery le American refusal to the military few days with deep concern, but I am rethat he had any actual part In the declared that his tearhings and hts Works Disintegration and the economic ruin Informed cancel loan. there still exists hop that bellion. ordered hia deportation to Eng- had inspired all Irish leaders and that of Germany spell ruin to the hopes of a formula that can be devised which will tide land for one year. would carry on for him. recovery of British trad. Is Erupand to us over th immediate they Opponents Isolated. crisis. A as wa known man.Vho Griffith Men who were Intimate with Griffith be ruined tn order that France should Y'st if our people were a little more fanever tot hla temper. before tho birth of the Sinn Fein recalled crush Germany 7 Fursuit of this pollry V. MUSICIAN miliar with the workings of British diAn anecdote Illustrative of this trait was some of the interesting chapters of his can have only one result the rupture of 6URIED. British and French relations. , related recently by James Stephens, Irish life. plomacy, or willing to sten to any conJlpeetsl t Th Tribes. tinental European statesman, they would novelist and poet. menace this For many years h edited a newspaper has for England fought MOAB. U. The body of John know that, in some not quit clear fashOn evening, so the story goes. Often It was suppressed by ths British three jeers, yielding to Fra nr on vital Bailey, whoAug died tn Scofield test week, ion, 'any nation which has something the phtn and Griffith had dined in the lit- government, but, undlsmsved, Griffith measures te plnoato ner, and shutting her was taken to his home In Montireilo for British desire or could do something tle restaurant in Dublin, in whose coffee continued its publication, changing its eyes to th significance of the FYencn burtsL Mr. was a musician and whi h would serve a British Interest, room the Sinn Fein waa born. Aftername after each suppression, fie con- action. Poincare a proposals lead to the may year Bellry of hts Iif were spent in finds Itself left te ehooee between servseveral with of wards, (heir friends, tinued this for fifteen year an j hi pa- parting of th ways England ran travel work, Some years ago h wa em- ing British Interest th road to ruin no further. If Germany j confessing crime they strolled leisurely up Grafton street per had that many names. music In the Mcab to bn aroused and On of his utterances, prints Yi May, follow,, Austria into ths quagmir, Italy echiooU. mpathetio world. ' and Griffith began taiklng'of hla x. er ,;-,- -- Inevitable Stated. - 6000 13, 1922. S', J ad ly HEARS NEWS WITH REGRET X |