Show cITY OFFICIAL J AS BULLDOZER Assistant City Attorney Appears In This Role Rolo According To Affidavit STIFF REPLY Iii Id Wit In Iti tn In Set St MM Mil irm t liHt t 1 I taken James Ingebretsen the 0 whom wom If It J brought broucht r i in I ne erve a ftp all t for his hla 1 I In falling tailing to 10 take alvan nl hl legal right in the damage the th city a very short abort abortS S j f r time lo to prepare a II Ift reply rpy i II ir I In hi a lIerl chart charge the hI city It attorney ply make maka ma a much more mo Ogden lUlu man mun than man made against Ingebret f I IC f that he hf h hue has used the pre Draa pret pr t 0 1 l power of at the city V C office me a 1 aa a ft club over the head bead t to fore force him to 10 take in lit action The Th dub club wa we raised I l h form of or threat that thet If II carried Oil OMI M have bae had a erlon ruit It II UI n MI II future 1014 f I 1 in J II i my could have ba p wielded tbt tb I t i I h he In r p ii t the throat I r harp rte U 11 a contained in the fol tol toli folI i t f language from Mr Ingebret S ply filed flied In n the Third t tr r stated that thai If It I i i the II he be would ic ichy i 1 ihy hy h forever refusing to 10 do me any an anI i OE 11 I show how me mp m An Ourt and nn M f 1 me mu b the bar a all ac an III rt riI fIr HI TO WAKE VAKE HIM Th Thi trouble Is over or n II I damage dama tilt null ull ullI led t I the oily city lIy by b Oen 0 I Hein Hem n being hl hll hie lawyer A Ant Awa Aj J nt was wea wa rendered lId l In Herndon M Mand i not vo n and Dininny let the time Urn tor f th r ep p pal I J al a ii I II pp me Now lila lili hi flied filed II comes come forward trying 10 to roo th Ih blame on nn tot for toro tott o t piling off an alarm cloak under I fl i ml md n 1 waking him up te t the th tact fact that 1111 ie dull II were wr p not nOI being 1 t I i 1 arr ar declared d red Mr I K j r M en that any mistake mad Ind IndIn it In imi or 01 neglect m on th Ih part parI of ot o Din Dill DinI DillI I uy i I II h taking action with reference to tot t he RBI a II 1 Mil II of exception x wa was a not nc oc 0 by Buy ny net act or word ord or ug u ut i t i tt or of mine mineTh mineTh Th Tb It replying to the th man mall manIa V li hn Ia IK Ii 10 pta 1118 tn to I nit cit It In HUM Jile high i I 1 u to with a Ith Hh nothing to do but watch an n l hl i oil int work ork Is Ii I a at follows follow Jn I being duty duly dul and RaY nay I am one nt f the attorney for or the plaintiff III IiiI t I jb db ve entitled action and an cc such I J this Hits affidavit In opposition to toi i Ui he h million herein made mad and pending IMI fl ih th tart part rt of the defendant to t ob obi i lr certain rt r tatt In re to 10 set Bot Bottling t lung the tM bill 1111 of exceptions herein REFUSAL TO SIGN On 01 or IF about the lith day da of June IroT I waa was engaged en In the preparation f Ion tIon of a p brief In tn the male m moUlt library While hll sitting at a II table tabt i m H n J 3 y one Otto of ot otIne Ine attorney for 0 the defendant nt hare hareIn In Into Inlo the th room and to tu tl tI tOC tabli tahl ui at II which I was wall Killing al ng and HI un ul th tha table tabie a II proposed pro bill hilt of or i In this cause eau lie called fits 01 t teil Ion to the tact fact act he h had hI l pre Ire re iiii r jt MI a II In tho tito words word ord and 14 i 1 forth orth In hi his affidavit heln helnI IK I tI and nd asked aked me ms tu to sign that IbM sUp eUp ui Ill Ii I r i iI I 1 mid and expressly told him that Ihal I 1 not lIot tiet Ot lit because caUMe Mr Ji WIl with Aith me ins In Im Inthe the itt Ih i 1 t and I Ired to 10 conduit hun hint hunI hintI I fn r entering Into any stipulation nl iud suid l aute au sInce my erl en CI 11 I i ii 0 the Lime th as a nf Ut vs v i j I i 1 never nl ver to sign n any an i t In III tl tile lue form orm proposed 1 by y Mild taid 1 fo the th reacon 1011 It II might U l I d that Ial such lIeh a ut i waive ah all II errors Tor or ur Irregularities thin that H might artt art rl after atler the dote dul ot or said ii ma as all before the slate late the th ma m lie lip thru said eald that thai his hi only l murt un In the stipulation was WIta to t KI IIa the t h fmc trouble t of serving not of ot otI the I th h H t II ITI fn rl 1 the time bill bitt and a nd ala als that thaI i jIlts might U IMo he included In I iI 1 I J 1 Ul 11 hint him that In il 1 ir o I 1 ih th ti ant IILa en 1 I had bad al at alt atI I 5 1 lY t iscu I the matter of sign Ilan hl li K ss with Mr lr fill 11 hi h liaa 11 Iro of this practise mid J 1 I did not 1101 think he be would consent to tn var 11 r It II In this Ihl Case cas a but bUI that he ht ha tool l coat u a furin of lit a stipulation thai ny very likely w rould use WIe In this can CO LId and that thit would every v ry put pur purI putI I i he sought That Thal I j said Mid U ii 1 one that ue wr havu havo n no to pro prom m p II ana amid of 01 course our Lour I would add adit ta Lu Luth thai th the Ih fun Cat fa t that hit the tb exhibits might l be e mi nt a part pari of th U the bill II He lie Het U UtIn liethen t tIn then n s atM ild It seems m to mo moo such suchIL u IL 1 will 11 all I want nant I said Id Yes Tes the tile statute pro provide vide ldes that hat I where no gt amendments Are Cr ar the th LIU III mar may b be noli lie He then thee kI Vary well veil II you ou take taM the h bill and ami aIM look It ft over und stud If Ir you find flati that you Jou ve no nn ti I i propose that furl sn i the bin bill III and aDd the lb further tact fact that hn I Cue t ti ie exhibit l may mar be he treated nt al a a R purl of th tb the Mil hill II and ad I 1 will call at your four Irk within a few low day dare and aad get g It H This i i a r d to do aim this Is Ie I all In Inu nii u or Sr effect eff ct or In any 11 aty manner thit I dd ST grm M J to to do 0 Th r c an morn as all a I J I I remember it il on nn Saturday forenoon and ad during th Ih afternoon of the th same day I 1 took th proposed bill hili to the I h of office flee fice dl of or Mr Il nn an associate a and repented to him hium the convocation that had occurred between my It l and Mr Ir and he agreed with Uh me nw rn that we w rot not sign etl the Ih stipulation PrOPOSed proponed by Mr 11 l l ln iy but that we Wv would stipulate that the exhibits exhibit might lie Ii Ie treated aa se n a part Dart of ot the bill and that we Wf had hod no 0 amendment to 10 propose propone DININNY I ON OX Accordingly that gm sam m day da I wrote upon the Ih bill my III aca e of and a nd the he I stipulation lion set Nt forth In the th af at affidavit a f 0 of Mr lr which was Willi In all In tn full fut performance i of my promise to lila Thereafter about June Jun 24 2 I left Ift salt at alt Lake JAk on ou a trip and was wan gone One about two to weeks uk ukI I 1 have hat no knowledge or informs Information lion tion ar to 10 the visit of r Mr OIl to tomy tomy my office during my absence but the bill waa as U In jp my m office during durin my toy ab ence with th tb II said mild stipulation In thereon but 1 I do not recollect whether 1 toll 1011 my clerk anything about It II aol AIlI I am unable to obtain any an Information from her hr on thin thle point now no or nr an as to the visit of for tot forthe the reason th thi hl i she hi h IK is no longer Ion a vest ee dent of the city It 1 Shortly tt inv III return to this city It and early In iii July I met mel Mr In tin tta t joint building at Salt hll SaltI I lk Iak ke and told hint him I had bait Indorsed on 0 the bill the as a averred In his hie affidavit bui but 1 J distinctly told to him him and Uld further said itald to him that the th stipulation sr se Indorsed upon the bill was wan that we had hacI no amendments amendment to propose pro and that the th exhibits exhibit might be bt treated t ed MI ta fort lart 10 rt ot of 0 the th e bill VOICE OICE FROM He Ie said Mild I tuc e c no iso reason why that will wilt not be manufactory He lip then a uk ask asked k ked ed me tao if It I thought of gf It to 10 brIng brine the hilt bill with me to 10 the office ot of o the city attorney In HIM its Ih joint building oia Urn time when I t was wae coming that way iVay ay and I 1 told bun I would be he glad lad to do It if I thought of oC o It but that he had better call for It because the summer vaca Uon tion of the courts was wa commencing and anti that I might not have hav occasion to 10 corn come to 10 the building bUll very ry noon anon or very ery often and then thea hi hs h said Mid Well Veli I have hae plenty of ot time and mind If you think of It bring It U and I f you dont I am by your office orn tery Ir ry often and I will run rumi in lit n and ami Rt gm U I said ald It 11 Is la on Ott the leek deck and the th girl knows about Jt JI and will hand It to you ou If I am m not nOI In This was wan all cli of that conversation With JH t to the thO said suld eras lion tion referred to 10 by b said Hid which he ht YM was wan hail had on the street reel The Tb only conversation con I J recall u Is I one we had on the Ibe pathway leading from State Stale street trel to the Joint building some IOme time during the summer The exact date d te I oil 4 not recall re lI He H then said You have not got cut that bill Mil of ot exception with you l and I said Mid No 00 I have not to 10 bring it II with me nt I am ant amnot not going over Ir to I the building regular ly Iy nn on Saturdays Saturday as a I J was wu In the habit of or during the Ih terms Irm of or court and you WOuld better not depend on me mI but had better call all for tor it He lIe said Hid Well Veil 11 I have ha f not thought of ot It either except when hes I saw as you And he bp slad siad furth further er r 1 I h hate e been n passing by your of or flee fice Severn several time Um and ond hive have looked up liP and und n nt t seeing eln you yu I have ha not nol called ailed tot fot It U And then he h stId lId If It you hap hup pen 11 11 to tn think of ot It bring It with Ith yu m IU mm I m ire day uhn you ou an alt III ta IYo II nid If It not nOI I 1 l ill III maki mak It II a 16 point t I till ill 11 for fur It II on Oil of ot o thi Ih the KC day to which I All might light and unil ne nc 1 I ted d I mover lr at any time had e in I which ti I J said or Jr r roI d In lii any manner that I 1 would bring II III the Ih bill of ot exceptions to tc the III Joint build buildIng i log Ing excepting only a I hay have ha herein i ia averred a TilE THE A i iOn On Saturday Oct ON IV I Mr loll I came venue to my and asked aked for tor the Herndon I bill and nd 1 I took look It U from my lilY I de desk k and aM handed it to 0 him He Ut read nad the stipulation tl I had bd Indorsed thereon and said ald he h did not nol think that thaI It would be lit as his bla tune time had run out I 1 II Isaid said I could not help that Ihal that I J h had d Indorsed on oa toe Lb trill bill such auth a stipulation u ii I had prom him and luc such a MOllO otto ono as I J tad had told him was wa Indorsed ther lie II 11 then stated that thul It was war Cult custo customary mary mal to 10 use the UI other oth r form such uch an as 16 he h had bad attached to the bill and amid a I told him hint we hud had threshed out nut thai iha before and that be tie hud hat yielded to n tl i hwa on the Ih I l I n a 11 II t tr of ut fuel fact tuf IU lU IL l I It h MI would b t the Ih same mom Balli i that U IL uld mid bit bel too to uie I Alt tu to Ia e th tb h bill settle I idE TH UK A IM He Ht then stated slated that II I 1 would n nm t the he hi h Yo i 11 if I ill u b refusing to 10 1 i u uny fj r f Gm r ur or how chow me mp any an us tesy ami Would Mould lIld publish t i lo to Hi th ID I s I a II Sc nn nit Unfair r atton aU l I loll tuli hn hit that Ihal I 1 ureS not 1101 Ilk Ilki hint him to 0 f I 1 n I ti rut pl thc thi In d ll 11 away ay ut i it Itta lluu lb Ih i I li uJ td 1 no at fin tt r I n fl I v j 1 If f fh h could ouid cul J II nil lilt ih its h m i 1 iii ii 11 Mi 1 ti 1 I Ii ni nd I as t I I iii h i UP u n nas HI as Mr Him KII s I iv t I i i 1 IK ii 1 and I I i Mr M III D ii i i l I allun is ith him Idus over ill I I n c Mi I 1 t 1 i tini U jU lo to Vi I i Ii h 11 wot woI Iljin lit j ii 1 I I j blot Hi lit bill of Ut tulsa u i idon n I I don on n cap can ca may he be Ul i 1 1 h I a 1 days dayH I after the tho judgment hi hw i t l amid nd lid I Iti I Hill ti lit el i li 11 li It I h Ii M i ii I t I ill H 01 O OL I L it Cl t Ii it lil It 1 if t ii c tin bit bits l ln II s n ii I t 11 lit r I Ii 10 I ml i I 1 S I I ill II I beck Uck III Hi uie ir If In It Ii t I I l I IMI having MI an sit a t ii mim In n r h It he n Ili in I I i II I or Pr I that Ihal I oo M tail Lall 1 i II II I i ip I p rd pId that thing tamn In u i II v vho I Iho ho thai hat mis s 11 I 01 i sly lly f ul I III I nil titI II I 5 Well Vell ih I Ii i Hi till I drag d ill KI hOl II rill thinS things ii 5 until J I l u I I f r n It I Mi ft 1 I isit I I did nut lieu 11 ii r I M II i Hop li lOll it a i in to id lb i v MI II lut I Ibl hi t u vi of vit ii ii i i II i ito in to t hi he that thul h ni not nil pact n un Uti r with willi Mi II H It i iThe i iU I The Tb s Its IM In lii null It I asit nl t In lit f fat i I 1 tIn th full i I aI t in lit both In lit b tane and loin II jr f r in Is h m iii 1 r I mi Cli n n i u H Ie tint Ih ii I I i t 11 11 1 Oni ill I li I 11 i Silt lIh l I tl I I ll in I tO the tile said Bald bill of 01 exception With re respect r sped to tho matters mattera and things thine con contained tamed In the said affidavit of ot said Bald DI Dl Dininny ninny and with respect to the th pressure and magnitude of his hi bl business bus In us I J know knew nothing and can An make no tie statement with Uh ret rece thereto but I do solemnly aver a rr that any an mistake Inadvertence or neglect on the part of the said Dininny In taking action wl cIt reference to said 14 bill of ot exceptions was not occasIoned by bT I In any n at or word or suggestion ef of mine mIn I The Tho above win wiit W d and to by James Jam Ingebretsen on ott Fri Tn Friday Friday day dy before O G W Parks arka a notary public whose commission expires Jan JanI 4 I 0 |