Show 4 BEST TEAM IN N NATIONAL AS THE UMPIRE SEES IT NEW rw EW YORK Oct No 27 27 No one Is In better position to judge judg-e the e merits of ot a ball player thel than the umpire 1 The he arbitrators for tor 15 games see the athletes athlete Ia- Ia la labor bor hor under all kinds of ot condItions therebY getting a different angle than the scribe who sees only a limited number ot of o games by rival teams During a recent tanning fanning bee In New York In which a number ot of the r league took part It was agreed that the following all all- allstar all star all star team from the National r league would be hard to beat Infielder Bottomley ot of o St LouIs first base Hornsby of ot St Louis second base Bancroft Dancroft of ot New NewYork NewYork York shortstop and Traynor ot of Pittsburg thud base hase Some of ot the tho umpires figured Frisch FIsch too great a player to tot tOl be left lett out and thought It might be wise to use Frisch at second and pia play Hornsby at first a position with whIch he is familiar In the outfield Roush was first choice and nd then Max Carey There was a difference o opinion on a II third fielder but Wheat it Lt BrOok DrOok- BrOoklyn lyn who ho is a great game this bear vear ear won on out Other out out- outfielders outfielders out fielders to e ta men men- mention mention mention tion ere ere era Cy of ot the bease of his run home home run ome-run and Young Youna and ot of the Giants tor for their play OFarrell of ot the Cubs was se- se selected selected se selected as the most valuable catch catch- catcher catcher er in the league le bec because of ot his promise and ability was wal a wide difference of ot opinion on the pitching question each ot- ot official of official having a certain pitcher who looked ed best to him nr |