Show TO BAR RAILROADS FROM MINE Senate Indicates That Rate Bill Will Confine Business to Transportation TILLMANS TILLMAN'S MOTION TABLED i Vote rote oi Fa In t s 1 Ii J rI I I hilt hi till Ing is O From Continuing coal anti and andOH OH oil Lands I n. n jy In s Acting for roi Mr i 11 Allis i I I is Ill 31 11 v. v ii In Iii till lit M tho j judicial I ro le 1 I to 10 1 I the Ill I le ml rail rail- I. I 11 IO fly rale 1 lull hill thill ua-s ua Jt IU-I IU ii 1 U ts a. a n aThe i I hJ tilt till The IIii oll III I I ii c Ion l' l h fl t. t lit tho oid fa fairly tl c In III section four of ur till the lull hill are ml out Second the H I in iII Its 11 I t. t judgment j III In the same Nina an III I retained ta 4 clellon is I. I. I te e. l III In the lite 1 Stale circuit hear t 4 C courts to 0 and H determine lie Mills t. t against n itz I t the coin coin- Fourth Po Ii I Ill no j Injunction I iii ii t of Pr order Is I. io to l be he granted ll tO a U hearing and FI Firth rc It I LI Hit ht for fiji hili 11 m ii IlIj lCt iou 1011 of or interlocutory I II s I-s to lo lie he I heard Il by h L three judge Sixth a it IIIi appeal from flom till the iiiI ill ill- ii I oi order iIii or 01 P decree to Lu lie lil onlY t 10 0 1 tilt the lie lO court III t of the lie Unite It Ld States t Washington at May Ia sty S That S.-That That the railroad rail rail- road rate Ie regulation lull bill to be enacted into law will prohibit Interstate carriers car car- fiers from lum engaging in III an any o other hel business busi ness e than that of transportation wa was Indicated lJ by the Senate lat Jat laty this after after- noon After tei an au entire SC session Joli devoted u t to i th tile tho lIun of how I con congress less could best treat lIcal evils lIs which It Jt was wu unanimously un- un agreed existed through railroads ralli owning or UI operating coal and anllo oil uil lands the tho Senate defeated lJ by a t II o Ite of oZ 49 19 9 lo to 2 29 the motion of Mr 11 that the pending amendments amend montH ments prohibiting such uch practices bo tc upon the table lable 1 ir 1 ow 11 0 n. n r or the South t t ian who Is It nominally In charge of r th tho i rate lah hill bill was vai lo to eliminate from nun consideration COny con con- toy y 81 the thc l I lk amendment and the substitute of Mr 11 the 4 phraseology of or which had been dl cu continually for or four om hours with the only apparent result or of having hu caused inci eased confusion as to what the lie senate le wished to lo do clu TIC lie had hud an amen amendment to offer oUel that he believed helle I r. r would wn clarify tho atmo atmosphere and i ti bring irl speedy rc results which In a few feu carriers ear car 1 words simply prohibited common i i doing an any other but business The Thc tho the motion followed a de- de I defeat of or senators by a vote of or 51 61 by amend amend- motion to lay an amen f to au J. J that a 2 1 c c i on the table was waH not In accor accord substance of the and V. V with the spirit unanimous agreement under which l I the amendments to th the rate rale bill were considered This question has being r had never but repeatedly lY come conic up Uj ed to a ruling been becil plc pressed before question submitted the S president vice Ice t. t themselves es in InIe view Ie of or to tu the tho senators R of entertained by b many opinion 0 tho Iho the table motion to I lay a on that a U agreement in IlL that thal it fore forc- j the violated been dl had ed cd a vote vole before t exhausted Amendment i Vole ute on Oil t The fhe vote vole on the l' l C to lay IllY the the lie table wa was walS amendment dment on HJ Ins I us s Bulk Bulk- Alec tIce Ankeny Yeut C Carter Clark Clarl lo lay Icy Burkett Dick I- I Prye Frye rye Hale Hole Wyo Cullom I Lodge o ge KilO Millard Nelson elson Long uthel Suther- piaU Spooner and lantI fillman To Total Berry lr cr Bacon Bacun Bailey Baller I cy AI Drun aid eget egee mn Clark Clarl Clar Clark Mont 1 ClaPI ln Daniel I Dill Dill- Ark Ari Clay DO Dryden en Dubois Dubols Fostel Frazier JI in Flint Gamble Gf uy c nr 1 I McCumber Mc- Mc LaFollette M Mon r. r lauri ii M Martin Perkins Pettus Nixon Overman O Smoot Stone nU nel ScOtt and Warnel Varner fn Teller 4 19 amendment canie III the no action J Jv vIn v- v UI II for con it nt Itt tile previous In ing been heen en on ic and D Dry Dry- KnoX X 1 Kc lun on 5 u was one the thO theu den urged c that thal then that t lt It n n nc great beat eat eatn n bl be of or uch b until It ShoUld bo lIo A f 1 h v The Thee New e Jersey if no tim limo I mUl I l Hut t to dispose of time the he be IH was Wl given Sl n result would their hol hold the bufferIng to the Injury ry to the te them n of the Mr tr coal to 1 be till un- 1110 KnoX time the constitutional 0 To u Defer in III which debate of f the hit resUlt and amI Fulton l I The rime Doll DilIver vei r I Flint that Ic r U II belief joined bring deferred To should U 11 the he Sen- Sen ell ell- Vi boro M uuro that r time the C N. N C. C C the uc Overman alu ate Mr r bo be u lo to commerce the Iho ol Oil bill of tf Committee report a to COI- COI of with nl itt this I that 10 cd this thi J dr Daniel opu delaY and that t the It merely cn that that thal lQ ho could If lO no Il would be hoped the motion mo- mo Mi 11 pre all time lOll tion II the tho Daile ItU HOon H- H Mt r. r of the at hand fbi UI the t that was as hold that to tion Oon give Ivo not flOt anzio an could sas existing evils lIs which he for or I Cute oure of oC no Ite d hA hAt zio nol l hId dorse or i would one ud on Ila mag c C t t t if 1 c. c r 1 c TO BAR RAILROADS FROM MINE OWNING Continued from froni Page One was as willing to have the provision take effect by January 1 1908 to Offers Suggestion Mr LaFollette suggested that railroads rail rail- roads oads should be prohibited from ac- ac coal or oil lands In the litter litter- period Mr Overman resented the hue tiomi on that he lie was aiding in delaying and withdrew his motion Mr McLaurin offered a ito IQ a penalty for violations Mr Mi Dryden declared the proposed legislation as revolutionary and a step that hat If taken takemi would bring a greater calamIty than hart ever before known In imi this his country country- He moved to lix January Janu- Janu ary ry 1st 1911 as the tho time for the tho taking effect of time the provision Ho wanted anted to know from where the tho peo- peo pie le would get their heir coal Mr Bailey replied that it would come omo from the tho independent companies The Tho senator from rota New Jersey the de- dared lared that they could not supply the tho Then Thien the manipulation of coal is greater than I thought the Texas senator If tIme the people arc not held up imp by bythe he the throat then lien why this outcry retorted re- re Mr Dryden In Jim Method Mr Aid Aldrich rich said that lint everybody be- be the business of production uni Id he lie divorced from moi that of trans trans- He lie thought the new em a very Intricate one omie and said it was as a grave question as to o hue tho powers pow pow- ers rs of congress Mr Bailey declared that the soon sena- tar or from Rhode Island was the tho car car- best friend Following this the spectators were to one of those hio rare occasions when hen the tho become confused and openly express their be- be The Tho noise In the he chamber chamberas isas as so great that many did not hear it t. t Some one else called for the and the request was again complied with senator would and another would raise some somi point of order The Tho air was surcharged sur- sur charged with exclamations of ot disgust surprise and amid amusement from differ differ- exit nt parts of the chamber i iTo To prevent the session from de- de eloping into an experience meeting Mr Hale moved an executive session The Tho question of railroads owning coal lands ands will c nie up again tomorrow |