Show wednesdays BATING BALLOTING on the final ballot for U 13 senator the vote WM was as follows follow i for rowlins Sona Se natora tors Allred Cains evans johnson Joh nion smoot so snow w wright total 8 represents Beno Ben ioa callis D B S cook S N cook duffin greenwood hanen en hardy hopkin kenner joseph kimbell lommon li emmon lund maxfield mckay murdock mardock parry bodney shepard A P dore DOOD stewart Bt ewart taylor Wil total 24 grand total 82 for thatcher Tha senator Bena torM cannon chambers harbour monson A W 0 kobaker No baker r hideout Bide out boulion Bob lion whittaker total 9 rep adderson Aud enoD creer doa dotson forebee gibson 0 0 kimball kimbal labarthe morgan martio martin obrien perkins ns price bay boy lance N C Bor son OB Thore Tb oreion wheeler total 20 franu total 29 for henderson Hende noB senator hamer total 1 ifor for brown brow n rita tive robinson total 1 yesterday in ID the speeches made at me noon session ot of the joint assembly by those who urged a recess of two bourn boon there was expressed a tacit agreement ge ement that that would be all tiao time bey abey would ask aik and that on re fe they would be prepared for tile the albal cont ewt with this under standing many who were opposed to the recess rehem voted in favor ot of it in 1 ft a spirit of magnanimity A few minutes attar alter 8 the joint assembly was waa called to order immediately after roll balio caIl OBren rose and moved that the joint assembly dissolve froot protested against dla die solution that the me distinct understanding demanding un was waa that abe opponents opponent of rawlins liaw lloa would not ask ak lor for more time denied that such a pledge bad been given then ensued a loog long debate on the be subject object or of adjournment the of rawlins opposing it while his bli opponents sought ought to ackom it after a number of dilatory motions had been disposed of a ballot of united jolted states senator was waa ordered when senator rideout s name was wag reached be arose and addressed the assembly in substance as follo follows follone fol lowe wt this will probably be the last vote I 1 will cast lor for moses thatcher Tha I 1 stand here as ae bin personal pera onal represents live to make a reply to the attack that bat bas bai been made upon him this after oHe 10 he referred to the remarks remark made by shepard mr Tua tober instructs ina truoia me to say aay that he be never maln mado the pledges he is ie charged with having made to the effect that be would withdraw from the race it if oot not elected un on saturday last on the contrary he has always said he be was wag in the fight to the enu end his followers were bound by solemn golemo agreement to stand by him until of them should agree that they were at liberty to vote for some other candidate the speaker referred to the ogden convention of two years ago and compared the reception which raw baw liner line aberts sino and thatcher olivo ly ay rooe received ived holding that hat it Is showed bowed that thatcher Tha tober was wa the idol of me people he denied that moses thatcher Tha lober or nil him followers llowen fo stood abood upon an aim anti charob platform but said bald that the be nime NEWS and the opponents oppen ento of Tha teber had tried to foroe force them upon such much a platform continuing he said 1 I suppose today will see aee the opponent of mow mom thatcher Tha loher elected but I 1 with wish my voice to go down to the most remote age of the future in ID protest protect against it I 1 saw aw today a block of 0 votes rotes picked up and planted where I 1 bad been aured assured they never neter would go and I 1 expect 16 e see ee another block picked up op by we be annie ame hand band which Is the power behind the throne here evans called rideout to order maying paylag that mat nis remarks remark reflected upon members of the assembly aiB embly but continued to in the same ame traio strain end and said today a member of the senate come came to me and said aid Is this terrible influence brought to bear on you I 1 have a mind to stand aland up before this assembly asa embly and resign and say lay that I 1 am not a free man and go home 1 my god can such things be ba in this land of ef liberty at we close ol of the nineteenth century things were not worse to la ancient almea when under church domination the people tortured them selves than for this senator to say lay that be was waa not a tree free man it ir my canal d date a to carries the content I 1 into a to the united states state senate and those theae are an uncovered what will the be at this juncture there was a bromen tromen dous done burst bum of applause app lauie from the lobby when taylor rose roee and moved to clear the lobby rideout continuing said id they bithey ask aak for the lobby to be cleared but bat such nob manifestations are the only way the b people have bare of expressing what to in weir hearts the wed seed has ha been aown but bat woo woe woo woe to we band that thai to Is bowing ii anere was wai boub confusion in the lobby at several etral points point during daring flue out oats remarks remark and they greatly augmented the excitement when bennion Ben niona la name was waa called he be arose and aad la in a calm and temperate train strain proceeded to refute the charges that any undue influence had bad been exer exerted to control the vote voted of mem berm ben he claimed to be himself a champion of the fullest liberty and bowed the abe of the post poal lion taken by thatcher Th siad aad his hie followers some borne of Bennio nj s remarks rei narke called forth question tion and ana commentz com oom menta ments from followers follower of thatcher Tha tober that dw duh played much bitterness bit terne of feeling prior to thin juncture the president iad ad repeatedly ruled as aa out of order remarks remark made in favor of 0 church issues but in no oae case had bid h he restrained a member who spoke poke against me church when the name hame of callis woo waa reached he be rose roae and protested protea teJ against the flagrant partiality that bad been shown by the abe president he spoke doke admiringly of moses thatcher Tha tober bat de dared he be could not under any circumstances endorse the principle UP upon on which he stood when the name of D S cook was wac reached he be arose and denied that he had ever been a party to the agree ment sold laid to have been made by the supporters up of thatcher Tha tober wat that they would vote solidly for thatcher Taa tober until two thirds of their number agreed ol otherwise berwise he had long supported aup ported thatcher Tha tober but bat considered himself at liberty to leave him at any ady time he appealed to president ident to verity verify his bie statement and the latter stated that mr cook bad never been under the pledge made between the supporters of Tha tober when 18 N cooka name was waa reached he areas and said aid that a statement had bad been made charging undue nce over be could not ot lot let pan page he was waa a mom mem her ber of the dominant church and had all the time understood tood WAS that prominent officers of that church desired the lection election of H P henderson Heo denon but act ing on bla big own judgment and with absolute freedom he be bad refused to sup up port henderson Hende raon and had voted all the time for rawlins bailine Baw line it if the block ot of votes votee referred to had bad gone to thatcher instead of rawlins it would have been all 11 II right with the gentlemen gentl gent lemou emea who charged ch argia czuroh influence 4 when dotson Do toona s name was wai reached hamaid he mid that matters matten had been brought into we the discussion which should not havo hav been but on principle which be hold held to be above party he be stood and would vote for mosse thatcher duffin made a strong and eloquent address add he declared that he be had voted fifty two times tor for henderson henderdon Hende raon and bad done so ao as aa a free man grow from conviction that his bla candidate was waa the beat was man prevented for the place he continued that noble band which ken hoi stood by him 0 so o long through this alvere vote content are not slaves in ID their bosoms beat the of freedom combined with the firm purpose of carrying them out and the gentlemen who have impugned their motives are not themselves thema elvea above suspicion it him hab been insinuated time and again in this joint assembly that there was a hand band directing the voting I 1 deny this hl assertion tion I 1 permit no DO man to loi infringe ringe on my liberty no matter who be may be and I 1 appeal to the members bembera ot of this assembly aa to say aay by their action here today that hat this talk must cease 20 he continued at some length in an veins vein denying the ibe minelaus lons of the opposition to the effect that undue influence was waa controlling the votes of the members member and insisting that he be was waa acting as aa an absolutely free and independent man during tola his remarks remark be was interrupted several everal times timea by t g members mem berB who 0 objected b to so 0 o much being amid upon the church lafue issue in reply to these tiong duff duffan a insisted that he bad the be right to doland defend his hii be and the church of which he w was a member ha had 1 been unjustly attacked and be was wai entitled to the privilege of reply he showed that about five sixtus sixths ol of the voters in hr his district were members ot of the democratic party parly and nd also of the churon church which was being assailed when hardys name was reached he declared that bat be had bad supported henderson hedderson out oat of his admiration for the man and his bis confidence in his hie qualities for the position of united states benator ee te but that seeing no hopes of bho election as a mac absolu absolutes teY free and independent he be claimed the right to change his vote he declared that he be submitted to no dictation in poli politico tion and utterly repudiated such buch a charge in behalf of him soft elf and the other supporters au of henderson when hanners Ken neri same name was wa called he expressed a brief eulogy on rawlins bowline oiling citing the excellent exo ellent qualities of the man as reasons for supporting him he said so far an aa the church influencing fluen cing my conduct li in concerned I 1 am willing that the matter should bould be referred to the church confident that it will utterly repudiate all onal billay for my actions action this remar k created lauchter joseph kimball spoke poke feelingly of his bin aa admiration mi ration and friendship for henderson Hen aerson and deplored the tact fact that hia big election was waa hopeless bo pele giving it 11 as a till his reason for changing hla his vote he stated he would now vote for an old school chool mate whose client he be had veen been for yom and aad it was waa with both pleasure and regret that he now new announced lais au vote for joseph joaeph li bawlin Bawl ln mrs mn la barthe said ald that she ebe had bad voted first last and all the time for moses thatcher Tha and it gave her pleas ure to know that in so 0 o doing she he was wae in harmony with the other lady mem bers ben of the assembly aaa embly obrien said laid that he had bad yet seen no reason for changing big bia vote and would record it for H P lH Hen denen anderson said ald that hat fifty one times he be had voted for a noble and capable man aaa woo would have honored the popi portion tion of united states senator but seeing no hope of nia bin election he would now vote for his hib boond second choice he declared be did SO ao as freely as a he voted for his first calloe sloan said bald he had been asked aided to deliver what might be called the funeral oration of the cause dear to the hearts heart of himself and his friends that whatever the result might be he would endeavor to harbor no tooling of bitterness he salu men may think they hey are tree free when they are bandsman bun damen I 1 do know kaow as ai I 1 know kaow I 1 live that undue influence ha bag been exerted over members of this assembly aia embly I 1 hold in my hand a frag went of a letter latter written by a member in which he says bays be holds bold a higner allegiance than to the state it that man vote helps help to elect a 11 united slat senator benator he today I 1 will challenge his vote the facts will cume come out time 10 he continued in this strain at considerable coni drabe length referring ferring to the DU ionea in in me abe newspapers newe papera of pulpit utterances adverse to big candidate and said raid need any man tell me that the oon con sequences of what L have done JR IB this legislature will not follow me to my dying day they certainly will on an I 1 shall ball feel them as long as aa I 1 live but I 1 am prepared to meet them 92 taylor made some pointed and eloquent remarks in refutation of the cuarte of church dictation elating that bat be acted with frith as a great freedom as ae any ally man who lives and that bat be would cast his big vote for a ata statesman teaman worthy of I 1 the be confidence of the people J eseph li rawlins Baw llos made a speech in which he lauded moses thatcher denounced the opposition to him and claimed that seventy five ver cent of the people of the bbate desired his bis election he closed by the constitution of the united states and ot of this thin state forbid any religious test leet but I 1 say esy that all may host bear that mow mom thatcher to 1 defeated by a religious test ft J mrs anderson An denon who had voted toted for thatcher arose and changed her bet vote rota to rawlins Bawl loi when torm storm of ahlm burst forth from members mem ben on the flot floor and men man in the be lobby and a few mo later rhe phe arose again and changed her ber vote rote back to 0 thatcher Tha mangan who bad voted for goodwin win arose aroe and changed his hia vote to thatcher OB leo who had voted for henderson Hender BODi saying baying that he saw no reason to change followed Mang anft anpo example as aa did martin who bad ad voted for or harris harrie then speaker perkins ni who hadr voted tor for harries arose aroe and aad changed bla big vote to Tb That atcher chr 0 0 kimball kemball a republican who haa voted for goodwin changed hla bin vote vole to thatcher hanson another republican who bad voted for goodwin then ben arote arose and changed his vote to rowlins abi rbi robinson noon the tb third republican who bad mine alie voted for goodwin arose add laid aid A I 1 am the only republican who was waa elected on ft a straight tra igat republican platform I 1 abongan my vote to arthur brown sil much of the time during the th and part of the time abu the ballots ballota were being changed by the members named it seemed as aa it the lobby had been transformed tran formed lutu into a bed lam the shouting bo screeching nim lag ing and applause produced an uproar deafening and nd the does defied all description io dozens of voices in the lobby si and d ou on the floor shouted for wilson and called on him to 10 vote tor for thatcher Tha tober but he firmly kept 1160 hie big seat beat refusing to change his ahto vote whenever a vote was changed to thatcher tbt uproar and applause were deafening and the announcement of a chadee to rawlins called arth cries of scorn anti and derision demon tb scene oene was disgraceful in the extremes extreme and not we slightest effort was wao made either by the president eident Pr or any of the legislature to check the tumult when the result had been announced by J president and he be had bid declared that joseph li rawlins had been elected united states senator and made a low few wen well timed calm and sensible Reu sible remarks looking to 90 ibe heeling of 01 wounds wound and the repair log ing of broso bep he moved that hat we the president pre aident appoint a committee of three to lo escort boor mr |