| Show t n HAS BEEN TOLD TOLO I i f His Cross Examination by Dc De fI I i in Haywood Trial 1 Is I Finished CONSISTENT ALL THROUGH Attempt I Id hi Slum Thai Ii 18 I tit I Wax WIl II si Ni Nily II I I J lP t II ly ami rl I I Holse BoIse Ida lio June iUne lj lIun i n wh w Iv Ivare 3 i lire are tattling to 10 save the life lICE of rif William WilliamD I D 1 anil the Rood or U th tf Western federation or oC Miners hull 11 1 thor liei Illo l upon Harry 0 n today carrying n 1 by h 1 m I u ot or o his Ii i Hf f his II li ULI they Ihy bit hi 1 1 crime down ju w ii to LII hil assailed his hh guiding motives Six Rix ulel hil ii they hey spent lit hI rig him hdm days ys I Ii i the tile July jun Ju ot of every lh 11 of or o n r f mid ii tin thun upon It him II tin In I 1 11 flu I attack pitt Eik 11 tit t every ICI UH to In t III I hi I craft Cl C 1 t tl convince c the Jury Unit Or 01 Orchard 01 chard wn I It l In Iii tin tinly ly I c thu Ow th live of or o Innocent In Iii the Ih hope 1101 of tiC III hi own 1 fl They lu curried their to t 1 the tho r w viti which the thu an nn ip their will lIS 44 they UC l b ity y It 1 nut 1111 Into 1110 his mouth by inert him hint The Tiit he of nt nl lit j kM git ye til Il I it Oi i thu ti Ih t Ill 11 lh Ihl it ti chali I I In It Iti lud 1111 i ittig Woods court ott ri a it I depth ii t I of or i ii tt iii n nii I human tat fill I I In III tl ii Intensity itt I t I t tt 11 t I that t ii a t und fl I td l hell ld tv ei IU mt 1 n ni i woman and alli when h they to II II Him Im the th Il t LI II Ii it r KIl 11 It David hay Id and alt u lid I that I to 10 him when I he ht CI ni Itt II a IL I f fill r slon He lIe fought to 10 Il himself I t but the thu learl t ea rt filled fl Ill I II 11 II III I Ct yr and ald he tie hI unevenly like a U woman His Iok to t and In iti 11 hid E fact In itt II a it j handkerchief Then ho he 1 tr r hi 1 mul went weil on ill Oi t iN iNi to the tho end Hu lie Il defended his hi motives hv IP i HalnA lI yi tig that ho lie 11 had IH 11 I b fOUld tid true tilte conversion III mid In it penitence had r 1 1 I OIHI to tl ma Hll il 1 toH r by h t freely COlre HI till nil ni had mill 1011 him him that h lu he wan II do ins a it great greatT T for 01 the and that CIC kind to 10 I men who nerved them there Val wim wa no ICI other othol promise you Ton know knew that If ItoU t you confessed COl eMed lei In leithe tI tIthe the thc murder the LIW Ih taLo W put pul you out of Ir the Ihl II way wn ham hammered INed Atty Att 1 Yes nil itI nilAnd And All It would Id do d o It I t lIe I 1 PUt me tUe out olt of or the way 11 v nut Hut somewhere lonA the tho lino tho Ih thought to 10 t you YIU that you 1 could Rut get out of ot It tt by li I t on OIl to 10 No o 0 sir that thaI Will not flOt the thought nt At all allAnd ni And nd hero hee It II was ns that Orchard cave CI a it the thu motives IC explanation of It that Impelled him to 10 UH tilt 1 yoke fell cli to a it tow low tone but bul there no nD other show of or emotion Complete si sl silence l lence I nce gave gae CIP every ery vord to the tite th I 1 loom 1001 The Titi TIl whiz of un ito In fan an overhead over ovet head was wal wa the thu ROU Roll accompaniment ot of the Itte recitation 1 l thought lie tr of or putting out of the tho way but bitt I 1 thought over ver cl my thy past Ift t J I did not bel In iii II a I hereafter It at all ul but bitt T I w was as iu 10 lii dip Ille I thought at zit linos 1 that Ull I t had bail been such un Ln n unnatural monster I my 1 crimes hail had ha boon Iten but no 1 0 great that thal i would not be rr In Who tl told lold you ou that Xo Ni 0 one on e Who Iio wrOte tillit out for you OU OUI 7 No Ni I otto fino but utter I unit had been heen Uit Uita a 1 IIo ItI i hAn had hn read It some Rome I Ih caIlo h Uv the the conclusion that 1 I would be bc for tOI or If iri I made a confession co of ot every ewry everything thing I 1 begun heglin to think that the tho gravo IW did 1 I il nol lint n everything I og Anil 11 I mUll mad o oUt up Ut my lY mind to 10 tell LI tile the truth about y the Iti oh a thins thin Sn Sit s yim thought you rOi ou would mal jour PUI pence peace with the Iho by hr M pl tutu I hung hun did ld you ou 7 asked Mr 11 1 i J No 0 ply fir h I I think any nn man eon con make his hIl pOni lOn with wih the l futuro If IC he le ii 10 to 3 l believe It I was l my lily duty duly l t I tell tel tiLe Iho truth 1 did not Iut sen II se any other ither way voy W re ardle g of oC tile the s to I I or ur anybody elue Ise I l owed Hod seit It II I t to II ii y I owed fl ll It 1 to 10 God od and Ild to myself t The 11 ill n e that If OnH a Iti did 1111 ii Iii not get gel 1 till the t tt to tu Ills itis duly tn I hi 1111 himself front trOI t 1111 or II my IttS other Ithol It U I Will ted Li Lu 10 tutu him hi h b tile the II oath It ht took 1001 I W 11 he hI Wo Ih of H r Miners t Th TIta read him hint until from thu Ih rHual but 1111 hi when they old Id that lie JIlT 1 XII ael Ml the tite that lle 10 I hi hud been given to 10 him by h the Ihl ti Almighty Fur Vu thu Ih awny on on oh ithe the motive Or Ir f saving his hi own till life If They Iho 11 to 10 1 show shul siti It II In ho the 1111 tie ct of Hr r drawn train from tin im immunity it luul of ut Ih in hi llio Iho Molly Mol tott I CI e IS hut ht tho is not II ut nit t they th is nought for rUI It In Iti II to 10 11 i Ht t Adams ii d mi CIVIl r to tu Ihl HIl t nn then I I in I the tb I it I II I 11 it o I gs Ih t Guv tIlt 01 In they y o the fact thu titu the hail twice his bin te ll I lil out 1111 Inn hu I reliant Orchard ripe ie the he hut that I ii it t It I had been beit lt t tila by it h i ch rift I I 1 Atty t I ty I I iw I ty or II t any anybody ii I body itic I After l It I WItS WI ed Ill that IhAl t I ia t I had hll liln fu turo IUle t IC in II I it t I II k te ti tig of n it Hint I tl I lie It I ll i hall hail I Kent sell t momy I 1 to tn bin 1118 It is family tt Ii Y In iii II Ill ii l that ho Ito hail had hailI been I i tt tt itt Ii J tt it tp 10 ti tits tOI Hint J hail hiatt I Itt him it I itt a net a I liti C iii It II Ott nu 1 I huh for toi 01 lib hl I tt up ii ht li WI tIlt i on It thu ho I lila but nl tilt itI tiny Ih I ni itI to III hlll him him II a i Ilum iun tik I ir fl l rhine till III table iii titi of thu Ih warden II ul iii uldie die iii 11 UK ut lIa iv lj h nI hitt given rN and ih Ihl n no II III oilier r r had In III Ii i and nn tIll nil Iliin 1011 I nn iii iiii i I itI he III t lt 1 In iii I for II 01 killing Then came A n showing a ato tIC ui to In how the prisoner been dressed and for fc r the tle trial nod and IU Uy for climax they howd Ing InK for anh saving the life oC or Boh Dh Wet Wol Wetter et Ill ter i to 10 death deuth for murder burlier Orchard Or hald admitted that he had appealed to Gov GOI Wetter Vetter ami that later tatt first reprieved Wet Wetter 1 tor ter and nad then c his hlll hi sentence of ot death to 10 ono one or r lire lIro Imprisonment Orchard left ft the Ile stand at 3 oclo lr titter having it II for a total of or i hours lust Just before he lie was excused nud nn remanded 1 he lie went vent back 1 to the tha bands ot of o the prosecution and Mil Identified the casing of the bomb he hc planted at It atthe attile tile the gate gute nf tit Judge house hoube hou C In hit Denver Orchard Is to 10 return to the iha witness chair Inter hater b tho the defens cel 1 lay lilY the tite formal lines jOt for Impeach Impeaching 1111 pooch log ing n hint him und the state must still have hal havethe tho the redirect 1 examination WHAT SAYS Cap Capt Jons the tha th who has figured SH 51 SI largely In itt the tile testimony und end who wholine line has been attacked by b counsel for th thu defense prefer not lIot to 0 be bl Interviewed at nt length on the th subject of ot o the thu Orchard confession It would be 1 superfluous for tor tee Jill to reiterate he lie said today Orchard has ha told the literal truth about the confes confession ones Ion sion tind tin thu way 1111 It Il was given to 10 me meI meI I made Inalle him no n promises I 1 never made maden n 11 profuse toti criminal In my life Or 01 Orchard chard hard drat confessed to me toe but hul aid he wilt not tithe rendy to 10 Give Eive lve It to ma tn rii finally q I 1 promised to hold It for tor some time lime mid faQ I J did so He 11 told me that when he heum um wits ready to 10 II tell lell the tho whole story Mory he would won lot me tee know and Borne time later Inter hi III told me ate the tho Incident of ot his life hire 1 fe leaving out nothing gler that ho he hall ban sold on tho the stand m Iii 11 to 10 toi i he h confession IH itt tile the th truth and AOl there is 13 to add The Tite state expects to 10 close clo e liB JIB case a e In 10 days or 01 two Iwo weeks Clarence Par Oar Darrow row tOI for tur the tho defense defence a says say AA that their HII w will III take lalie about four week thoUght though It Is III possible it may he ho concluded l in inless less leMs It Is JO I conceited conceded d how however ever that the Iho verdict will not be he before Aug 1 1 SESSION ESSIO Alter Aller r re cv cc a Orchard was WIH questioned his hut contemplated suicide He J I to Ie said this v 15 e tome sOllie lime after aCtor he ho had con As iii to Ills hits lon Orchard said ald he to Ie rIll felt he hu ruid Ciet it II ns liS a n tidy duty dut to 10 his God his hiM country society odet and Where her did hid yoi yot get It language rod God cave 1011 It to 10 me nie You got sol It H from loni ion Oll ionI J I Uld 1 not jint Well Veit Ill lie Iii poke to you yuu about Hod iou and jour om u Itt country CO thU try and ii yourself III nt t he 7 1 dont think ho vald about tny elf read tead to lu the tite the Di itt obligation gat ion token taken by b members of at tile the lit W I terri of or Miner lIlIer ami If hI h tutu hail III kell any other 01 her secret oaths said ho Ito did mil Itoh The oath of ot the Iho I federation exacts cult ii I ci s with your you r duly y to 10 God COil tn to your country and your fel Cel fellow low how men mell tines does It Not 11 H It ei I remember Phi DJU you ever tell 1111 lt you yet lIn hurl had the tite oath 1111 nf the le of ot thu the Western estern Federation of or MIller No sir 1111 lr I did thu nut not H II few r rhe he Ill made ma l hi con he h was wai u r to re moved d to this the penitentiary I building I ItOM I nick Ick he ht 1 mild he In had b lute ii out tilt 1 of tit the I tie ii oh on 00 n the me I ii lit lif Ii e hud had gum guile to In Il to In Li before th gram jury r A MII U I It II Ih I it i I tk th II of or tin t Ii rd s coin 1011 tea tes tesi i 11 I I ti Ii I 0 a 1 rues I ti And tild 1 you oU Here tere rc put pitt in 1 the tite 7 some cell i with t lIh him lr lie JI I to we nN xi thrown I Into nto I ilio tIu next flex L cell 1 No o Kir 1111 Where WH h 11 ho M MIn I 11 In the saute cell ecU with me meHo metie I Ho tie wan lint 1111 In with willi you OU then sir air Orchard aia be lIP Il ned and the th warden to 10 do tIn what that he lie to 10 make Adams alt all he Ii h knew to tell the Iho trill truth h hJ J I told lol l Stevo that I 1 thought of or mak making log ing ft I confession lon that ho had better do dothe d dIhe tile the name same that the truth hail had to out some I Po Ho your confession elon you lied to tf o Stove Steve 1 l dont If know Imol that 7 1 1 lied to 10 him I toll tell hInt lUm J I had confessed 1 1 1111 1 li 11 I ell ott Steve that when you 01 got 01 nut you were going to put Pili water between ht you OU and what I was wall left of o the tue Western l of lit N 00 i ale air 1 something about If It It II ever iver happened that I 1 got out Id go 10 the What were we you It going across the for tor bf eti 10 tn 0 much In III the thc federation between dyer MII el Child and l tho the others otheN that thu t If Ir any anybody nn body roughed up It 11 do Ill them alty lut good that they would 1 get Ret them sooner or 01 later la I r rOil You Oil you vou had murdered Got Gov and anti that you yuu deserved hanging you ou ouy Yes y fir And having couf t d And nd expecting to In be bl hanged you jou were with Stoe RI Adams the plans for your our fu tu fuI I tire lire Yia ys ii sIr 1111 il r rAnd And Anti this was Alt b cnute of ur Mc Ic had told you 1 No Nit n sir I L dont donl kno that I 1 had any hope hop When camo to thO thi petit peni penitentiary after th tiu of ot Adams 0 O told he detective he hi h hs l done dOllo he hI to Ir ii get gel Artam to tell tho truth Slur left the tho ely nry a 1 said a III he had hiatt not hot beet been In a I twIt end bed hll l the tho freedom Iee of it r tho Iho t building thug a ground Hr lie Insisted that T hail had made madl him bun no promise of o ImmunIty NO 0 PHO lift Ito mild Fild 1 he ho make me 1110 11 any promise said 1 Orchard U it he in did hll he ti 11 keep it Ho BA once onOe he IIi would the prosecuting po attorney coni 1111 out nut and teo ee oc me ute I 1 told him hn III for tor when I 1 mAil ninde up UI my m to 10 confess I would 1 tell ten everything of ot my 1113 own 11 free will vItI So 1 he would rend the Ih attorney up hip to It see II you anti fix tb fl It J 1 dont know I that h ho slid 11 It 11 thai was the construction 1 J put upon It And 1111 he Intended that you ou should pili that construction upon it itI I dont know thAt he lit did didGo Gal Gov Go GoolIn Gooding hap lIa been heen out nul to see eQ you yeLl on many times ha hanant nt nl he heYes heYes Yes sir And culls calls you Harry Yes YI sir And shakes hands with you yon Yc Yes sir III And talks with you In a 03 trien Iy J I way Wll it Yes Y iten tI Now en you 01 know from frOnt his manlier r to tl tr you ou that he never omer intends you OU shall be hanged He hits has never told me Inc anything of the tile sort ort But hut you ou know from his hi manner that lie b regards you OU III as 55 n it friend He Ito hiSs has told me tao he thought thou ht I 1 was Willi right end doing a II great 1 reat thing for the tho state Mate and the country And he said ald the Ih Mate would be un an under under der tier rin en obligation lo to you ou No 00 sir Orchard Warden erdel Whitney also calls him hInt Harry harD Youve You b been n made n II hero hiero of or by b Mc Me the governor and the warden you v No so 1 L 1 dont know mo v what bat you ou mean meau by hero Orchard denied theU he ate ato his hili at al the wardens Ard ns home or that he ever eer had hod wIne with his meals His fits food to 10 him from rom roni tho titO wardens kitchen Orchard wen w questioned at length about his written confession He lie wild said 1 he ho wrote two having left some ome of ot hU uk misdeeds out of oC the first Did you write In this confession conCession or book hook the tho speech you lUU made here hero on thA the witness s stand this thi morning about your duty dulY to God Gud and nd your couTry Y 7 No ro sir tr Who bo wrote that statement for you ou Nobody You Tout had bath no preparation for It II ItI 1 I may m have hale thought of oC what 3 I would say nay Ha but when I started slatted In I X lId did not no Know what I u would i 33 ay II Orchard denied he ho had hod ever Ewer hen boon put lut In a 0 chair ehl lr and anit examined and cross cros l by b tile the attorneys for tor the state In lit preparation for the trial Richardson wanted wan led to tD know knew If It Detec Detective live tive HI Instructed the Ibe witness H bUt to 10 his demeanor on ih the Iho stand Iund the tha position to occupy the tone of or voice und the WiLY way WIL to look at coun count tel nel II when questioning qu him etc tc Orchard denied dellied It all alt He Be said allt had been In Boise Dolse several prior to the trial and had bad d frequently visited him demanded to tu know If It th the thought nl was W visit lug Ing him for tor any an other reason l than the tho nud glory glor of or the detective agency to which ho he belonged Orchard he know Do 11 you ou think the 1 of your OUI soul |
