Show MANTLES CAS1 E VOTED ON U s Vances Substitute for the Majority Major-ity Report Adopted NOT ENTITLED TO A SEAT Handersou Mores a Keconsiucration of the Tote 7r Vance Moves to Lay This Motion on the Table but Without Action tho Sennto Adjourns Leaving tho HIantlo Mater Still Open WsEuoTo N Aug 23In the Senate Mr Pasco Democrat of Florida gave notice today of a substitute t Mr Vests minority bill for silver coinage at a ratio of 20 to 1 The substitute proposes a commission of three citizens of the United States to be appointed by the president to ascertain and determine by J the 1st of January next the just ratio between be-tween the actual intrinsic value of silver and gold as a basis for the free coinage of silver After the result is reported to tho secretary of the treasury the weight of pure and standard silver t be contained con-tained in a dollar halves quarters and dimes is to be fixed and determined by him and silver is to be coined The resolution offered yesterday by Mr Peffer Populist of Kansas as to the violation vio-lation of law by national banks in declining de-clining to pay depositors checks in currency cur-rency was token up and a motion to refer re-fer it to the Committee on Finance made by Mr Hoar Republican of Massachu betts gave rise to a long and somewhat excited discussion in which Senators Voorhees Democrat of Indiana Gorman Democrat of Maryland and McPherson Democrat of New Jersey favored reference refer-ence and Senators Manderson Hepub lican of Nebraska Kyle Populist of South Dakota Hill Democrat of New York and Wolcott Republican of Colorado Col-orado opposed it and insisted on the adoption the resolution Mr Gorman pointed out that the adoption adop-tion of the resolution would be notice to the comptroller of the currency who would immediately proceed to enforce and thereby necessitate the closing of banks and cause utter ruin to the country A The cause of Mr Peffer was sustained r by Senator Hill who broke away from the leadership of Gorman and Vorhees and in direct opposition to the position taken by them made several speeches which showed division in the ranks Mr Hill plainly took a position which indicted indi-cted that he has opinions and views of his own not to be molded by those who have been considered leaders on the Democratic side in the Senate He undertook to draft some modification of the resolution but before he had completed them the morning hour expired and the resolution went over without action I took its place on the calendar where it can only be reached again in regular order or upon a motion supported by i majority voter vote-r Senator Stewart gave notice a he was disappointed in not getting the floor today I to-day to address the Senate on the bill discontinuing Icon I-con the purchase of silver bullion I that hb would seek the floor tomorrow and Senator Hill gave similar notice for FridAY next When the hour of 2 oclock arrived Senator Hoar called up the national bank bill and made argument against Senator Butlers amendment repealing the 10 percent per-cent tax on state bank circulation At the close of Mr Hoars remarks the national bank circulating bill waslaid aside without action and the report of the committee on priveleges and elections in favor of seating Lee Mantle a senator from Montana was taken up Arguments Argu-ments against the adoption of the report and the admission of Mantel were made by Senator Gallinger and Platt Turpie and Chandler replied to some of Mr t Platts points and Mr Pasco replied top to-p Mr Chandlers Mr Hawley aigaed in favor of the resolution The debate was closed by Mr Hoar In favor of the majority report Then at 515 a vote was taken on the substitute offered by Mr Vance declaring declar-ing that Mantle was not entitled to a seat The vote resulted yeas 3 nays 30 and so the substitute was agreed to Following Fol-lowing i the vote in detail YItAS Berry Michel Wiz Blaclbu Murphy Caller PRimer COle Pascoe Culom Perer Dixon Platt Faulkner Proctor Galnger Ransom Gprl Smith Gibson StockbIfe Gray Vance Barns Vest Irlc Vias Lindsay Washbur e Mian White Cola 1icherson White La Manderson MilLs T MItchell Or lthell S Bate Jones Arlr Butler Jones Nov Carey Lodge Cameron Martin Daniel Perkins Davis Powers Dubois Pugh ETtye Reacb Hansbrough Shoup Hawley Squire Hisgins Stewart Bill Teller Boar Turpie Hunter VYalthaU and Irbey Volcott 30 Manderson who had changed his vote from nay t yea in order to make a motion to reconsider made that motion A t moton motion mo-tion to lay the motion to rec nsider on the table was made by Senator Vance but without action upon it he Senate adjourned till tomorrow leaving the Lee Mantle case still open |