Show five are saved from froin plane on lake michigan engine afire affre and propeller gone navy heroes to rescue in ln time CHICAGO the navys valiant catalina Cata llna heroine ot of many a night patrol off guadalcanal Guadal canal was a prize heroine again to five fliers who crashed into the tossing waters of 0 lake michigan one of the clumsy looking flying boats her starboard engine blazing and one propeller gone hit the lake three miles oil off winnetka she bounced around she bounced on the surface rode out the heavy seas and gave up her crew uninjured ensign ensina richard brooks of louis ville the pilot who brought her safely down told his story with an affectionate word lor for the tha scarred veteran W we a were 0 patrolling the naval station 0 12 bombing range at 1000 feet 1 he related fire broke out in the tha starboard engine and I 1 headed beaded her down it was too rough to land but w we have an any choice we wa hit with a terrific crash he said then we bounced back into the air and the fire was out 1 I thought tor for a bit we were going under but the old girl rode out the waves like an ocean uner liner 11 saw the crash john seaman first class saw aw the crash from his lookout post at the tha wilmette coast guard station and reported it to harry albbert boatswains mate hibbert ordered the stations crash boat out we see the plane at first because of the heavy seas said then a couple of marine planes started circling and we knew they were marking it ft for us when we got there the crew was shivering under blankets on top of the wing we passed a line and began towing her in lt 00 jg john R bicknell of st SL elmo one of the tha planes crewmen was washed overboard as the towing started but was rescued by brooks other members of the crew were lt ag jg donald egly of petroleum ind bob merriman of chicago and earl singleton of S springfield aviation machinists mates all were given dry clothing and coffee at the coast guard station leading rule breakers an argument came up recently as to what sport game or competition lias has more rule infractions baseball football oot ball boxing golf tennis racing hockey bockey basketball or what in our pinion opinion the two worst offenders are football oot toot ball college and pro and golf basketball and hockey are not so far ar behind judging from the penal les ies inflicted but they are not quite up to the two we have named hurry up yost told me once that he be doubted there was ever a single football play without a foul that might have been called this sounds reasonable in football wo we have az 22 young active athletes all under binder tension body to body the four officials are usually hi high gh grade doing their best but four men cant watch 22 men scattered all over the field holding is the main offense there is illegal use of hands and arms there Is off sid side 1 e there Is starting too quickly there are any number of of offen Tenses sea that a player can commit often with no intent of breaking any rule in rule breaking holding especially the pros are subtler than the ca collegians Ile glans they know more they know how to grab an opponent and let go in the fraction of a second I 1 get this from ex cx collegians who have just turned pro we cant match the pros in holding all of them say they are much faster and smarter yet if officials begin calling too many penalties they ruin the game they are accused of trying I 1 to 0 hog ohp p abt so most of them try to call only the penalties that count overlook an offside or a holding penalty that had bad no effect on the play this sounds reasonable enough unless the sound ot of the whistle w dominated the play I 1 in n the matter of rule breaking fo football leads them all it Is the type of competition that leads to rule breaking a big part of it unintentional tent ional through that leads to holding offside or starting ahead of the ball also illegal use of hands |