Show SENATE WONT WON'T DIVULGE VOTE Mam Many Solons Protest Ag Against Secrecy In Up Tip per House Voting WASHINGTON March 27 By 7 ByThe The Associated d Repeated Pree-Repeated Press efforts to have the tho th publIc let In on the deep secret of how senators voted yesterday esterday on the nomination ot of Thorn Thomas F of ot New NewYork NewYork NewYork York aa a a II member of ot the interstate commerce commission lon were ere blocked today In the senate senale mat by practically Republicans the lam same combination of Republicans and ond Democrats Democrat that con con- confirmed con confirmed firmed the nomination Th The senate wrangled over the I Question tor for more than thoD two to hours and then voted 34 24 to 10 30 against going back Into executive sesSion to 10 decide the Issue of ot whether the vote on confirmation should bg be made public as a usually la is I done don In Inthe inthe the case caso cas of votes vote on highly con con- con appointments made mad by bythe bythe bythe the president The roll call on the question of going tolne Into executive session resulted as al follows follow For Republicans Borah Republicans Borah hart Brook Brook Brook- Brookhart hart bart Dale Gooding Goodin howell John John- Johnson son John son lon LaFollett LaFollette McMaster Norris Nye Nyc Nye 11 Dlease Blease Democrats Bleas Broussard Copeland Dill DIU George Ha Hal Is Is Kendrick Ming Kinf 1 McKellar May May- Mayfield Mayfield May field field Pittman Shephard Simmons Stephens Tyson Teon walsh and Wheeler Wheeler-ia Wheeler 1 Labor l Labor Farmer 1 Total 30 SO Against Republicans Ding Ding- ham hom Butler Dutler Cameron Capper Cousens Curts Curt Edge Edt Ernest Fer- Fer Fernald Fer er Fess Feas Gillett Goff Gott Hale Hae Harreld Hat Har reId Jone Jones of ot Washington Keyes Means Ieans Metcalf Moses Oddle PhIpps Reed of Pennsylvania Sackett Smoot Wadsworth War War- Warren Warren Vat ren Wat Watson on an and 8 2 21 Democrats Democrat a Edwards Glass Gilles Jones of New Mexico Overman U II and Swanson 6 u Total Tota U 34 The vote to confirm was 52 to 25 totaling 13 IS more mor Ihan the total vote vot on the tho th question of oan an executive session The Th row was precipitated by Son Son- SenAtor Senator Ator Dlease Blease Democrat of ot South Carolina who with Senator Norris Republican of ot Nebraska asked unanImous consent that the th vote voton on be made public In tant In-tant stunt tant objection w was wa offered by Sen Sen- Senator Senator ator Curtis of ot Kansa Kansas the Republican lican floor leader and Senator Mean Means Republican of Colorado on the ground found that two senators who ho were wera absent would have hav made mad Such uch objection had they been present rhey were unnamed Senator Norris Norri then wanted unanimous con consent lent for tor every sen en-ator en ator to b be relieved from th the rule for secrecy so 80 that lie he h tell or secrecy so that he might tell Senator Means again objected After Afler the th reading of an Asso- Asso A o elated dated Press dispatch detailing wh what hl bad d transpired In the executive session aslon senators senatore reed agreed that the vote vole seemed the th only thing thine that re- re re remained a L II secret cret and argued that thaI the public ought oue-ht to be informed about that Senator Borah Republican of Idaho said Bald he h could not under under- understand understand stand the reasons reason for secrecy recy and f served notice that hut he h would oppose further restricting publicity on sessions session I z nm ant Informed on this side Ide ld of the chamber Ie h te said tint there ther will bo be b more mor secrecy on on executive 8 sessions from now on If It we dothia do thia w will It h at th the mercy ot of what t seeps out through the th ky- ky holes and it would be he Infinitely h het- het bet better t tel tat to publish all the th facts act S Sen- Sen Senator Senator n ator Pittman Democrat ot of o Nevada evada also I protested against this eon on con constant slant stant secrecy while Senator Nor Nor- Norris Nor ris ris us char charged d that had senators the vote ote vot would he be b made public the th vote would have hav been different Senator Class is Democrat of ot Vii VIr- Vir Virginia ginia suggested that th the tho Nebraska senator was wae wa impugning the lh motives mothe ot of the th whole senate All All right returned Senator Norris |