Show 7 1 KIGE E FIVE CENTS PATHETIC APPEAL APPEAL- MADE MADEI I TO SPARE HAINS' HAINS I LIFE I ACCUSED SLAYER SLAVER OF PUBLISHER ANNIS I 1 I I T r I J tL i THORNTON J J. J HAINS Sketched te t d in While ilc He e was on Witness Witness' Stand Stancl I LA MAKES PLEA II Send Him Home to Mollie Is the Burden of the Peroration Perara tion Voiced By the Counsel for Man Accused of Murder ATTORNEY JEY FOR FORSTATE STATE IS MAKING HIS ARGUMENTI ARGUMENT I D D' Defender fender feder of Hains Asks Jury to Spare Him for the Sake of His Aged Father and Moth Mother Mothr r and aDd His Little Child J I CLOSING HOURS OF TRIAL i J C O o. o M t M M M M M t t t M t t M t t t M M 0 O. O 4 Yew few eon eon- York Jan Jun 13 13 V juror r 1 f 4 with siim bl bis red covered with vitla s sUr ur- ur 44 4 j f 4 con 1 planter r wn n. the 4 I f figure sure la In the lie trial of Thornton 44 4 4 helm at J lu huJo In 10 suite 4 of the bl rn fact t that Im time the trial In Is In tin its p 1 Int hour Im Juror Tn 44 i 4 ii 4 0 i i ilio lio chair Nfl An 4 2 antI 1 Vho ho I ii I. a 0 4 V 4 In Iii Astoria lie I 44 4 4 nIght In II amid Uti ws WI 4 1 4 from th tilt platform of t- t l a u 4 44 4 in trolley ear car 4 Sir Ir Darrin I m I 1 In now DOT well under q 4 Tl- Tl II lu iu his him ummi op 01 for the 4 Ho lie did not rend reach tiny any ell ell- 44 4 c 4 maxims to Satiny t hut ut b be a 4 J number for or t t tI tomorrow j n t. t fJ 3 I 4 hu Im had beet beu kelt from fh h 45 5 court room Toom nt m the t. t 1 il 4 I d tb the Ih i Tj 4 uj am for th the nu ere 1 eD T d ft 4 ax I I 4 r hen un in n id ten lell tb n tx iy 4 V I of ut her r liu 1 ur MiA t It T. T i r t. U t f. f t.- t. tiliO i iliO t t i. i l il t Jf M II L nd q ic Jl D u.-l u. I today ju Ju h if i or hIli p r I lio had to hon n chari 1 I b by b Mr IT u uk Jo nr Cor or Mood blood 1 I monc money J. J I In outlining h his case he lie e r reI re- re rJ i- i I I use o OZ ot the llIe gun IUt 1 I male At-male u US Oice Iio J I called it n a cannon and again mie I saId it Jt watt wag so 80 big big- that lie Jio could pu pm hI his bit biggest frost linger er into the c. rc s r- r Thornton Rains Hains smiled at time the prose prose- l i cu cutorA tor's tors opening even when ivhon r. r Darrin turned to him ant and charged l di directly di- di that Thornton van tho Jn spirit of or tho the tr tragedy anI and ad led Jed hi hJ hIe t I brother to Bay Uny Side that tho tIme murder m might mh-ht I eh t be be- committed d. d In closing his address begun bogun yesterday yester day morning Mr Air Mcintyre counsel for hams Hains said You Vou will be bo told that Thornton aided and abetted In Inthe too the killing of ot Annis Do you belle c that open openly re-ck re recklessly ho plotted the time murder mur mur- dor der of or a t. t fellow V creature even so vile a creature a as Annis and then thon h 11 hould could hide behind hl his demented brother broth broth- er I r am ama done alone I pass one ona of ot Gods God's own Into your hands You are aro tho the arbiters You are to say whether hadies ha ho holIes dies lIes a horrible death or lives lila Ills natural natural nat nat- ural life lite I ask you rou In the time name namo of ot God to spare ipare this father ather the tho sweet old Jd mother upon Lipon whoso whose face race you Oll saw the tle beauty of or r tranquility to spare the child Mollie Mol Mol- ol lie lle tho horror and shame of this con con- If It you ou decide aGa against Thornton Thorn Thorn- ton then thon I must come here again to labor for his brother If It he follows Thornton then his throe three children like Ilka Mollie will be upon an un uncharItable uncharitable un- un charitable world bereft of oC father tather ashamed of mother For Gods God's salt sake Jurymen send him back to |