Show STATE DEPENDS ON N TESTIMONY w tf f rt i Of ASSASSIN HARRY ORCHARD OR HARD mm HAWLEY DECLARES F HIM TRUSTWORTHY Denounces as Wilful Perversions Perversions Perversions All Contradictions of the Chief Witness STEVE ADAMS DRAGGED If II IN f 1 Argument Concludes With As As- As That Testimony Is Sufficient to Convict flo Bolo DollI Idaho JJ Jul July 20 J. J 12 E ii hawley talked nil all today sum um up iii tho the evidence on which lh Ow state slate of Idaho lO asked th the of oC William D. D Haywood who I Is charged with other lenders leaders o of the th Western Vestern Federation of oC Miners lIners with will Frank I tho murder o of If chat the state Is pendent dependent l wholly hoh Upon tI the thi tt testimony of or t Orchard with I. I such s ration a as Color j and crimes furnish turn Ish Is 1 I emphasized h b hy Hawleys Hawley's argument nt aiu and analysis iti il lr testimony The chief prosecutor pro I I charges s without reservation or exception pf p- p f i lion tion that every cry witness on in the tho present I and this sweeping sweep swep defence Is Isa a p perjurer reI l Includes the ll l'- l' accusation ing ng l Od l woman 0 I Mrs King her daughter daugh daugh- ter and Mrs irs Fitzhugh the tho Cripple r t Creek witness t who vIrn tt testified that 01 they f De Detective e D. D C C. y Orcha Orchard rd anti and i r y r cott t ihie he Insists he became Lecam secret confer confer- t per per-Ico agent II In numerous r I 4 i t In everything that has been bc n argued J- J r-j r 1 o far nr by thin tho tate state Orchard Is the th l Hawl y Imd insists t that the self self- confessed a oaI Is I the most r reliable t nn arid truthful witness 08 that ever took tool f. l th to tell equal and exact truth j. GOS GO'S De Stroll Strong All AH Ah discrepancies In Orchard state state- all contradictions to his Cl asser- asser cr- cr 11 nt arp designated a as wilful por- por qs ver Tonn Hawley Is really ill III and this morning he lie again agala asked askil 11 the and saying that f Jc gence nce of ot court jury he w Is hi afflicted with a t splitting head headache ache nehe That Ills his health affects his l logic Is a lIe He gets gels the names name 1 o ot witnesses s 's ml mixed eJ and places test T ori 1 i In the mouth of or an- an i lie Ut dwells so o much Juch on n Or- Or o o lar rl I tj J pu l n a- a J lJ S1 II l l oCio fr wJ- wJ i Ai constantly cor cor- ne nr are cit l 1 I L' L y h hI tr W 1 y L-y it nde analysis c rit St th t Vm mn front from the thO point ot or view of the luo stale tate I. I Governor GoodIng ann and ecU Detective ate ate- tc are U listening lo to the th argument ir no d 1 arc arc- exceedingly 1 pleased p with f s efforts This morning Hawley Haw Haw- ley hey provo provoked t a n. row ro roby b by staling that the 1 j defense tad had not dared darell call can Steve Ad- Ad 1 Orchards Orchard's 1 partner In crime ains brought Adams hero here said sold We Ve c ti downstairs In a a. hawley and he h. Is 18 Kite brought him here herc that cell The rhO 1 v 1 1 the defense cren e might ho have him handy to to tp truthful statement Orchards Orchard's J deny lon IUm z in many i- i that they were to together I crimes that tile they pulled the UH win s sF l re that n fourteen union non-union men to 1 sent F at Independence on t that tat at fateful sixth of June Adams was va the th man manof manof manot i stand to Ia contradict contradict con con- the tho of ot all men to tal take c Orchard but the defense hay hav having log ing no defense ne dared not call on 5 him k shouted Darrow Wo Vo object t drowning Hawleys Hawley's voice voiLe Mr Ir Hawley Haw Haw- icy ley Is Ig stating that which Is if not In tho the which he knows Is 11 V and that record uh absolutely fal false E The rue state brought Adams J here as ns their witness and they V lid IUd not make him a witness he because bound by his hl answers they Ih would be for Cor the prosecution to It Is improper initiate facts y Hawley and anti Darrow were read ready for fora i- i V a n l tilt Wt but Judge e Wood ended the the Jury controversy N telling Darrow c I Instructed to disregard testimony will he lie Is Hawley many mony given CI by hy attorneys r f t argued that Orchard had no w will ill no urn motive mOll for far the murder of or Beck and S McCormack at the Vindicator nor kt hatred of or tho the personal had liatI he lie an any men n who were slain at union non V i V Independence 11 lie He was vas simply a hired murderer who executed xe crimes crime on I Hawley Howle b. b orders orders- from Crum Haywood and controlling controllinG con con- Haywood as os the actual Western Fed- Fed trolling leader of or the chief chic mur- mur and Orchard V as St steve Ste teve e Adams ranks rank second to te toV said paid aId Hawley us as the favorite fa V V d V 8 in of oC the Inner circle cirI Ir ff I the Bradley explosion at UL ULy rr up r conr con- con prosecutor the prose Francisco Fan y beyond be- be ber beyond the state has shown l r tended t that was Orchards Orchard's story doubt that r yond a n dynamite bomb It was that r true the tho LInforth l wrecked that V not flat g ga p. p the Braille Bradley Into tints flats and t hurled In Inthis InV point street t Hawleys Hawley's IIa principal could this connection was sas mat Bradley radley I V and escaped 5 tint not have ha gone downstairs J asphyxiation If ir there had hall been a and x-estl- x In th the tho hall hail VV gas could have wrecked etl the tho bule which heV ho hp if the flip building in which h front also elso argued that u V lived 11 It was ilium- ilium explode not can lighted cigar I mating Ina gas doV dc- dc the w will vil 11 open for Cor fl fens on Monday V |