| Show THE MURDER CASK CASE the prosecution ution making things look very black for mulloy yesterday afternoon the jury ury in the trial of neal duloy for the murder of el george J hashes park city oo on the of august last was comil completed eted as follows robert Gor orlin linak sti saeno E F allen alien abart chaw jolia Ily dach F I 1 D chit hl t H 0 barb hart bart wro win normn george dou dollt prank frank shetton Shet toB A B R cuter caner ir 3 1 fabiah li mrs kate hubbes wife of the murdered man and dr bavard P le compte who cond conducted ducted the postmortem examination with dr childs MAHT wi MA HT r were the ottly only wit witnesses nees ex yesterday afternoon in i nis is morning dr mantor kantor was the first witness after him bim came james moffatt an eyewitness eye witness to the wool proceeding his testimony is substantially ly a statement of the whole case and and was as follows on oa the 1st ast of august last I 1 was living near park city it was M monday elic election tion day 1 I was in ia cupit capit brennann Bren nans saloon neal mulloy malloy sled and george J hughes were in park city on the evening of that day at the saloon a little after 6 pm p m I 1 saw mulloy malloy there saw hughes a few minutes minnus afterward they came in info the saloon separately mulloy had been in the saloon and went out before hughes came in he be returned a few minutes later when hughes and I 1 were standing at the bar malloy came up and said tie be had voted but had scratched the ticket he be was addressing hughes and 1 I hughes said he be voted the ticket whole mulloy said he would not be compelled to do anything he did not want to hughes said mid he would not either mulloy said raid he bad been once hughes said yes I 1 was wan several years ago I 1 was mist met on OB the street BY NAMED URN and at the point of the pistol was forced to run an engine down to coal vule ville 11 mulloy mullo loy sat said you knew everyone on the tr train hughes replied no I 1 did not SM malloy alloy called him bim a liar hughes said id he was not a liar malloy said he was a liar zd and a coward or he would fight hughes said he be would not fight go as mulloy malloy was too small a man a man maa as named med shears came up and said he knew hughes was not a coward mulloy malloy again challenged hughes and they went out to the middle of the floor door mulloy then wanted to go out ont and ana they went shears and I 1 tried to keep hughes back he said there would BE NO FIGHT as s he would talk the matter over with grulloy mulloy and settle it they ther then went out the side door and upstairs the crowd A diagram ol of the building was introduced and aid explained to the jury mulloy went up stairs and to a door that leads to 40 the higher ground at the back of the saloon there were about 13 steps to the plat dormand for mand then the door led out mulloy wenton went on the platform first and I 1 passed hughes and followed him shears went outside hubbes stood just inside of the door and I 1 stood between him bim and mulloy malloy mulloy malloy said hughes Hug bes you heel yourself youra elf I 1 am heeled 11 and moved outside into the open aar hughes jumped back to the middle of the platform shears and I 1 tried to keep out oat but he turned and came back to the door which was open he raised Us right band in which he be had bad a pistol he be stepped inside and put his bis left hand band on the door jam am pointing his bis right toward hughea Hug heas the latter started to go down stairs 1 I 11 beard A PISTOL SHOT and mulloy malloy said take that you s of a 0 mulloy malloy held the pistol in his bis right hand band hughes was going downstairs looking backward staga red the wall his bis left breast was exposed to M Mul alloy luys Is shot he be made no threats either by language or movement when bugies staggered mulloy at atte aim tor ft a moment and anen went hack shears tk isk d what have yon ton kne dane mulloy malloy mule male E lo 10 mallov warned warned him kostop to stop but bat he did not and mulloy malloy warned aim nim a second time raising his bis pistol and baving it you yoo come another step I 1 nive live bullets irk ih this for you to shearer then stopped toe next I 1 saw of hughes lie he was waa lying down in ia vie the saloon and toy thy th y said he be was dying the aiole traus transaction action took place before sunset on cross examination moffatt said e and hoeben goebes were mern hers of the same lodge of A 0 U W had bad not seen duboy before he be come cam cameleo elno court I 1 had bad an argument with him at that time about aboud election matters about a week ago I 1 looked at a copy of of my testimony before commissioner norrell did not read it because I 1 knew what I 1 had bad testified to when malloy and I 1 were arguing the barkeeper told mulloy malloy that toe the language be was using would not be permitted he was talking about D DC C mclaughlin I 1 had drank two or three glasses of beer I 1 WAS NOT DRUNK I 1 thought at the time there were two pistol pistols bots but I 1 think it was the echo and that there wo was a but one I 1 was considerably excited I 1 went on to the street and about ed to lynch mulloy malloy D C mclaughlin stopped me I 1 knew what mulloy malloy meant when he be spoke of hughes having been compelled to do something which he did not want to do they did not say anything further about the lynch lyn chime lne of murphy I 1 came lop p from price emery county to vote mr shears was the next called m the course of the trial |
