| Show y air nort ruil airl 11 I 1 it P AS 0 hilj ti lj 1 I I 1 jl ji i il A luelf I 1 ano d ARO 0 afia BY lly aaa awa ATO L T agre melq peir avd ayd ABE SPENCER FOUND liah trul 7 W ina lna n bleto present vo to 1 our r ennis tg abday gytha jj text of judge z banys charge change jury ry in tha ala ola claw son case ase y we were unable to tol 4 kon ion account ot jat 19 the tho original beng cwg given give to the the I 1 iury jury F as 80 as it Vs V wat wai s den deU vereiL and other othor arrangements it ift haung fallen failen hut but oy Y 0 llo ilo o lauird faulce 4 of if ours it wa a written charge and read as aljo ws i gentlemen odthe of theall july 1 1 tb the court cour charges fiare douthit yon you thit tnt the tile jows of the tho united stater slater at a t e of 91 america in i in ahja thas territory aliat who ha ja a ayio giving jiving a and nd m marries r rles ries another is guilty gulay R of P polygamy a and net nei that the first flitt count of 0 f ane indictment which tile the defendant stands charged states that on I 1 the farst day dav of att Ati gust Ms ae nia married tried viorence yi orence anit ann P dinwoodey Dino DI 1 odey with whom he asi isi still As lis ills his bif wife and from whom he has noh not been dinoi divorced ced eed and that af afterwards ter wards wands and aud audon nudon the fust day of jular 1883 he married tad lydia spencer jn chist te thi i j di clat clai Di district of of he wex tex vf f TT count the debeni defendant an byias has pleaded the courte urther anther clares chares L eshou you yoa an that tile the law presumes the defendant t ilmo innocent cent until he Is proven guib a reasonable doubt it is S not t D necessary 0 ostry stry that the eyl evidence dence shaula al 8 show mhd the marriages paaren ra occurred on the tho days th therein ren named there thera is no ao dispute in t evidence with respect to the mar marn ariage of the defendant to floreuce florence ann dinwoodey and the real contention Is 15 bj As to the charge that he married lydia spencer ti and ami ithal such licA luar iuar rig gaw gew judicial district to prove this marriage admissions of the defendant and circumstances are relied timm tho the court furtner further charges es Y you that admissions and declarations decia decla M df a f the hastily made are lre entitled ard to nut aut abely made an and 4 ident lne ine they should receive great weight you should not look at the circumstances in evidence separately ant should consider them with respect to td the fact to be proven an and with respect to each other E 14 id go eavor to tc discern diso erl their connections 91 kneir coincidences alku aru their disagreements if such they may present it andio and so considering themi to together bethe r give them sue sur such h weight a as 8 in T I 1 your best judgment anent they waybe be en cn 1 titled to eryou can the evidence before you upon any reasonable consistent with the tile innocence of the defendant it is your du duty to do iso BO with I 1 th respect to the i second count of the indictment the court instructs ins tracts you to fo ind and the adf defendant enfant not guilty on chat dalit the court further char charges als at IL a reasonable doubt is vue one bosq based upon reason reagon and such doubt mus muse be e reasonable personable in view of all ait tae evidence and if after au att impartial and careful consideration of all the evidence ltd 10 0 this Is case you can ca candidly edid say you are ard abt satisfied sati shed of the existence istance ot any uny fact essential to he defendants fend feh dant ants allt ku it you a reasonable doubt in at ade age cinq the file defendant not guilty guilty upon 06 hc first count af the L indictment also aiso but buit after a candid and cageful careful gon pon idera tion bior of all au th the evid evidence edlee eddee abu have an abiding conviction of the defendant guilt that you would be willing 0 0 act ic tipon upon it in ili hp tho more moge weighty matters relating to your 9 own ag ai affairs rains fains you have no reasonable doubt and jf if you yoa should ouid be so satisfied of the defendants fend ants guilt you should tind lind wm lm 1 vadare the sole judges of the credibility of the witnesses of the of the zhe evidence and atthe 0 the facts YOU should diligently inget invest 1 gate ate ato M and calef carefully ully ally top iop eop siti catli a I 1 der dei ernce enice liffe before defor you vou to give it such cb weight as you xon may z believe it entitled to when so considered but it if you sou shall believe belleve that tha any or dr witnesses havo have wilfully sworn falsely joany to any auy act maternal material in this bejou cae ou are 0 to wholly the ulc testimony jn bioty of suc sue such elv ell witness 1 1 besa w ag witnesses except so eo nar far f A 1 as a thet they thet thay may be by otter tnt tri trustworthy i evidence co ur sa with ty respect tp the form I 1 our oun thavil you ind jhb dele 9 pant polya polygamy lily as charged arged cah ach in iff ia th fars count af pf of r verdict will wui be tho the who iury jury U U tind find the U fandi tandi amt gull gui tv avon 0 n the lue ti first s r couii coula count ofa the indictment 11 if 1 not guilty on tho tile firsa first counti chuu lol iol 0 o ae JU nde M t he e forli rif verdict T the tho lury iury jury IL anh it ho odeli 44 tf not n i ick ili isaf itaf pi ot a rd a aln aw div riv V i fi to fo tim hourat 0 arof boin doln to tress y ress tio no verdict had been returned at f 5 the count court ordered a recess ece taken until ight eight and on ut at time da haurand haut and fifteen away a 11 t flo fio V grid brid nati flad cirrio tron Iron the tho lury jury 9 m eY ept ivied 01 CR the tha judge am received 1 notice fro from its twelve that aly were unable to a areg teg reg and asang alvn ith fth to pe dischar discharged 9 ot r 1 chejne now called te toe order and sent seat abr the 06 jury basl easl thy th entered the presence P desonce jadda and worn and in fa 0 6 8 t to mai mar th reed upon a verdict feldor t s man madi res ies responded in the me rit rie negative a ulve 1 ti lie ite niso aiso auts arts answered were d a second iq 0 to th ohp p effect that there theve I 1 mas maa 3 rno rio prospect of an agreement being reache dand hild alid the test ot R j it mt mr ackson then thed asked abw zhe abe ju jur jui livere vere 10 maior mhlor wiltes Cd for fon convicted aa thi this aly reply seemed tn in on 4 t st jt to sat iss IQ tha tt I 1 6 attorney tae taa ta judge tid ald the jury to ey were avore ed theyan Th eyad becu been ait oit rqn 1 itras 7 ic leaked ked out 1 a flat ali hll 66 currad juthe inthe ta fir tir ooin two of the bed hed 0 elt ell 0 on 4 fitak of ofie who was ivas lil lix r 11 ono win aln was far 11 base bae motive for tvr nt kli kii nation mhd T insul tedman called dla dis is ildi lidi ilari and they bot set and had to ye seph separated by ote foe b bliff aliff yi fl thee the 0 those who stood outfox out ic we ard C james r F woodman E vve ider lder R pj G lam iam s aboia A who in aa decided decide d art tri bri dri 01 anict A I 1 were edmund wils PT i M MW W I 1 vis boot booth geqrge george aze W blehr I 1 tuond I 1 charles charle ga gil 1 n and MIA eld Ellswort vol voi th ih daggett I 1 shortly A orti after the court i rpm W weds wees 4 cleared depute marshal marshai 2 a r h al ganni 1 presented himself ata hta afa at tile the residence 61 bishop III II B clain ak in the twelin twelfth Twell th wardi wards ana reque requested sted to see 4 mrs WO yra mart mar ara i carev daret G Claw clawson son sop althof of 41 rudger edger adger claws ant Jf moto Aoto isop elsw elaw i son songs q nat bat he waited pente of her va 1 andico rep nep xe led jed tha that he opted to e h r tim VIM 4 a subpoena abra the bishop ba hoi hoj stated seq ea thaine eid eld I 1 d tp 0 know khow h was 1 ivell t wish to sea search ff f toe xoe the holise said sald t the h c deputy ap apu daa dan s house uffa unlesS s you ave the he p papists baij 4 anthor author tb you on hayl bayl to do 9 f 0 I 1 id the Bishop ys the thy sid tid of 0 macca macra ed Z wc I 1 C not h warrant or at a least dl H I 1 I 1 I 1 he resorted ta the gaoa t tu I 1 that 1 get eer her anyhow 10 her isyou if you catl cati the tho ar but you must cowe como q nere hero wit authority allt aint horitY before eat 0 r 11 1 P cheri took tool teave reave at about abo u the same samp s all ail time nime the I 1 with wilbe lydia 1 lp p cel cul 61 efad d rooms opposite the kei nei ner ncr of the tenille block i was Z s by deputy marshals dodging f I 1 be bet bei i iad every tree in the tv vicinity affifi 1 oba 01 i them viem view to anc ic apor 1 I dr and on its being opened 0 a su s who orv was wag f fourie 6 within tle elo rho rhe lady was liepp notified ag af da bear pear beffre the distinct U att 0 this nis i As so an 0 it IN as oali ahas w M the courtroom court room this I 1 morning arnin am mr yx Y roar rian assistant As U I 1 3 s attorney 1 I johnp q to his feet t and alid ill ili wormed n for 4 th sll wi a i one of the important it 19 by the prosecution at th irv tato 1 e tri trl thial trial aa bu but who aho had been mis mik lins sins was waa Ns now ace accessible e I 1 and d luo bovea t thata thapa brew trial of the hl aa j f tha atal ys rudger budgen C agog ageg take lake I 1 a lc place P c at 10 toda to o da div to this h ants counsel objected amr air 4 inthe the witness W V in cyst bay huy and being ians answered erele IU in th pega negative said sald 1 1 IL did not zot appear that sito site lie W waa trying in to b evade evad e any process of df tt the courland cour tand tana conid appear ii t week r or next e t mouth month buth just as a aa fais jar noon and he saw stiv jio no reason tor sh such ai hasta besides le sides A hey s said sald tl it tork kork work vork nard nara hardship snip sulp on OIL bitne 9 slum skam summoned polled to tho the city derbm dis distant t parets cpr other cabes al qa 0 nu I 1 anted if they tho ivae wore wece I 1 d to te I 1 dr nonoi X 0 o awalt awall 4 alt ahre re fon for thi case cabe to be pose d q ajr r Benia ett th ildr ilar knes ess 11 hohag ho had taken taker an t acarl ia preparing re paring the dc fen k I 1 bc ati absent 0 city to todar today d dar day lit sit abid a arid A eredio rit ment was here herc I 1 for fol urged on tuat juat ground as well i 1 I 1 but nut ut 4 pr a insisted insist cd that the e tf f f b had ha atto at 0 an and JCu n pane fane ane atil 41 ill N ir lavor lavon at the ahe tha oddin op euln enin of af she the odd oda corts I 1 0 tats a an ahida d dt f thet they th defendant 11 as ires ices nic nie an att who rostad mad in n ph f the t he defense dei del vis pis for r a C awol qt ifo ito i ie iv legro 1 toll alid T that neason reason ida lda wl ll 11 1 L 61 0 tran lair iran pa pait part I 1 trial cou co coureton cou riton diton f it 6 ates gres d leq I 1 0 th 1 l 1 eo lip 6 di 81 i 11 akol 5 i udica 1 t wila c the theo ersil Mr sIL sol ra aa I 1 belgia W e V 1 bi 0 p all V eyl dyl pui poi p Y uy o f ar 1 to to 16 r thear ule ulc P r 0 o i court was pia pra t 1 atly aily e aar ass aad rt 9 it J J r trofa I 1 dj 7 IT it antt fall lluent fluent mi n ro ag 0 its ali nil ellb alib to a e affe 1 e I 1 uia ula Hid e e IN mitt awl trl teron 0 tr ti eda b eto ete mid t wa b ucil elt eit etna ornu il gly t I 1 va tt U til imely I 1 Q aa 6 tri iq 0 r vh 10 41 tib lr itt aws oeta e catl ti Kd kebe fefe defel detel ailt A ii or yum yue te eln C y 11 it 0 O tl nira fa tf eure ehre 1 ele elc 11 C y W 0 la in faed eadd M cj I 1 i 1 t aw pa q taid rows ja kril krik i VL ray arid 1 cave hitt hiko annc to fo the C 1 l fim fam IT cst eft owel butr Os from i 0 fir I 1 tufic ital lluu it it il fl 16 r I 1 ilo iio ii o wl sto d 0 q sla sia e I 1 it a and d tet tat cal cai upon t fi 2 1 efu T a 0 ry 0 r a c 45 41 41 9 p I 1 j a i 1 le 47 11 e 1 A E I 1 R ha 11 il la P url uri g 1 I dij ajr i jj r ta r this s q az t 4 0 0 N IT fad aad 5 1 t vilt or r 41 the dialed ud sla sia 0 0 r dha att ati 1 lil lri d t tar b raj MW pv t af pf lour eid eld toy arfy wem CA lata oafa wad b b dja ika 14 cl ough tv 0 nai fair A tinpui tat tal 1 L C j ran raa fiato p i I 1 v JF irit g 1 1 t I 1 at T 1 I 11 unit 1 1 atud atha d op hiis d eliis eiris IT r i lri iri elfa elai rel rei elfi ay fraro oram limn limp 40 to toutan JU tah nulty nuite 1 I 1 tji the thu 9 1 1 q 11 hll hil NI ilk lix kt ka 4 al alioa in a W wt 1 I A taw tam T doilia rance ranee upa uda 4 i jiann gilt exen exon en f 91 N the AP glaw rei pol ol 01 i tx jox L 0 4 o elders ao II I 1 matso mayso faTso 1 j I 0 o U all ail anu ireland areland Jr eland elarid I 1 1 jo ui ula uia roder ivha W 0 quy 9 to over be e 4 1 ki agy lar YO IX quAter pig PIP aj yo mil mii the ri I 1 a F M rj 0 ag paw naw ral ohp ahe 11 N gwim wk r ipg 1 I raj io 10 I 1 IL P hg jary zary JATY JA TY X brofn 0 fm the bue lue bristol V md P 1 aa jabr habr ti lii 40 tb pulp tw ia Y iff v ted teb y 0 Us 61 f it 0 I 1 ewid gt e 1 A I WT e 10 I 1 slat hlat e t i ns lisa it nt til ill R li sJ 44 or of tac aka ak quid i foe fos ere re of t and aalde A I 1 C abit if s th 16 ta i aa I 1 at u d oy or fk V nt A oui A wyl oll av laae laai fhe aret r 1 I 1 au fl yn 0 E I 1 1 4 r V 4 pmj ims jwj liag flag buhi cuvi if iua lud a g w pifei V Q IQ efti eji exi ayta iv hs pwe ayt in if iti klitta lr I 1 ul A t J ta aj I 1 pa eq WW 0 t N all arl rein lab qute I 1 e P IV iq ji WL i I 1 jt to elt elv tf I j I 1 11 vat vav oki oti gairc jid fid vi i it uv ull ura y t t ti I 1 at n i 1 e ua a conj r t t f r j 1 0 iee tee ma L A I 1 a d 3 ensign fhT lami JAMI beu ked true tru e with v an unsullied record as a servant Kt fOod to ff i 4 i iivo tico ro olt HIT at 1 rimu remu m no ff 6 tim urr |
