Show MURDERER Atty Aty Richardsons Rapid and Searching Questions do Not Disconcert Him HE MADE TWO CORRECTIONS C Insisted He Was at Wardner Wa at Time of Outrage Lighted One of the Fuses HIS GAMBLING OPERATIONS tl l for fO c Laid tl S on Oi Admitted oil cli lil 1 Drinking ij Ida UI Juno 7 Tho of or Harry lalY Orchard wit witness ness S against Wilam D Haywood ln wood has his carried down to 10 tho th dynamiting of f tho ut at Cripple rec Colo lu September 1003 and lud its progress pro Indicates that It wi con cou much more than jho direct examination After A COI protest from Or Orchard Orchard chard against the of or Atty AUy nich which ho said cut cutoff off ot his answers and a I wrangle counsel counse on the subject the tho of ot witness as lS to t his ex experiences in tho Couer country was vaa The fhe defense laid lal the tho foundation for fora forn a n showing that Orchard was not ut u t tho day the Hunker Hill Hi and mill was blown up and uld then ed on 01 to tho thu life le of ot Orchard In Utah Ital 11 t 1899 1900 und un 1001 1901 Tho wit witness ness mss owned up UI to a lot of or at which he repeatedly rep lost his hla earning l The defense showed that until after aCel he went to Cripple Creek Creck in hi the Ihl autumn ur Orchard hud had never known Hay Huy HayM wood M or 01 Moyer or hu w 1 IUles that t he stole Itoh oro and Imd powder from tr tor The rhe witness that he heard Moyer and Haywood deliver speeches at tt after Uel tho strike of or 1903 against any al violence vIole Atty At ol sought to lo show that Orchard hud hl suggested tug blowing up th lW r powder In the Vindicator and an while the witness admitted that thal be he told AV J r Davis of ot the existence of or the powder pow er and that the Iho Idea Ide of at setting It off of had llad come to him ho JIO swore that Dals suggested u tho act Orchard William llam 1 who at the tho call of ot Mr Ir from the tho back lack of tho courtroom us cs the man mal who had aided him hl in 11 tho experiments that led to Lo making the thu J finally used In the Vindicator leall ORCHARD RESUMES When Orchard Orchard resumed the tho Ilando day dRY Atty ty Richardson began tit at once to ply him hll with wih a 11 rapid of oC questions Before answering Orchard asked per pel permission mission to correct two statements Of ot yesterday He said he had neglected to give the Lw name m to of ot his sixth sister Hister Horsley Horley who married a man named Rogers and iI who lives In New Nework York ork somewhere Orchard also said that he stated yesterday ho IJ had no 10 partners in JI the tho wood business In 11 Burke Durke Idaho He today that there two men cn to whom he owed nM money and Ind to whom he had prom promised an al Interest In the business While Orchard was making tho Iho lat lal latter ter tel statement Richardson interrupted him with wih a ORCHARD Tim attorneys for the tle state stale nt it oleo objected to counsel cutting tho vit il nesa off orr Orchard also protested to tC tho court saying Nill he would to have IW the opportunity to state II o Ida hI an ln before being Interrupted Wo Vo both cant loth talk tal at the saino samo ho said to Mr l Richardson and ald yesterday a you ou asked me mc new before 1 could answer tho old ones Counsel again joined In II tho protest Sir Mr Richardson became some somewhat what hat excited declaring that If It it was Wt tho of ot counsel to start a row between en him and the tho witness ho thought they might Just as II well wel havo hlo it Il out at at once olce Tho Te witness will wIl ho allowed to an al tho questions without HUM Hal Judge JUdg Wood sternly and the examination proceeded OUTRAGE AT r Orchard admitted that while he h was 11 In II the Idaho country ho quite quie a I gambler playing po poT poll T I of o tho Iho time Ho 10 was asked how ho vot the tho day tho Iho de to go SO down dawn to 10 blow the aunko 11 Sullivan 1110 mil I I said Bald ho did dil not remember Sir i Rio wanted tho to Jiamo all 11 who wh attended tho nicotine 1 Ho Ht gave tho named of or 01 six nd Richardson ith IU n ni y YOl u Not all I r hut but al thoy aro T only onH who o name I 1 can Iro ro 10 01 nt 1113 3 coolY tl Tho attorney next took look tho it I description te of ot the Iho f jo train Tain which tool tho Iho Joiners t to Gardner wild It Jt VIM of ot 1 cur omo bo hu Ing freight and others pas PIO 1 Arc 10 you OI sure WIIO 1101 that thu t you were wre not at 11 nr Ir whon this c Declared I 5 Miro Inre camo thu i l I I Olio LIla of ot tho Iho which tinder tho mi Mr II wanted to tl III the Iho of or rill ni helped unload tho powder at mid who wll helped I H I the mill 11 Orchard eno they Iho nil ho could 11 11 I I Ill yu YOI l Hay wood Moyer o ot or 01 nt n t time f Nu pr worn won not with lh you 1 at lt tl n WI Wil JNo N sir not nt Unit I of Qt IDAHO AlO TO 0 MUmS ho left 1 after th IlA up ot f the Hunker Hill n I l mill ID hI Ho Jo w Wl I I II I l taken over thu Ih years from to 1 0 In detail explaining to 10 Mr 1 Richardson on he worked where he sot ot his hla money and td where lie h went from time to lo Orchard sold he worked on an average of or 10 JO or 11 1 months montha a year In 11 tho Iho mines of oC Utah Nevada and Ari Arl Arizona zona 2011 He e Rambled part art ot the time Did Dit you YOI lose when you OU first began ney ICY to demanded attorney Not always Hut Bul you ou finally sot Jot so o the other tel fel fellow tellow low always lost did ld not you IU Counsel for fOI the stale objected to this form of questioning but it waa wa allowed by l Wood WoodI I nearly always lost quietly re replica reo pl t the witness HIS HS JOUR t GS In 11 reply t III to Richardsons questions queston Or 01 Chad traced his hla s from place to place pace Tho ho attorney wanted I to know how hol much mich money the tho witness had at place Orchard supplied tho In Information formation to the boat best of ot his recollection r tion admitting that thi a percentage of or his wages went over the gambling table Ho seldom remained morn mOIl than Ihn from one to three treo months In any Up to 10 tho lm 11 tuu mo ho went welt to lo Colorado In 11 1802 Oi Orchard chard said he had never heard of Haywood Haywoo NO cI or 01 Orchard said ho ha did dil not hear heal of ot Gov GO action acton In suppressing tho dAleno Aleno t troubles until soma time tm after uter he left Idt the thc state of Idaho The rhe witness said it was his on Initiative which took him to Colorado Colordo and said that no ono connected with Ith the Western eat ern Federation of or Miners had hat urged his going At that time July or August of 1902 there thore was no TO trouble in 1 Cripple Creek Arriving In Colorado Colordo ho went to work In tha Iho echte mine m ne and renewed his membership In tho Western Federation of ot Miners ners Joining a local loehl heade 1 by b AV F Davis Dayla who wil had been bool In charge chUo of the party parlY which blew tip 11 tho Bunker Hill Hi and Sullivan mill 1 t Atty Aty Richardson asked tho repeatedly about his gambling o experiences xI II laying much stress on this fea fe of his clos When Whon tho Western Federation of Miners ordered a strike at lt Cripple Creek Creck In II August 1903 Orchard said ha Ie went out ont with the other union men menTho menh Tho h strike sIke committee was composed of W v F Davis Sherman Parker and a aman 1 man named Orchard said l he hal heard that Parker and ton aro dead HIGH GRADING EXPERIENCES 11 Richardson next took tho witness through h his hIl high grading experiences in the Vindicator mine When Whon you said s the other dl that Iha t tou you ou hud high graded In II the Vindicator during tho Iho strike you OU simply meant that you Ol wore an era thief I dont tont know what you call rl It I ro r Orchard We Ve took tok the high class clas of ore oro out and sold aId It 11 YoU often made an high as lS 5 or 30 3 a 1 day you from high grading Yes Yet Orchard said Raid he also 11 0 high graded while the tho strike at work In the Vindicator TUB fIE VINDICATOR vI In his direct testimony 1 Orchard said sall hl hod hOll reported to I Davis tho finding of ot ofa a 0 mine carload of ot in tho Vindicator Up to tho th you told lold this I to 10 Da Davis D vis Is had thero full Illk to you 01 ot proposed violence to fo tho mine asked Mr Ir Richardson No sir sll Yon broached the tho You Yo Id Id the tho leaders leders of ot the Western lo e 01 of or Minors had blown up The Tho who had hal told him of or thin Hu 10 believed It w IS Arthur Your 10 object was Wa to 10 to I tho of ot thin I felt frit homo omo to 10 the Iho mine own cm and had hUlt I bought of tr It Tho fh nol lul had hal boon llon brought In and alI I were welo running UN iK around to 10 know thoro A sli nil how he h iamo taloo wan powder In III the he h hid had stolen somo HIA unit and wild loll It I Waa thoro anything In 11 your experience ence at Ida which suggested the tho off ot of ot this Ihl puw to you youIt YOI It I inny 1110 tha thu that thu Ihu powder In tho mine ho 11 off oc Im from you or U from iII From J Davis Duls Ho Io hl ho would nui 10 KOO OO to It off nr ho mil hall communicated hil bin thought hl about blowing up tho thomine mine to II lI Orchard suld 1111 1 thre about 60 non lion nonunion union mull working In ihu 1110 Vindicator lor mine Hu II he II O 1 UK till lunching oft off of Iho of Mould have huo mount ilm death If all allAnd And 1111 you I in hI murder CO I imm mun for I iU in III lunch thu py Did you iho tho m n III at lit I a 1 An n to 10 this Ihl question 1111 by h Ihl Orchard i ld thill to III Cripple during hI a u edi ursine werL II tu tuI I fj H I of ot any sort Ol be I nay Ing they th would surely be bp charged up to 10 the Iho Federation of MInei HAYWOOD CAUTIONED ED STRIKERS Haywood spoke to It the effect the strikers against drinking and all gambling as well Haywood fay lin that the tho mine owners would like violence for thoy could then bring In III troops and break bleak up lip till the asked Richardson I r dont remember that he ho say a that any nn violence would react on and nr was not to bo be countenanced I f believe ho did With Ith a II man named Orchard said ahl he vent to the Vindicator mine to attempt to 10 fire the powder A eager discovered them and they the shot at him This incident canned c an abandonment of or the plan of or blowing up lip the Ih mine at tilt the time Orchard said ald the mine WAS guarded by the when he and his companion went down hut there wa one passage left unguarded Two months lator the matter blowing c up the mine again taken up Then who ho suggested It this time lime demanded Richardson Sherman Parker and Davis Dals PLAX lLA TO FIRE FlIm Orchard said the plan thin th time lime was to 10 attach a IL pistol to a n lift bill bar barlit lit nl the seventh level Tho cal cage would lift this bar u discharge tho pistol Into a u box of ot slant gIant caps which In turn tum would firo the powder Orchard said Will Easterly helped him conduct experiments along alons this line JlII Is In 11 the room asked Richardson in a loud oleo A Amon man stood up UI In of ot the court awl was w ts commanded by b the at nt attorney torney for fol the defense tin to como down the center allo and confront the wit 1115 Is that the Easterly Ba you moan mean Richardson naked of Orchard The witness looked at lit tho new 1111 cornet coiner undo and quickly replied the man Orchard tho were conducted in an abandoned haft hOIlo Soldiers were stationed within yards but nobody said anything to the tho revolver ts and exploding caps Cap Whose hose did you Oll use Zit 1 own Orchard said Ea terly told laid him ho bo mixed up UI with ex ox explosion Did you ask him to participate pa te teNo No NoHo NoHo Ho declined d without being b asked Y 8 us ho h 1 said he was an officer of or ortho tho union SECOND ATTEMPT For the second attempt on the mine I lo Orchard said he was promised 00 you going to lire Ire the carload of powder No It was to tl ba bt a 11 bomb this time Urno Supt McCormick and anel Mel Buck H k wore killed a week later lator Orchard supposed their thell death was due to his bomb Hil Hilly Hilly ly helped hel 1 the tho bomb bombIn In 11 June 03 said he mar mai married ried Mrs Ida Toncy a widow with nith children Her 1101 wius WIlli but a short distance ell from the Vindicator mine The Th ald the th woman continues to live lve them th 0 1 KO 0 till far an ho hOt knows Orchard said uld ho went to l Davis and Parker for tOl money after the Ih death of o oMd Md and Beck They tho next day Orchard admit admitted ted ho hall had felt folt sort Bore he had hul bean uen refused money for tOI hi his at attempt tempt on the tho mine why ho Informed iho Florence and Cripple Creek Railroad company COlli 1111 n of tho th 1 miners plot to wreck the train Orchard Mid hl ho wan n It because he hI had not been urn 1311 ploy to do III the tho Job The 1110 luncheon lun heon until p II m Will at lit this point EVIDENCE DOVETAILS US Juno 7 following the 11 timan of ot Harry Orchard thu principal pal In tho Haywood In with referred to aro d in I local OIa I morning V II 1 who wax Willi the victim of or u I bomb laid In a l vacant lot Int through which the tho wall UH in ilL the th habit of lit to In and from Iho 1101 lIu III H thAt In III with the iho with the tha killing of Wally by II tho bomb Intended for fOI Mm IllIn Mr Ir Een hIll wf Ir of or thu former 11 1 oln III recall il Urn V tho tha night 11 t whon two men her IJ Orchard of following on Oil u 11 certain for fOI tha th of r him hut but that dl covi r d 1 thai 1111 On WIB W not an und gave It up III Wolf olf whom he 1 1 lilt II h hud 1 iiri d an 1101 an III int In III handling mall from to a imd I lid labor Ie bor union mini of or WM Ihu lol him 1111 he h would kill 01 ln Ki ri fI MIK liil 1 tor hud P 11 him from hemming ft 1 mUll 1 reasoned uc J t I to thai ii for 1 tinip P lii th iVnOr 01 1111 M ilm hili to I URMI 1101 the Ihl country to In dl I nr or hi Iol m 11 ii rot In iho lh II i Mih t 1111 Th pur tI ri bonime h lie and 1111 Orchard tin ln I rr fr that hi h never 01 had ui ti d tI with fUL a n st to t ti i bv h a I sproUl r 11 tn I i nj Ih tint iiii 1 for COl iho of tiC i al I i V 11 Y I lillI M ity Juno lun 7 It 11 I of or j i s hero hIo mi 1111 w ld In nn thai hn hI hud HIP trial In ol ht nn l KI n letter bin ht lir Hi II said ld In h paid no to i In h because they th evidently dIll did nut I crimi 1111 li Ir I hi I very I on my II PHI lo 10 n II about thin t I ii hauls or I about the 11 an I Mr lit l a 11 I e av a II lt i il I 11 and 1 I am 1111 only WIIt iK in u l prim railing me to 10 Holne to toJ j ui tI h i just t m will be hI and what I know n i me and these various I mill hut but I dont want in 10 do till a II tiling lIhlA lull ibm ran h K oll iii In tin II lluhi of r I IIII to In any un din in III tin till II I 01 III |