Show GOES HOW MUCH BENEFIT CAN WE EXPECT TO DERIVE FROM IT m A sia kiple ilc irk in that of ferniany Gerni any abe t iny wn W lc duty aly or hii iro iHlo iii and buc aloit at tit ill all chero ii 1 tu to it II so far iia as the reciprocity policy of tile tho arf M ant nt administration tends toward tile tho improvement of our foreign coil I 1 aco it ilia lie deserving of favor and were it not for other reasons reason such favor would ix bt freely accorded to it even fly by tho thota those ta not in with the pre present aut fiscal policy first ot of these ILI ri is that reciprocity if i evidently intended to ob obstruct eruct the progress 4 or of true tariff refo ir principles anil and another a natural he alm ilm inc rice nce is that abero exists a inar airest disposition on the part of lu its supporters benj to exa exaggerate ceritto ge ritto tho the benefits likely to a accrue C ironi front tho the several treaties effected this I 1 is the secret ol of tho the of tho the high fugh protectionists projectionists over whit what is in reality Ki lity vollie noine coil concessions ceL slon a to low tariff principles principle it and is fill arll of tho the artil tl attitude of if tariff reformer ii ij tire tho latest treaty with germany Is ii 11 good of the truth of this it lik ims been held J up a wonderful combi cambi nuion of s acumen ind and diplomatic sagacity higa city on our flat t and a tremendous s forward in ili opening up foreign tit til it alteta ibets to the farm produce or ol till tins an it imposing show lot ha buen bren made inide by placing sido by ade tile old rateb of duty in germany on the products antl the new and 1110 calling ir attention to tilt iho sub concessions secured it to tins country it must be that on these loot look we well 11 airl had tile the fonce been made lo ID tile the united states abates alone might inisha even hivo been invest invested fd 1 I with somo importance As it is tile tho follows follo wm I 1 shows that they affect a i small mail part only of our exports ti it Teri nany ind that competitor with U us tor for the getman del mail market in ili agricultural pill pio products ducts has been accorded like comes s I 1 ami is in ili A natural position to take I 1 enuch I 1 killer advantage adv antao of thern theli than we a te are aiu during tho fiscal fisc year ended juno julio ua IM the list last li st tor for which I 1 lull all details aro are available arai lible our total exports to germany amounted lu in title to 21 i a very considerable trade but of this total tho the articles upon which v hichi the duties have been levied ravi d furnished only UT it may of courts course bo be argued that tho the latter total small on oil account to ot I 1 t la I 1 critics lint but ila as will vi bs be shown later on these duties dill did not prevent heavy ili importations 1 po rt adious front other european countries of similar milr ti products nor when wo consider how much the acius or cr duty on thu the above year s bial importations porta t ions tit lit tho the revised rates would have been to gar lauy does thero there appear to bo much in in the argument itself the following table shows the amount of duty actually paid what it would havo been on tile the reduced scale and tile tho mount amount that would nave have been saved by getman importers importe loly duty clity diffor alil New tariff tote Wl treat icat S vm 1 X S 1 vote 11 re e as 1104 1 ap ai SAW 8 6 I 1 oats aim 6 aw W 1 balu Mi ilo ia iw iia JAs llin III wa 4 IT hiller Hn ller b 1 I 1 i I 1 alu oxen 1 SUS 3 4 llor q aa ni 1 ni floor c tc rati 1 25 TI wai U totals siaw im A c 1 1 4 in ili addition to tile above there I 1 is a i to rc of ij dill y on oil imports of lumber anti and willii we cannot exact exactly c calculate alc but bet making makin nn in extravagant allowance for it the entire reduction in duties on our exports to Gerni germany any for tile ear lysyj 11 OU would come half a million collais doll dol lais ns this result appears still more trivial when contrasted contris bcd with tile the saving which the to aultna hungary w ill oil 01 imports front from that country the german zen iii imports front froin austria iro returned atz at hi ly IV on oil which old duties anio amounted anted to R JUS 62 under tho the new treaty these duties are ro rc ducer to a sins saving of 87 0 OUO eliy bent upon it effect il t at i commercial tomm ercul union etli ati autria tria italy etc should have e twell willil willing ng to t relend 1 end consideration to the united states ano also to secure its Anio trade in ili beet t needs no explanation with tho the a abbio bo 0 kewis kiwis dign es before us the il against P nusia 1 I by ill tho new treaties will vill v ill xv vt lont doulet leive tile tho effect of chi changing rigin tile boarer ol lut jermanus jerm anys arlin supplies to boino es cs tent lout but then the assumption that any any ma mau tt lial benefit will accrue to us ris thet c front efrom ia n not will well slip supported ported the following chov s Geri iierman ys imports iiii ports of if tae four hviding Irn ling cereac cerci Ls j in 16 b i with chief sources ot of supply in thousands thou sandi iud or of bubels total tal il ausilia Au siriA ru hk U US S wh Wl icat I 1 islai i 1 01 ga es I 1 nii aai if sw va M iv onto its 1 ib CM C id 4 milie ll 11 3 iam att 7 2611 i all ili only cue in instance tance ineize docx the united status stat reilly leguie aigul e is as 1 a I competitor will Liiro Lu rolV pran 1111 A 0 of supply ind and it must bo be apparent that aultna Aust ni and not lot th fill a Ou countr auntry will ill derive tho benefit of lower duties oil nn grain tile the I 1 eduL tion in her caw ilk not be by estl a 1 l which fiust still op mate to our disadvantage in cu king OI 01 oven with it ill la thero is till still t 1 a I confide ration were we wo market for foi imports iiii ports iii ast have ili ordinary year eul been delv drawn 11 froin russia we do not of that competition in dioro anoro duport iiii but on tho contrary ary intensity it tf if It kusia is discriminated against even to the point of exo exclusion wion by it simply moans means thil that her kalu plus applies hup up plies will lind find their way in ili still greater volume to other counties I 1 ort in at britain tor for ii it itani istance 0 o und and nhat lait we might gain on the one hand would certainly be more thin than lost un tile othel 0 awing ina to tile the extraordinary state of if things now pie 1 allu U bope preheat cut or immediate Ox Prience is ia ot of no value in testing the soundness of tho the abot aio co a analysis but with ii at return to normal conditions it will bo be seln that the treaty of winch which so much lias has lie beau made Is it a emal email smatter aik itter indeed new ew york dally daily bulletin |