Show i 1 HIGH PRAISE fOR j ARTH R S O Oi l i i Noted Eastern Strongly ft Commends Work of Utah I Composer RECALLS S SPEECH OF BRAHMS i Have i Coi t of ot III II Su Sti Sul Sil l c pro mi Moment ii t Y I That Tha Arthur Shepherd of Salt SaIL at Lako t belongs to a class ot u muslI I 1 clans nil l tho Ihn th members of which can Cn b I i enumerated In II a dozen of or news newspaper ji i paper type output Is I tar fur from rol rain fell unscrupulous In n I or un Unguided r guided In la f 1 the nw L t ll fan n of t Lawrence Oilman tho the musical i of 01 Harpers Weekly In tn an in 11 I I cia clo published hed In th the currant number lumLer L Mr II r till GInian man primarily on Oil the i jj 1 lack Inck i ot if f sincerity Incel in II an 2 und and the triviality trl ot 01 the thet t Tish popular themes After Atter of ot thu th tendency ho says ny ho he wishes t I ti i gI e credit and 1111 recognition to a n 1 IM IMf f n tain slender hut but output A i which Is l nt tL onre once anti and Ho 10 lb then mentions In thu i Class cl ca s Join Henry I anti and Arthur Shepherd the young mu musician IU kuIan of ot Bait SaU Hal Like Lake City who won the tho v prize with his I for tor u After ter the tIu th work of ot N th tin othor oth r compose Mr 11 Oilman goon goos on n to for tor a 1 whole column fully fy 1 a half hal of ot that f Jact jac ac d d to Mr II and his luls work SUS Su uy a Mr ti h ht Oilman Ulman t t With Wih Mr 11 Arthur Athur Shepherd whoso somewhat adventurous 0 ot of th lh the 1 kl prize for tor com coin composition L position brought ht him re Into public notice a 1 few tew weeks ago lO go one ha him hatho hal tho lenty curious experience or of ablo to write with the ness Jl S of o if a n positively 1 Mr Shepherd Is 1 no 10 than he he yet yel whatever ho IH If Im definitely from the center of ot Ids luI own creative faculty Il Im ImI A I p may to one Indeed he not In Infrequently frequently doe the speech ot of Brahm but one ono realizes that thuit time tho ton ham lias no vital lal significance for tor or there Is II also alsi al o the tho c Iio ot or Mr Ar Shepherd himself I a volca fresh tresh confident ami virile virie And moreover Kit lit It II lie hm noted that hn ho writes t Ith a sure pure and ond 11 wIth wih nn An command of or the materials I m of nt t Ills Ws nit art HII him technique Is I 5 extraordinary one nn on hil hi It k kl ka hla hl hI and und Variations mini and his hI Prelude for Cor or piano with wih an as n much mulch won wonderment derment nn nii I pleasure pl u lre they urn aro his bin hil opu one lne mimi and two Iwo yet ct In them Ih time hi pe hm r ot of the composer Is In II neither n lher faltering Incoherent nor I Hut But what whal Is II I of it lt far Cur greater conme cnn e Mr AIr Ir facile un on undaunted UI daunted tl 1 II js tho time vehicle hicle of nt II a it temperament or of singular 11 maturity and force Ills Jia lel C of ot lila his bl feeling for tor tho the architecture of ot tones tOle Is II exceptional 11 It la 13 I exercised a u lit lt littie tie t at mit lt tho expense een I of ilch and ti signifIcant color yet t It makes no ito 10 doubt for tor or nIl and proportion and aul must continue to In have hiI of oure our Its I it nud ltd its I no 10 less leu than Its 11 Chop Ins 18 lt lla an lt IH lino ot of An tn Of Mr Shepherds ln n IlloW poem A Stir Star In the I I hove havo left lett little room to speak k In detail I The rIte writ Il ban hUK Itch of or o the effective live tive reticence tho lit continence or of emo T tion that thU his work ho hohas iY has hlll learned urMel the ti art urt of ot bin 1 his hl resources resource re for tor supreme and climatic urt art I which In Iii thin Instance Is II I reinforced i by hy tho the noble 1110 of at Mr Ir Lanes Lanca Lan verses veries I I 1 have havo singled mingled out cult for tor this recent im ulc by hy Mr lr Gilbert and amid Mr Ir not nl 1 It I Is tim tho the best beat of ot otIl Its excellent kind hut but It H Is If representative Il of or tho ot of a I small It If growing body hody bod of o artistic endeavor lelor whoso whose who o achievements however limited In volume vol I are aro fr not excusably to bo lie IB Ig a |