Show UN OLE SAM HAS NO LUST OF EMPIRE Not Crowd Crowded od ed the tha Philippines On H 14 m LQ 10 SRI Soya Latter Culla Call R it LI Liar r thio limit t M May after I 2 tb the Philippine bIll bUi was taken takeD up In the Senate Mr Pettigrew save ve notice ot of a sub lub which provides for the cessation ot of and ancl negotiations for tor the ot of an Independent guy luY er ment In the Philippines Mr Spooner Wt then took the to speak peak on the bill Mr Spooner agreed with most mOlt ot of the speech of Senator lentor Lodge LocIe but he wu was 1 lees radical I It there had bad been no war with Spain a treaty transferring the Philipp Philippines to tb the United States have received a vote tn in Ih the Senate Tb trusteeship under God Gud would not have Ive been accepted We would have said ald our lImit duty was wa to our ow own people There was wal no lust ot of empIre m l am among on U no nor I Is there now In Inthe inthe the wise It ta is often used Mr Jr Spooner said that on request ot of Admiral Dewe Dewey after fter the battle of Manila Bay troops were sent nt to Manila The They were not sent to aid Dewey wey to hold hi hs position but to capture and hold Manila No protests f et were ere made mad against sending I troops troop We held anla when the treaty ot of Paris Pari was 81 adopted ot of the treaty he said aId there Wal a tIme when be was wal to It but he would now IA say that with all 1111 the f facts ta before him he could not see lee how bow the President could do other than Ile de demand mud mand the celli on ot of the The sentiment pervaded 1 the entire peep of the country countr that the PhIlip PhIlippines pin pines could not nol be left leet with To this point lie he to the unspeakable horrors of Spanish tyranny In Cube Cuba II If said that It the Philippine had bd hadnot not been taken b by the States Spain would have havo resumed her sway In Inthe Inthe the nd We would ha have been obliged d to march our troops out ot of Ma Mann nn fills Is Spain marched tn In The bondholders would have furnished the means to carry on a war ot of Spanish conquest We could not do as AI w we did didIn didIn In Cuba demand a relinquishment ot of lOVet from Spain of the Philip Philippines pi pines Spain could not Dot have kave Vented an each In III Iter he over oer th Ih l ciu ot ill It WI WIt t er 0 8 or th of 01 eli all but Filipinos In and Ind asked anything he wo wolie worse lie he maintained that under nde th theme eon con no one could seriously demand an 1 the withdrawal ot of United Stat States troop Zulu Mr questioned the t or of the order and a sharp contro ersy ensued Mr Spooner said uld It came ORm In an official statement from tb the war de department Mr bir Petti charged that the docu received by Mr Ir Spooner wu was manufactured evIdence for tor effect In this hIr r Spooner uld It was U ot of equal creel cred with much that Mr had presented Mr Pettigrew In reply ply said that odi elal reports we were good u as evidence against tb the government but not DOt the Filipinos FIlipino fro retorted that the South DakotA Dekota lucid that everybody wu was a liar who produced proof against Int Ute the assertions which he Pettigrew mad against the government fill remark was ae applauded by the galleries |