Show SAM HAS HAG NO LUST OF EMPIRE N Not Crowd cd ad the On H m fl TO lO F W Cal Calls a aLiar LI Liar r lio t Ills Washington May la after I 2 tb the Philippine bill 11 was taken up In the Senate nat Mr lr gais V notice noUre of oC a sub whIch provides for the cessation I ot of hostIlities and negotiations for t the establIshment of oC an n independent guy uv In the Mr II Spooner WI then theD took the floor to 10 speak peak on the Ibe bill Mr Spooner agreed Ned with willi most of 01 the speech of Senator Benator Lodge but Ill he was 1 I eu radical If there had ad been no wr war with I a treat treaty the th PhIlippine to the UnIted would Itar scarcely have received a tit ote In the lb Senate The Tb trusteeship under Oud would not haVe been accepted We would have said Aid our ant dut duty was 11 to our own people Th There wu was no of oC em empIre lr amon among us UI nor Is II there now In lb Ih sense It Ii I Ii often orten Used ud Mr Spooner saId Id that on request or of Admiral Dewe Dewey after the batt battle p of Hay Bay troops were sent nt to Manila They were I nut lt to aid Dewey Dewe to hold bold hi lila position I but to capture and bold Manila No were mad mado against troops We held Manila when the treat treaty I ot of ParI ris wu adopted of oC the tty treaty Ill he said there w was a time when h he wu U opposed to 10 Jt it bUt he be would now Ia say that with all U the facts before belore him h be could not see He how bow the could do other than de demand deman mand man the cession o of ute the The sentiment pervaded tile the entire people of the country countr that thai the pin pines could not b be left lett with Spain To Illustrate Ihla thu point h he referred to the unspeakable horrors oC at tyranny In Cuba Cub lie said Aid that If IC the Philippines hall hod hodnot not been beeh taken b by the Slats Spain would lave have resumed her WY sway In Inthe inthe the islands We would have bave I been een obliged to IS march our troops out ot of Ma da nub hili U in Spain marched In The Spanish bondholders would have furnished the means to carryon carry on a war WT of oC Spanish conquest We could not do clo as 1 we dId dIdIn didin In Cubs Cuba demand a of sovereignty from Spain of 01 the l Philip Spain could not DOt have granted u any ieh demand her over U Mild there wu was l f at read Mr r I Der of oC 11 UI the 1510 fW 1 ary arr and nd asked but In in anything nt l be t Could that under these thele con lit II malat maintained I auld demand one aue no of U United It d States troopS trooP the questioned the be authenticity Mr lr contro I ot of the order and nd 1 a sharp versy veny In an esia It came Mt Mr Spooner SP fl department from Crom t the I e wr war charged epel r pel that the docu Mr leIU wt was Mr lr by rece received for effect treet In this evidence country cred of oC equal said Id It wu Lr r u Mr with much that r rhad had presented W In reply said Id that orn Mr pettigreW ft good d as aa evidence rePOrts ment but not aptt the government the retorted d that the South lr e held that t Dak Dakota ta produced proof f wan u S a liar who he which rt U th government O ment the mad applauded by the This remar remark was a I |