| Show i A DOOP 1 i GIRL LOSES SUIT t ourt Rules Against Singer Singerin in Damage Action I r. r NEW YORK May 5 Hen Heen I Kane the boop a sin CT F today lost her ner suit for against Max Fleischer cartoonist the Fleisch et er studios Inc and the Paramount I corporation Supreme Court Justice Edward J J. J McGoldrick held the he had failed to prove her contention that the defendants wrongfully appropriated printed her singing ing technique in the Betty BettJ Boo film cartoons Miss Kane said she t va deeply hocked at the verdict il I consider it very t ts nIl all In Thy friends believe the cartoon la de rate caricature ot of me she s said d. d Samuel R. R her attorney saId saIdI an immediate appeal would be tiled filed I The doop a trial began April 17 Miss Kane seeking damages on two grounds that the defendants had used her pIcture In violation ol of the civil rights law and that the cartoons car car- constituted ti tio on tt McGoldrick decided The has failed to sustain either ca cathe se ot of action by proof ot of sufficient prObative force |