| Show r r 1 i Fumbles End I Ill ll Drives Near tv T Goal Lines B By TOIl 1 E PORTER In one of the mo most t bitterly cone confuted contested con con- e tested games seen in Salt Lake City l la In many nany seasons West and South batU tattled battled to a scoreless tie Friday on the West gridiron to leave the panthers on top in the the- city chase with th three wins and one defeat at al althe atthe atthe the halfway mark of the season at East Idle this weekend is second n pith ith one win and one defeat while G South gouth trails with no victories and andr r tWO to defeats ly South Has lIas Edge oj Both Bath teams learns displayed splendid deI deI de- de I I feVe p po power er while South had an 1 edge on offense counting 11 first be do downs to four by West Many Cub g drives however were smashed up y J jn in futile attempts to pierce the thea theP a P Panther line and most of OW the he ground gained by the Cubs wasI was I I nade me around end or on forward or he literal lateral passes ed A A. stiff wind hampered kicking Ed I cne West Vest attempt going high in the their ir ir for only six yards and one Sou South h Eli f kick tick bounding back 15 15 yards for forth th only a yard five-yard gain although several sev eral cral Cubs made frantic efforts to ground pound the punt te Fumbles halted the most threatening threat threat- el en ening drives by the rivals West beI being be be- I II ing stopped by a muff 10 yards yards from from If the goal and South losing on a d I similar muff only two yards from fromA fromI I A I. score ig The best Panther drive in the l 34 first quarter ended as South held heldon heldy y yz on its its' own yard 25 line West Vest t f stopped South on the Panther 20 It t yard ard line af after r Glen McGhIe re re- f covered co a fumbled punt and andI I checked another Cub attack on the West yard 17 stripe before the half ended with South on the West yard Vest yard 15 line The Panthers came back with a ae e rush In fn the third period and two plunges by Jack Littlefair carried I 3 the b ball ll 22 yards Ed Coburn took tooka I 1 a pass from Littlefair to the Cub y 13 yard 13 rd stripe but Roland Smith recovered a West fumble on South's t yard 10 stripe and after kicking out of danger the Cubs halted ani another an an- i other West attack on the yard 27 line as Joe Anderson and Milo Mangle Mangle Man Man- Mani i J gle checked Littlefair's drives 1 f Halt Panthers 1 I Bob Melroy Meiroy ran 12 yards off off- tackle and South again kicked out Weiler Davis and Wallace Rosan Rosan- 1 der broke up West's attack behind the line of scrimmage to keep the thet I I Panthers from crossing the midfield t 1 stripe and after Gene ti dashed 16 yards the quarter ended with South on the yard 50 line Lyon downed the West safety man in his tracks on his 33 yard stripe but after a plunge to first down Coburn booted to South's yard 13 line one of the best punts of the day against the wind The Cubs gained 27 yards on an exchange of punts however and started the final drive as brook smashed 11 yards to field marker Melroy skirted right end to the yard 58 ard line and on a double lateral ran 13 yards ards then went and cut back I to the West yard 10 line Melroy Meiroy picked up three yards at tackle I and Mangle made two at center but buton on the next play Van Hansen Hamen recovered a South fumble on his yard two-yard line to end the thrust Melroy dashed to the yard 15 line lineas lineas as as West punted and made five but a lateral and an end run were stopped by Louis and Bob Parmley and W. W Davis' Davis field goal try was low The lineups SOUTH WEST R. R Smith le Workman r Tucker It Birch Birch Tr Anderson Jc Hansen tr McGhie Weon 19 o C S Spangler a al Thomas Thorna l Seal l rg r rt f 1 Parmley 1 1 Davis Dayi re re Coburn Melroy MeIroy Perrl r In lb m Z L. L s Perri Smith ft rh Ifa Mangle re ro Ii ft lb Littlefair lf Score by quarters South 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 W West 7 0 0 8 0 8 0 8 0 0 8 0 Substitutions South Latches rh Sphere ih Sorensen re Tolman It West Welt Fau Faulkner Faulkner le Ie Utter referee Cahoon umpire Blazer I linesman AND WEST FIGHT i J TO TIE |