Show b IE fA IS SHINGLE TARIFF lARIff V Votes ot s 's 48 to 30 to to Keep Them on Free Ll Li List t After Battle I W WASHINGTON Nov 13 13 Asso- Asso elated dated Press Retention Press Retention of shingles h on he free list was voted toda today by bythe b bythe the senate Tho vote yoto was 49 to 20 29 t Tho The senate Ii In so 50 acting sustained sus sus- tamed tho the recommendation ot of Its finance committee Tho rho house had proposed a n. 25 5 per cent duty A vigorous contest was waged on the tho ho senate floor by members from the ho Pacific northwest to lo to obtain a duty on 01 tho the project t. t They c contended It t was necessary to meet l Import con competition principally froni Canada Can ada It was vas further argued It would the lumb lumber r Industry 80 so that it t would assist conservation of oC forests for for- Ol ests estu by iy permitting the working walking out o of or a reforestation program 5 S 'S |