Show FINAL DEBATE ON QUAY Many or Greatest Lawyers and Orators Ora-tors in Senate Speak Washington April 2LToit Matthew H Quay wji today refused a teat In I lh United States Senate on the appointment I ap-pointment of the Governor of Pennsylvania i A Pennsyl-vania by a vole of 33 to 3J The entire en-tire time of the Senate today was de voted to debate upon the question I Inn of the greatest lawyers and era tars in the body delivering speechee 0 As HIP days session wore on and the hour for the final vote approached the rallprl filled until they were thronged 0 iMth mulilludes while other mull d hides were unable to gain admission in the fioor of the Senale was every t IIH mber of the body now In tho city and scores of the mombdra of the House of Representatives ITjr 1 A T i nr rYT A v ii PLEAD FOR QUAY The great throng listened with deep attention to the brilliant argument oCr t oC-r Sponner In favor of the seating of I tin foi mer Pennsylvania Senator and I I k tu thi dramatic mid fiery < loqin no of Mr Iinnlcl Who appealM to his ell < i ui to do viiut on his oath aa art s i a-rt < r If deemed right and Vote to I Dt do Justice to him who was knocking at I n th < tienatu doom VOTJ2 ON CHANDLERS MOTION 1 1 AK UK nit tl k opposite the PTI l rZ 11 JT i t T 1 I nrlot t1wr l 0 JS n hl1 I in ill i 1n1 1 ij Mr Tri I iL In I Tr-i Hu IJf H1 J rl h hUt for th f nil t l i i r a n i rhi i th ij fin ti i tho r pdmtr mot rs I of Mr Chadlcr to strike out of the I resolution declaring Mr Quay not to I bo entitled to 0 scat the word not Senators throughout Iho chamber eagerly followed the rollcall for all knew Llw vote would be close FAILED TO ANSWER The first sensation was caused by the failure of Mr Pottlgrcw of South Dakota Da-kota to answer to his name although he was In his neat Whon Mr Vests name was called he voted Uno In a clear voice thus dashing the last hope of the friends of JUr Quay who had expected confidently that the distinguished distin-guished Mlssourlan would vote for his long time perconal friend VOTE IS ANNOUNCED In perfect silence it was announced that the Senate had denied to Mr Quay the seat which lie has sought for some months past I Consideration of the Quay case was resumed at 1 oclock Mr Peniosc continuing con-tinuing his argument begun yesterday afternoon MCUMBER CHANGES FRONT McCumber delivered a carefully prepared pre-pared constitutional argument 10 opposition oppo-sition to the seating of Mr Quay Only a brief while ago lie was regarded as an advocate of Mr Quays claim but ho announced In his speech that after careful care-ful consideration ho had changed his opinion This change he said was not based upon emotIon but upon reason LINDSAY AGAINST QUAY In an extended argument Mr Lindsay presented legal and constitutional reasons rea-sons why In his opinion Mr Quay ought not to be aetUcd He held that the appointment of Senators by the State Executive was provided for by the I framer of the Constitution merely to provide for the filling of vacancies that may be regarded unexpecled They I never contemplated he maintained that tho legislative power to elect I should be divided with llu Executive and he urged that in the present case the Governor did not possess constitu conlltu I tional authority to appoint Mr Quay SPOONERS VIEW Mr Spoonei OVIa said his long and laborious speech IWo years ago In Ktip port of Mr Iorbetta right to a Heat had ne med to have liulo iilu 1 t and had not even convinced Senators Quay or Penrose He brlleved the question pcnd t f InS ought to bo determined upon the constitutional view of It taken by each Senator Per olUHlY hud no decent place In tho dlxcusalon He did not undervalue un-dervalue precedent but precedent should shunklo no Ole END TO THE CONTENTION Mr hub asked Mr Spooner If he thought It watt well that this great question uhould be continually beCoro thu Senate Mr Hale contended that It was hotter for Governors and for Legislatures that there should bo an end of such contentions WOULD VOTE FOR QUAY I I shall bo glad said Mr Spooner If this discussion shall lead to legislation legisla-tion or a constitutional Amendment that will put an onu to the possibility of such cases In conclusion Mr Spooner contended for liberal statesmanship and not 1 narrow view of the case Neither personal tic nor popularity l cas would influence his volp which should Ibe cast for Mr Quay STEWART FOR PENNSYLVANIAN I Mr Stewart explained that he had voted ugalnut the sealing of l hal bett two year ago becniiBc ho did not think Mr Corbftt came here with lean hands L have put the slightest il < > ubi hal I ill Governor In anx I case a llkr UK 1 rvndlng ha perfect right cl to apj D rh Penafnr rect Mr Tiirrrr nri bm onfrtlonB com rMJ him to vote against Mr UIY although he had voted In favor of seatIng seat-Ing Mr Corbett Ho differentiated between be-tween the two cases JUDICIAL QUESTION This Is 0 Judicial question said Mr Daniel and ought to be decided upon Judicial principles According to my I legal convictions Mr Quay Is entitled to a seat In this body and so believing I will so vote Mr Daniel concluded at 350 350SENATE SENATE GALLERIES JAMMED During the afternoon the galleries had fled gradually unlll at this time they were jammed Every Senator In the city was in his seat and many members mem-bers of the House of Representatives Including almost the solid Pennsylvania delegation were In the area outside the rows of desks Tho Joint resolution providing for the filling of temporary offices In Porto Rico was scat to conference Senators Foraker Perkins and Cockrcll being named as conferees QUAY ISDEFEATED Ai1 I oclock thi cha announced that tho hour for voting had arrived and the pending question wasMr Chandlers Chand-lers motion to strike out of the com mltleo resolutions declaring that Mr Quay was not entitled to a seat in tho Senate the word not The motion was defeated 32 to 33 I DENIED SKAT IN SENATE The question then recurred to the original resolution declaring Quay was not entitled to a eat and It was adopted adopt-ed 33 to 32 the former ote being exactly ex-actly reversed on this question Thus Mr Quay was denied a scat In the Senate on the appointment of GOY Stone The Senate then at 425 p m adjourned ad-journed I |