Show AGAINST BELL TELEPHONE IT S Circuit Court Decides Famous S Berliner Patent Case Boston Feb 27 Judge Brown of the United Stales Circuit court bus decided de-cided against the American Bell Telephone Tele-phone company in the famous Berliner patent cosc The suits were the Bell company against the National Telephone Manufacturing Manu-facturing company and the same against the Contuiy Telephone company com-pany brought to restrain tespondents from selling using or making telephones tele-phones or telephonic apparatus with the microphone attachment and to account to the Bell company for past use manufacture and sales upon the ground that uch was an Infringement of patent S iThe cases were argued before Judge Brown a year and a half ago and as lncyrelatcd lo the sumo patent the microphone wore put In together an 1 worn tried as if they were one case I The Berliner patent Is considered one of the most important held by the Bell company and does not expIre until un-til November 17 J90S rue patent is Ihe same one hat I bus been before llie courtsIn the United States vs the j Bell Telephone cpnipany where It was held that tho patent was not Invalid < on account of delay at the patent of I I I lice n The whclrjTcaeo turns upon the va I I lldlty of thVpatfeiU the defense set t ting up among other things the Invalidity In-validity of tho patent Its lack of In t 1 I vontlon anticipation and nonpatent ability It is understood that an appeal ap-peal Avlll be made from the decision nnd that It will be carried to the United States Supremo court on this appeal > 1 |