Show ow bum dmm in H is I 1 ar ii S french government defeated on a test lest vote precipitated BY RAILROADS the deputies censured the MI alatary for or assuming to decide 0 a judicial question guarantee of at Inta on bonds involved amoryn wand la tuo the new hew Ile idea brides la L populated parl paris jan ll 11 tho the cabinet resigned today to day having been defeated da in the chamber of 0 deputies an tile the question ot of I 1 giving priority to an order of 0 the day lart la li it rt ev evening erting 11 23 barthau Bart Bar tiou thou minister of public borha his bla office for or tho the reason thai the council of state hd had decided against him in the matter of 0 guaranteeing the interest of the southern S railroad lines it became generally known that AI alexander the well known deputy and ed aitor in chief of 0 the petite it Fran francasso calso would the llie government in regard to M barzlious Bart lious bous resignation and that the th a government would reply thereto consequently a largo large crowd gathered fathered in the chamber to listen to the proceedings it II was known tint that the ot of the cabinet was not as sure cure as it might have burn ben and the ener enemies nies of the government had bad hope that the debate deotte of oc today to day would result in its overthrow these theao hopes wore were realized INVOLVES A BIO QUESTION tho the nU Nillon which led to the overthrow th r row ot of the I 1 Is 1 a wide one it la Is really a question a ad to whether tile the ciambor ot of deputies Is superior to the attic courts of 0 prance france anil and whether the chamber Is 13 able to net met aside the lh constitution lit ill will in the government nide made a contract alth the orleana and midi hallways under the term of 0 which in return for certain facilities in the transportation por tation of war matell matr ll the hotkin ment Rau ranted thin iho interest on oil tue lae bonds of the the government hall that the guar ant expired in 1 1914 but the directors of toe the companies tool look a different vi view and construed the agreement to men in I 1 III that the government ahn the interest Int erect in perpetuity suits were brousha la in the courts to settle the ques luc lii in tun jim lq li 14 ri the directors to endorse their bon bonds d s I 1 to 0 the effect that the guarantee EUrn tee espil expired d I 1 in n hll 1911 the direct ora to do no mo sill and the case wai then taken to the council of state wh which ach la in tuch such matters malan B Is the final court of appeal the council on W wednesday ednes day last decided aided that the guarantee cua rantee was wag perpetual this decision which it a majority in the th chamber claimed oA ned the right to reverse revera was it a compete com ne gatlon of the conten canton all on i n ii i i y I 1 A n t barthol Bar thoua i action on the railway guar tin teals consequently the battor fiby day tind and tho in the Ch chamber aniber today to day led to the resignation of the th other a of the mints minis try ATTACK THE MINISTRY in u lila 1113 Interpol interpellation ladon it Ullo raud said it was not barthau alone who had brought before the council of state the between bt wen the ste sante to and the railroad rall road companies but the whole cabinet the decon ion of the it sta clr to therefore fore affected tho the iner but only one bl inviter aken the correct attitude ata 4 Iso me for ot state a baud aud to sr I 1 |