Show LYNCH MUST PAY PENALTY i P rda Board Beard to Com Corn Death t 4 I DUKE DENIED OEM lEI HIS LIBERTY 4 t ROT BOY ao ON P I e TRE STATE board of pardon pardons yes yesterday THE I afternoon refused to Com om Commute mute the death sentence of or James Junes Lynch to life lite Imprisonment Dment it n an that t at he must mu die on Friday FrIda Sat Jai S 8 1804 1104 Harry T Dukes petition f fr r a pardon was denied a aft as was ateo also thu thit of or orM M L Boy Hoy Kaighn sentenced f fit H r nv ft tie years ears for shouting shooting Willard S Hayn H a In the corridor of the hotel botel on 00 Jan 21 1901 In the th Kaighn see case a however the th board granted the young man a parol on the condition he first h as u assured a position by sortie some rf cit citizen citizen izen Less Le s than two t w hours hour after the t hI board adjourned Colonel M Iti M Kaighn K a served notice on Governor Heb M I 1 Wells Wel that he would give his sun son a po position in his hie law office as ae clerk dt rk Later in the evening the father r went nl out nit to the penitentiary and took his sort son on v hack ack home with him Lynch was as sly disappointed when Deputy Warden Wright t tid him that the board had bad denied him hilll a life sentence He had confidently nty a commutation of sentence Th ThO only thing he h had to say MY was wa wasI 1 I it is all up j pow ow owIn w wIn In less than an hour after virden Wirden 1 Dow received word that bat t the board boari had hail refused M to commute the of or if Lynch to life imprisonment the in t NeTher i n r was waa placed f in another r cell and n a fi ath eath watch placed over him ilia He now nov Decu ct u pies ples a cell ell adjoining the one o i s pied l by Morten en after the board r used to commute his sentence It i js I r th the ground floor of the north tier tiel f 1 cell In the south cell house bouee Deputy Warden Wright a sai 11 last evening that the death d ath watch arranged ana arri ogeil yesterday afternoon was tas aB but npr rao rat that a permanent one of n I i shifts eight hours bours for etch each e cb mar man ouid be arranged today toda Duke Was Sorely Disappointed Duke wa was crushed by the aim aun ment that the board had refus d 4 to liberate him He H was wu so 80 Intel inte l that he hp had little or nothing t 1 sa II y when told of the boards Ioard action H had bad confidently expected a pardon an all 1 was WaB not prepared for the news new th Ih t his hi application had be been n turned down Tn ln der the rules of the tho board he hf cannot make another application for clemency cl r six months month The hoard board disposed of the oth r ap applications before it in the tM following manner Thomas Ames burglary de dp denied denied nied James Jamee E Dalton theme ears eara fer fet assault to commit t robbery Ty commutation tation of sentence dented denied Ed Red aed Redmond ed edmond mond mend robbery Harry Har HarPool Poole Pool continued Et Ii C g Q four foury y years an for assault upon un u his hiI wife witt par pardon pard pardon don d ll granted Jack Tark denied Peter P Bit I tOn tin ue 1 Joseph eph To Bridge felony denied dented Henry lenry i Wright grand larceny and burglary parole denied L 1 J 1 Napier obtaining money under false pretenses sentenced last May for one year far pardoned Fred George murder out tit on parole for rehearing on application appU for fOt m par pardon pardon don denied Kaighn CUe Case Game Came The Kaighn K case was presented ted to toj j the board by Attorneys Attorney Hender He Henderson n and anti andi i Hoffman They Tb Y cited the fact that th the young man was as convicted in Septem September I ber her of oC voluntary manslaughter man la and sentenced to five years in the th pen penitentiary penitentiary by Judge Charles Charlt 8 W V Morse MorE who tried the ease cast Attorney Hoffman read a number of letters letter from prominent prom orom i nent citizens asking the hoard board to ex tX extend t tend clemency Judge Morse or recommended recommended mended a parole District Attorney At A t Denote Dennis C opposed u a pardon bat but favored a parole Parley Parle I 1 P Ihrie teneen U who was az as county c attorney y at the th time of crime asked for a pardon pardoe as lUll did also Judge William I Hall of the probate division of tie the die dis district dietrict court coart The attorney then tb n called the tb Boards tards hoar 3 attention to the state statement ment meat of ot Haynes that he be hell had gotten what he deserved de mental condition at the time o of the sh shooting wa warn mentioned Attorney Hoffman say saying sayi lag ing i be If did Ud not think the young mao man n was in his bill right mind milad owing ing to tot th n excessive use UR of cigarettes and Iru He said pid Kaighn had now no fully recovered eCO ered eted and is 18 a prisoner pris f Judge Henderson produced f r th the edification of the board hoard letters from flom eleven of or the jurors juror juro recommending reco mending a pardon The twelfth Edward Korup kat who ho is Ie out of the state could ot d not be located d After reading ading the Judge produced a petition frn fifty women asking a for i lease lea l Letters Letter were wert also allO placed in tn renCe c cI I I from ti Ih mother and deter iter eI ter of H iyre j t asking for fr clemency Then i a me lOt a aI number if f t letters from prominent 11 titi j I acne zene art ari a petition signed hy by h every peace af of If the city and 1100 county from C Frank Emery and ant Cap Captain Captain tain tam of PoliCe down 10 t o the deputy depot v and nd patrolman The c of Thomas Ames Ame cam caio next He was wa men three years ears for burglary robbing Bros store at Og Ogden O Ogden den He H was Wa sentenced sen tp Feb Fb 21 h 1 1902 As no on in ont appeared d in his hi l hi his Ie case wa WH ae passed pas d to be considered in s session sion sionI I Lynchs Petition Well Presented i Attorney H C Edwards thee ther pre 1 i the th petition af of f James Jamet Lynch ho bo was wa followed by b Attorney Will VIll F Wanless The latter stated that the i left home in ti tl tIE e east w vien v en n he Will wee 17 of age ap that hat he er f d six ix earlS in the Idaho penitentiary C for robbing a store tore in small email t n in itt n with ith several other m rn of a ai nail quantity qua t t ity of tobacco t i Letters from flom fr im Trial Tri i I I J T 1 K F Ki i tooth ot h i nd ad District Di d Attorney i were wert Iad I tad ad by Attorney rny Ed n who wh fter t r I wards ards ward gl a short f r the t h hI I time crime I mf H fl produced i 1 number let t 1 toes rs MI and petitions pt t lOt asking a kug c Ig for a ration of sentence L Try Included one I irom from ten jur tv uw n t being I the thet etty t a r of lr e Mayor Ezra Thomp i m Sheriff C Frank Em Emery Emery ery and a of h depot I There wa was 0 o one r sent to tn tithe d the cau lam Jame K t Iward Dlton Dalton who asked f I a commutation omm 11 tatton f sen sentence sent sentence tence t nce H v s I giver three 11 eec yean t for assault aJl to In u c rehia rohy v y on T P IS 1902 Trial Tu al Judge Jud e Jar Jac 1 Ii it and j I Attorney L refute refus 1 to toed toa sign feign a petition in his h ii f Attorney Irvine j ar r Kd Ed t ed edva edmond mond mOll who wants want an toO a l i J i H 1 va v van vangiven given four tout years yar hy liv hyon T 1 J JI ton n non on Dec 13 1902 for r hf Th The Re ac recommended i 1 par au i 1 monde mond wife ha baa si i rth to t 4 since her n ia s Inar p I District ALt r Y Eichnor opp oppi i pardon but favored a parole Harry Poole Pooles case came next t been continued con from last laet meeting m et i attorney said the man Dan was no not I P c t 1 i kl I that h t the beam K Ki I i t i j jf of f romance roman entered into tire the th IJ I gs at it this time through the then pre preMi n of f B c eNUS cas la ae bv b Mi la MiU King Kina f r He Re WitS was wasi j I Irl rl years ears d ig Jo hII j U n toI L 1901 f i ir i v In a i i I U Ujo UIO o ohi ut wife While act at atIL hi ILI I b h in u a pr at Spanish Km u H i il In yung un woman Hainan fell feU in inV r t ri tte i te vr V 1 l aak uk i r to tl o marry him hl a il vu I 1 I I fc j tt I H family famil protested Th rh d Ihl hi city where th thi thy thyri ro ri i led nl ml n arroll continue 1 hir hirU hi ri 1 I h t U H P n h hl by l fr V 1 VP t p I th h tine throe t of f ill IT i irre t titi i iti f s of t th gir at ath to rt Ind h hr i to 1 11 i h hr r hull huR l fl Finn nt WU Wll Take Elm Hlin Back t L M n nuel E r 1 made hf hl h UK SH t rt iT t wa as re rf rei 1 t ts el U he b bo rj i i in a i tr i and 1 h hlOI 10 lOI X t n t tH HI HIhi R Rtin c cre me tin meli re i week tee t t hi h In t Lay day 1 iv In iti i uon I I loll J li 1 i mil uni w ing t ti 1 v ards rd ill ti t IT os a nj ui all 41 II 11 j hi t 11 f vt t th I tar 1 wards ard l ar d rf 0 01 On izon 1 Ji wl lf P Po Pi I i h n ir ar aPI 1 ur air d i it 11 i th wi wj n i 1 tand tajo Kin Nin ii E Eward ards 1 bJ 1 vry v rv I T his hh p o to tn t 0 pret pr prein it nl t arroll n 1 after hi i i rr st sti H B a aI I 1 that ti Lb vung m a i rail rai I Kit aile to t a the i J p n 11 i 1 n jg 1 ig p in i rc ted there therell i n i t neeka I ek art PI hi t M h ar arM arletter I i t letter wi Wa M id ad fro ron n i firm v ii ih h hit upon hi h rele a alite s sil 1 lite b i w will hI i given er enI il II il h Ohio Thin ny y them I Th The Tte io eph Bride a came carno m 1 ne next it having b hn t n continued from I the lat last la meeting Thc father of t the lit little litt tle t I girl grave gave ave some testimony The Harry T Duke case W wa then ailed Attorney SOlen ren X en enA Appeared A for tor him The rhe petition for a pardon which has h ha been oil orf flU before the th board for several evera months wa was ae a d by a large lr number of o letters letter recommending a pardon be granted f One ne was warn from District Attorney Etch Eich Eichnor EtchI I nor who did not oppose e hI his rt A Among the writers wrier were ere Judge H P I Henderson Hf Par Pry L Williams Williame United states Stat tt District Attorney Joseph Joeph Lipp Lippman man A C Ems Ellis JUdge W H King Attorney Att ey George Westervelt ity Attorney George L Nye Nyc c 8 B Patterson P Mor Mori i ris is Sheriff C Prank Frank Emery County 11 W O 0 Carbis County Aud tor I M Fisher Postmaster Po A L Thomas Thomaa Thom M H if Walker George G e T TOdell TOdd Odell Odd F F E S 8 V Shelp eore e H B Wood A F Phillips Phillipe Wll Wil WllIam G a and T TE TE Ham Iam Igleheart H Whitney I IE E Kelly Keny I trong Plea Pisa PI For Beet Duke Duk Attorney H K J mMe mate the plea for pardon after Attorney eno ad concluded the reading of the let letI I 1 ere era He H contended the question flue tion I for fur the board to consider conal er was wa whether Duke has baa been adequately punished J i He H called attention to tt the fact tact that Duke Duk pleaded guilty thereby savins the t hf state the cost coat eo t of ot the trial Attorney ney Dininny contended that the mans a punishment did not begin be in when he het t up for sentence but from the da dabat day that bat he be stepped from the path of ot and will win continue as all long as alt nt h he The attorney said asid Id he represented Mr N rill Duke who asked him to go be before Tore fore the board and plead for tor the liberty tf ff f her husband hUll band to whom she abe he has hall been be n true tnie all this thia time In Tn conclusion At Att t Dininny said id This Thill brokenhearted wife gentle tm Iun n asks aika you for her Har husband as aa a present and I hope bope you will j i t disappoint her ber berTrial Trial Judge Charles W Morse Moree and Strict Attorney opposed the of J Wilkinson on convicted convict t 1 1 forgery on April 23 3 1 1903 03 There wac as a anne one to ent him The lIe case of P was waa passed for the month mil ulli 1 that of Henry Wright asking for forI j I i taken up SJ Oft May 22 12 9 1 was wall given Riven nine vears years for or grand lar larM lartHY tHY M and und burla He ILe waa represent 1 1 i hy by F I Loofbourow |