Show JUDGMENT UPHELD BY CONSUL GENERAL San Francisco Aug It The decision of the American consul general at Shanghai China who recently gave a judgment for in favor of W V Porter Boyd of ot Honolulu and against the na Development company has been up upheld upheld upheld held by United States Circuit Judge W WW WW V VV W V Morrow to whom the case had been appealed Boyd In suing for for breach of contract alleged that through the board of commissioners of the devel development development development company he was hired as secre secretary secretary secretary tary to the manager of the Canton railway ran way at gold a month for five years from Aug 21 1902 and that he was wrongfully discharged July 11 ii lOOt 1904 The development defense was that the board of commissioners had no authority to hire Boyd |