Show ISOAP COMPANY SUIT Brought to Annul a Sale of Treasury Treas-ury Stock + IN FAVOR or PLAINTIFFS A OPION GIVEN BYJUDGE I1ABSKALLXESTERDA + Banker Stuts Turn N xtWil 1lead I the Fedeal Curt On XondyA Attachment Suit Against the tonglomeate Mnig CompaayCourt Notes + In the federal court yesterday iudge Marshall gave an opinion in a case brought bJ E L Penn E A Penn F W InersoJ and L P IngersoJ against I F Kincaid John R Bruf Emma F Klncd and W T Dinwoode The plaintiffs and dMendant are stock holders in the Utah Soap com pan and the suit was brought to annul aale of fifty shares f of the treasury stock at 60 per share made bv the defendants to J R Bruf on Nov 23 1898 I WaS alleged that the sale ttasmade to BruIt mae at the meeting in the absence of the plaintiffs so that the defendant could obtain the maorl of the stbck and prevent the plaintiffs from interferIng with the mnnageait of the company and displacing Bruit as manager Judge Marshal found that J R BruIt H F KIncad and E F Kin cid colluded to conspIre against the plaintiffs and that the trnsacton l a device to selthe fifty shares for the benefit of themselves The sale of the fifty share must therefore be va ClltO1 |