Show t ti The Ogden Street Railway Attorney Rhodes gives the following as the altitude of the Swan people on the Ogden street railway franchise matter lVWo assort that the charter of Ogdeu is not nor has been broad enough to allow the council to create a franchise on the streets by any special act 2AThat the Ogden City Street Railway Rail-way company is incorporated under tho general railway law and thus obtained the right to negotiate with the council and acquire ac-quire right of way and construct the lice it now holds 3 That an individual could not have done this 4That the company has carried out terms of tho contract on its part and the city has no power or right to violate it it being an executed contract 5That since the congressional act of j 1SSS neither tho legislature of Utah nor the council of a municipality can by a special act confer charter or a special privilege utiThat the only way a franchise can be obtained is by and through a corporation entitled to acquire franchises by reason of its corporate character and the metod pointed out must be pursued |