Show I I I I I i I GARDNER AND A ROBINSON WIN IN A KOT OT fIGH Tie Vote Broken by Sick Nan Man Manto Nanto to Elect Speaker of the House WETS WIN IN SENATE IN CHOICE OF GARDNER PROLONGED THRE CORN RED FIGHT IN THE SENATE CAUCUS 4 Y E 4 4 o 4 f OFFICERS OF THE SENATE t President nt Henry Gardner of f 4 4 Utah county count 4 4 s Secretary Heber L Cummings 4 4 of Salt Lake LakeS 4 0 4 S Minute clerk to be bo selected by byi 4 i Senator Carl A Badger of or Salt 4 S Lake LakeS 4 4 S Docket clerk Ben Bachman of 4 S Utah county 4 S Enrolling and engrossing clerk 4 0 o 4 to be selected by Senator C E J 4 Marks of Salt Lake LakeS 4 I Ii S i Chaplain Rev J E Carver Caner of 4 0 4 s Weber county 4 S 4 Daniel James JamesS Jameso 4 o 4 S of Sanpete county 4 S 4 S Assistant H HS 4 J JS 4 S E Steele of oC Weber county 4 S SJ 4 J Committee clerks clerk Mrs Clarissa 4 0 4 Van Law of Salt Lake W J F b 4 4 McAllister of oC Kane John of or 4 Utah 4 i 4 Mailing clerk Mrs hefts Denis Elch Eich o oV 4 s V 4 nor of Salt Lake county couty count 4 0 4 Stenographer Miss idle dle Foss 4 S So o 4 of Davis Dals county count 4 0 o 4 Doorkeepers L J I Iiron arson of oC Salt 4 4 1 Lake Lako county J 3 R IV 1 Le e of oC Gar Gars 4 o 4 s field county 4 4 Messengers W R B Thompson of 4 1 4 Millard county H C Bowden of 4 i 4 Box Elder county count 4 4 Watchmen Alexander Spence of 4 t Cache county count Joseph Van Wag Wagner ag 4 0 ner nor of Wasatch county 4 5 o 4 OFFICERS OF THE HOUSE 4 0 4 Speaker E W Robinson Cache 10 4 Chief clerk Alex Buchanan Jr 4 S SS 4 S Salt Lake v 4 4 8 Minute clerk C R It Jones Sum 4 0 4 S i 4 Engrossing and enrolling clerk 4 4 J T A lell Kelly keily Millard MillardS 4 S Docket Do ket Clerk E T Woolley Wo 4 4 S Weber 1 4 4 t Andrew Andew Mor Morris 4 4 ris Beaver Deaver BeaverS 4 0 S 4 Assistant F FM 4 1 i 4 M or Gavin Garfield 0 S V 4 Watchman Joseph Ste St El le Piute Plute 4 8 4 v Messengers 8 George Gcorge Sear Seark 4 0 s sS 4 S tah tab C F Wells Box Elde Eld f i 4 Chaplain J W V Jenkinson Salt 4 8 Lake 4 8 81 4 1 Doorkeepers Alfred Alder San SanS Sanpete 4 4 S pete M 11 L I Sheffield Wayne Vayne 4 t 4 Committee clerks Florence Hull HullS i 4 S 1 4 Salt Sail Lake Mabel Carpenter i 4 4 Utah Rexal Bachman Weber i 4 io o 4 Janitor John Burns Bums Salt Lake 4 1 v 4 Mailing clerk W V H Croft Da Dao 4 S o vis visOn 4 S 1 4 0 00 On the sixteenth ballot Senator Henry Gardner of oC Utah county was chosen pres president presIdent presIdent ident of the senate at the Republican cau can caucus I cus at the city and county building The Therace Therace Therace race for the presidency of the senate was 15 almost unprecedented It was a three cornered battle between Henry Gardner and John Y Smith of Utah county and andI I W X N Williams of Salt Lake county I I In the fight the prohibition question was Involved I Gardner was backed by I I the element clement and his fre be beI e eI I I lection lessens the chances for any an prohibition i legislation His supporters were not all opposed to prohibition and antI his op opponents were not all prohibition men nev nevertheless ne nevertheless his election is us regarded as a ablow ablow ablow blow to the Prohibitionists Senator Williams is committed to Pro Prohibition Prohibition Prohibition Senator Smith Is said aid to have Prohibition leanings while Senator Gard Gardner Gardner ner ncr Is noncommittal which Is looked upon by the as a fa favorable favorable omen In each of the sixteen bal ballots ballots ballots lots Gardner led by b a vote ot or two but only on the last ballot did he receive enough votes otes and then only the required number to elect elet The ballots were secret but from the expressions of the senators before and ard after the caucus this lineup Is believed to tobe tobe tobe be an accurate one for the final ballot For Gardner B X Smith Kuchler HoHley Ho ley Wilson Wilsen SCY Sc Badger Gardner Miller For Williams Burton Wil Williams hams liams For J Y l Smith Bullen Smith Brink Brinkerhoff erhoff Hyde Marks The vote ote by ballots was First ballot Smith 6 Gardner 7 Wil Williams 11 liams Iiams 5 Second ballot Smith 5 Gardner 9 Wil Williams Williams liams hams 4 Third ballot Smith 6 Gardner 8 Wil Williams Williams liams hams 4 Fourth ballot Smith 5 Gardner 8 5 WiT Wil llama IIams 5 Fifth Firth ballot Smith 6 Gardner 5 S Wil Wll Williams WIlliams liams llama to 4 Sixth ballot Smith 6 Gardner 8 S Wil Williams Williams liams Hams 4 Seventh ballot Smith 4 Gardner 9 Wil WA Williams Hams liams 5 S Eighth ballot Smith 6 Gardner S 8 So Wil WA Williams Williams liams hams 4 Continued on Page 9 i AND ANDr r ROBINSON WIN IN A HOT fIGHT I i it from Page 1 t 1 Smith 7 i Gardner cardner S AMI Wil 7 T Gardner S Wll Wil 11 ii i not t Gardner 9 t oJ i Gardner S S WM Smith 4 GardnOr Gardner I t a Gardner S Smith 5 Gardner S 8 S Sro ro t Smith d Gardner l lu III u ement ment that Gardner had hadt ind t with applause by b byH th H well II an all by b the members N of or i i who were war w re anxiously 4 IH I corridor any news from fromI rm I j I U Lo Love o pre Hl 4 nt of th the last lut oId d tI at the aUfU and Sena 1 Kuchler K hI acted arted a IW et ta J r t th exciting contest conte t t for pre pres u 11 vc not a great pat deal 41 of in InC Int C t of or the th got gal th larger number Dumber of Sill Salt aIt I Lake county was wai wasi i r and two wo d iv i the two latter not Dot yet Jet ft be bel beI r l I n of Ut Millard coun roun f Orvllle the de df dei i it for tile the house i time lime land In a position in iR the thein ther i in r 1 he hf sought to toh bS 15 sergeant 0 II II jI w d ted for tor this on oni onby i 11 i t bv by Daniel DanIe James Jam of San Then he tried tiled to be M b it at arms anus and was waa defeated tx by II It K B Steele of Weber eber I I he WAS wan gives given sI a poI po 1 nger l lz r and Senator Marks were d I in m attempting to secure po poi i lineal and were fI fl fIn i n prizes to dispense u ir r will m be allowed to name 1 rk end and Senator Marks the lIle 11 I 1 clerk m mt t at S I In the 01 i l In sexton eslon until 1 m |