Show I MR R I EDDYS MUO PROVOKED A PUNCH Dr Hasbrouck Explains tho the Eject Ejectment mont ment from His H Is Office WAS NOT NO ASKED W FOR FOIt FOI BOOKS Hacy Mory iturE ury Told rOw In ii lbs Hie Ihl Police Court This IiIi hi Leads CI to o 1 of Vt A case cn o of more than thal Inter out ost Olt was IS that limit of ot Dr tt H A It charged with wih a n amid before Judge Diehl title morning The ThiO fh doctor who l II Is president of oC the tho Saint Joe Jut Muting company was 1 with thc th offense of at r refusing f using to pel mil M I II I and ond K 1 Ii A Walton stockholders to examine the bunks books bOIk and amid certain pa Jut papers jt pers and documents of ot tho corporation When tIme the CliNt up Uj UI for tor trial It wiit siLs Wl M loon eoon seen SOCI that there was renly moro macro moroto to It I tItan than appealed l on oil 01 tho tIme face bee Assistant County Ally Alty Aty litter prose prosecuted po o arid and Judge JudKo Wenger represented time tho defendant d Mr Walton testified that lint In company with wih Mr 1 ho hu went to Dr ulce on 01 March 18 und tad made u a request upon Ui him bitt to lo SOC eo the books boo liS Instead of complying with wih the request tho ito H said sold Dr Has flits Hasbrouck ln brouck smote Mr MI l y with stub wih a 1 tight right hand punch und and Ind then hen blandly asked It If Ithe ithe he wanted any numy more lore Receiving a In nega negative lye tive reply the tho man 1111 ot of medicine often affen placed hi his itis hand upon elton Mr Mu Waltons shoulder and nna asked It If he lie wanted d anything Upon learning burning that Mr Walton aiton did cd not want anything the doctor ordered them heat Ilem both oth out ot of the time chico Mr lr testified that when whet he his spoke to ho ito said How 10 a c Ic d de di doe doc doctor tor tar and then therm Ito tho to doctor walked up anti and hit him and at nt tho time same tints time he ii made mU 1 some settle remark about parentage the tho same Wih with a canine of the female persuasion The defense dorotso was tes IS that several ago Mr Mm I I and amid the this doctor ii Iii 11 I t taint trouble and time the former accused time the lat it iatter itter ter tar of ot dishonesty dishonest Also SI that lint he made mado malle the time that time the next ext time tle he lie called c llod on Hasbrouck ho he would commie come looking for tIll trouble Ho lie 10 poked poke his mug In II my 1 door dour said the doctor on the thc witness stand did and 1111 I simply hit lilt hint him The thie accused denied that anything was said with to 10 any books or but that thought Eddy wan waH looking hooking for trouble ho anti and ho Ito concluded to Rive give It to hInt him Upi Upton Upion Up Upon on examination by h Mr I lter Dr Has Hasbrouck In brouck bronc that he 18 na not en emm enI I any of or brotherly hov Eddy J he h ald time the laU laUter ter tc h lai a win r n to Boston HOllon The defendant did not deny deity lN that lint he lie mako the lie remark about the dog Two Tivo other witnesses were ero examined for tor tIme the defense and they the both testified I that they did not hear either Mr fr tai Wal Walton 01 ton to or Alt Air 11 I ask Isk to see nee lee tile the books on Oi tho the day du In question They wale wuie haiti both hot h agreed in ium the time statement however that when w en dt entered the time doctors privat olce he lie came caine out much faster tuter than he tie went In InThey They rhey also agreed that when the tho doc doe doctor doctor tor tot asked Eddy end and Walton If It they wanted any more they thoy th wore siere cro both bOlh pOll poel positive tive lve and emphatic In their declarations that they dm not care for any Judge Diehl Diehi then bout had his hl Inning He lie le held hele that If any uny demand d was mends made upon the defendant for lor tho the books in question luelon defendant did not tot hear It I Dr Hasbrouck was found not guilty gUity and discharged dI t At one omme stage RInge of at the proceedings It I really reny looked as ns though there theto might be ho ben hoa IJ n a scene In the court room It I wes was while the Iho defendant was under tinder cross exam examination He lie 10 was asked why ho lie hit hi Mr r when the th latter Inter entered Int red the otilee Because he lie looked like e a 0 whipped cur was OR the reply n na the tM doctor looked defiantly nt at the tho th object hJ 1 of ot hi hil wrath A moment later ho admitted hint the only provocation h lie he had for the te as us assault sault was the sight of Mr r Eddys I mug |