Show CLOSING SCENES IN THE f TINGLEY LIBEL SUIT sin aico C U jan lo 10 with tho fourt annu packed to 1 ry linail of its 1 parity nith perched in window sills ami an throng a to a position in th remote part of alie rear corridors samuel of san feancisco Fian cisco alio closing arall in behalf of he defendant in the tinley case at the opening of court judge announced thai it would lo 10 impo to tho case to the jury today mr iilo aid you have oath that 5 ou this MSP on tho aa U i pan by and bo guide tl by the law as it fall from the lips of the court tins was not an oath to you inches but an oath to the ci oo 00 d that you would determine alib case strai pins tour hearts of all prejudice who is the plaintiff in this cas chewe did she come I 1 glicr past not in mv matory tory stand on the record katherinc tinley euing the ioa I oa 1 the personality sona lity of the defendant ii known it has no desire to hide its past arson its corporate it n burnce its wealth who is here mr andrews of plin Uffe conn ocl objected lo 10 the inference that mr had un unknown oa 01 1 mr pc allowed to arr aceil and he insisted insist pd chrtt mrs le vi wis it lias not allowed to be allwn to jun continuing Conti nuin he 11 plaintiff cornea upon the tape and ohp of b noon glicr of the a a ww said to her claiming to tx thi lowi nd boap nf lit the right to pj int ik M coi on the right to think ami speak the not give us this right but ahry guarantee this light that canies conies to from hoarce the right to print ia hip right to the inan alio writes to his wife that which he lo 10 be true has tho right to speak it tho right to speak is tho right to publish pub liah newspaper docs not have to go on the bended knee and beg aitio right to publish we have no cen scored press it will bo n arnd day for when jurors shall punish those acho speak ol 01 public matters so long as their heart tire free from rancor thie libert r for which our fathers gmo their blood ia vor thle if taft of the free press to be denial iba institution at point loma was 1 lif appealing to the people of the country for supporters support Irs ringley was n public character mr the kimory of the provisions ceab behin tho freedom of the nd said the pres i the clarica cla voke 1 a the people to tho aid of mb t follow the lap aye to die far lie nag the hero representing this press th ires |