Show uuna ani I 1 AJ LA the anso of iho U S ys lo 10 alfi renzo snow fl Oil Jl THE COMPLETED an array of witness ey thoi bo long before 2 yesterday the courtroom vas crowded wilh spectators who had assembled toW te ss the proceedings in the case of alii unit d states vs lorenzo snow charged with unlawful cohabitation with his alv ro the following jury wax em paneled during the morning and the evidence for tho frank carson george bunc D II 11 spencer amos I 1 stone E adam kuhn bohu keck joa smith ales 0 bowman thomas arant belij and fred fay r the attorneys for the defense were audgo R K williams lion P S ki hards judge harkness and Mc richards 1 before tho the witnesses commenced judge karkness stated that ill order to have timo the defendant is w to admit that lie lias been married to tho women named in tho indictment and that ho has never been divorced from them that ho htiu claims each woman wife the iro acu ecu ing attorney slated th ati that bo accepted as an aid to the the ourt wished snow wished to admit that he had publicly claimed the ladies achis wives dining the time charged in the indictment the indictment on which the trial is based is the one charging unlawful cohabitation with his the between january and judge replied eliat he could not fy defendant had claimed as his wives publicly well but I 1 thought he said they were his wives during the time cli arged in alie indictment judge 1 I dont know that but the relation of hus and wife is not denied of conr sc the will admit lie lias more alian ilie varan if hie pro wishes the anler of alie marriages we will jre 1 l rief discussion ensued as to in the trial t fsr claimed eliat anly such evidence as ref to the t laurii g alie time cli arged in the indictment could be in this l aasc ii understood that there suu su u tivo indictment aud it would manifestly be ui aar juuso the same evidence in tiyo or inore cases they eanid only consider the conduct of the dc during the of time january 1 aad december thlu case that the conduct the ladies alleged to bu riis wives prior to the m the indictment could i to alio rulings yf alii of cutilli apil the court of the united states he should therefore hold toi show ahai the held out to the or ia ad obese ladic were his ltv of Is rial aind ad ml the act enso was y cai the of an alic axa mi nation of the witness wib than proceeded itt y f tine attorney state if you aru marriah and who i ayour hua liani ber 1 i art 9 now clawy if been divorced i i sir JJ imro still his wife yea sir r low lony leavo a abu ived together tho deft net objected to aliis ovi t ij to ahe at issue alie objection overruled continued do you as husband and 11 ll 2 hii I 1 Nf tir never well I 1 have in former days alok anni did you collve 1 I paa rayc law how I 1 f welt I 1 tall yon havo ou any children by this de kivini li vini i novare you ar prescot 1 I 1110 o in my own house I 1 am mi art ss io my bofto and pre ahro alone i dobir I 1 have a stepson living na chiw loep has he been kivini with you he has been with TOO wa child who ia adeline snowa Ihl inyo name was 3 deard 1 lo 10 is she hie wife of isy alte coart that is admitted At toncy I wish thin evidence in orjin or it will laitu niini ito to the witness state tho anler in ho d Is di linw snow ihal first wife W alho d tw b ladies oh the bame day r V tl alia is the name of the oilier luly is dead then sarah harriet eleanor mary ahl lhnn io and the last jg minnie ays pir mr snow reside arp ti where he at present lived in no wing of the old blout O lie ight question was objected to by ali on aitio that li f inart would be in fit objection and x ti in could be lakee at ahia for ho defense that aliey would nut repeal the dili el on it being understood attorney who lived with mr enow to where he hla itaw minnie tri eai f who UK liefl knitli according to my by the court who also lived with hiim witness no ono cleo prosecuting attorney how many persons lived under the bamo roof tharo anro our wines and we cadi had a panco for on reel ves there re four wings who are living there snow eleanor and myself then you sarah eleanor and minnie lived under one roof well there is a roof to each wing you live in one largo house with four wings did mr know live tharo four persons lie did not live with rno for a long time well but he lived in the house ho lived in the wing with minnie according to the best of my k bowl adao ue did not live in the winy I 1 lived in D you recognize mr snow as your husband I 1 recognize him as my companion I 1 married him forty years ago you did not answer my question I 1 consider him my companion were you ever married to him I 1 was married to him nearly forty years ago do you consider mr snow ho father of your children sharply yes sir you have no children except by mr snow you were not a widow jadv no sir does lie recognize you as ilia wife I 1 have not asked him for a long time i tho question was put again and answered in the same way and the court stated aliat the question biad been admitted by the defense prosecuting attorney well does he provide you with a home I 1 live in my own house who provided it doryon lie has arranged cheru I 1 can draw my support that lias been up till the first of december this year and has been so since the birst of january 1883 yea sir have yon seen mr snow since jan yes sir lie has visited you how often I 1 do not know not very often he would call occasionally and ask about the children mrs snow state if tho relations between yon and your hu band at the present time are the same as they were years ago lo 10 by alie defense and objection ovar ruled there is a good deal of difference well tell us what it is in my younger days I 1 lived with him as his wife and raised children now I 1 am an old lady and do no consider con bider the relations that were binding upon my younger days so much ao now I 1 do not live with mm in the same way the only difference then between your past modo of life and your pros ent is in not being BO much in hia company objected to and argumentative objection overruled answer I 1 said there was a good deal of difference way 1 live no v and the way I 1 used to live in my younger dais wall H is only this the fact is he is noi in your company so much ho does not live me the same house he visits you at your house does he dine M ith you no sir ho has not dined with me during the past year the court observed sharply to alie witness that apoi como questions sha appeared very anxious to testify and upon others she was not ei anxious her to answer only the questions put by alie astl prosecuting attorney state isyou before the grand jury in this caad yes w I 1 did do you remember the question whether he dined with you yes air 1 remember it r what was your answer I 1 stated that I 1 could not tell but I 1 thought he had but when I 1 came to examine as to the time I 1 thought ho was there I 1 found that I 1 was mistaken i then you admit testifying before the grand jury that ho had with you now state if he lias bot dined with you when you invited him there 1 have not invited him there did you not stale before the grand jairy eliat ho had dined you I 1 d to say that it he had dined with me it was by invitation I 1 could not positively tell but upon reflection I 1 found he was not there state if mr has been atway during the year 1885 sir he lias been away part of the year what time he went what time he returned I 1 cannot state exactly I 1 think in may he returned when I 1 did not eee him till after ho waa an bated by the court during the past ye achaa he ever introduced you as his wife witness I 1 do not remember that he has prosecuting attorney was you hero at the examination before the united states commissioner november salt yes sir about that time were you in the marshals office with other ladles waiting to bo called as a witness in the case yee pir state if whilo you were there wait ing mr introduced you to any ix abon and if BV to whom he said harriett brother peery and I 1 shook hands if he introduced you to mr peery a his wife I 1 did not so understand him now baute n hat alio fact wais well I 1 told you the fad ftc near as I 1 know anything about it tell if your attention was called to that matter in the grand jury room yea sir it was lauw did you testify in relation to this matter before the grand jury the question won objected to objection wan overruled I 1 did not testify that he introduced me a lili wife for I 1 did not BO it 1 told them ho introduced bro pecry to me but aa to the borm I 1 did not remember by judge hark nese witness resides from sir shiow on tho saidu her step s on anink livit with horTh cru are levu in the hodg n hai no rooan in house could not tell how many times ho had visited her whenever ho came it was gen brally on with mr rinow sat down for a lew minutes ue ban only heen iu two or three during this bedr nuno of mr snow papera camo to her house to hia alico llico in tho eirick haitie na i counsel tho whether iid been any sexual intercourse between witness dp alin period tan and dec ast 1st and alio question was to as tins coult sustained the objection ke dlbert mr is 72 years old if hot witness does snow minnied ho gaii ia centrally located in brinham city witness does not defendant visited any other persijs in tho houpe when he her alic did not halcli him attorney did lie visit any other beraun under alio sano roof bitnes Wit nes well biot while he was in iny i many diio is atie lik U as married i wint resides in herein ln belf hi iby biml by herself 11 years or mure afi anit to that tame ehe lived in the h mr lial im alc head of tb family all aino mr inov is the r of witco he calls on aa any would fie has called very few limes during alie past year would approximate lie number anca at four 0 live the relation thip between and M r dynow lias always been llie tame nith the exception that he ha not livid in alie amo famo f lionso her pat few years tie docs not visit witness as oft 11 noff as lia did five hist irvi as he grows older i arua ahng attorney and tho lie has visited yon the past ii i i because been avny boino p ir of liv time till isaa 0 o b alie n pa defendant donld have visited if li e lad not lean absent tho objection tion crass examined witness house is two blocks and a liala cotant from eliat of the defendant mr snow probably half an hour at each call he made during 1883 the visits were always made during the day there li no room in the hous occupied by sir snow nane of ilia business capere or letter come to witness residence redirect re direct aliey recognize each other as husband and wife just a much so now eyer rheid ELEANOR was called and sworn lerenzo snow is her li ausband she has children and resides adeline snow lives about three blocks from residences phoebe snow lives in alie baic home with adline witness h aa occupied iier place of abode about twenty years air snow lies across 11 ic block live in alie old homestead witness and th e whole of the ladies alleged to bo alie defendant have never occupied one hodac at the flame binic ivr snow only called to fcc two or three times diring As hear as bitne can remember he has been away mat months crosa occupies six mr snow doc snot occupy either of none of his business papers or mail is left at witness home lie passes alie house an his way to bustnes tf whenever ho called he would inquire how alie children were he never ps in SARAH took alie stand haft hien married to I 1 snow nearly 1 forty years arter witness lived of alie other ladles and she t cn moved fo by herself lias ildved froia deafen f dant could not at she had been introduced i ahe ifo of I 1 snow tilt past ten years mr snows to witness have acen lis as helias grown older did not the warda used when cintr to mr short time ago cros elvei in aliat Is called the 11 hoffstead in froin the brick lioci e to town air snow pass tant huo hi been in witness bouso two oralu ce during 1 lie acer remained in the night abid never slept alie object falls ana to sec glicr son alio I 1 manager of the coon co on aci he would ask how the folks acro getting along mr anon has not alik d in fitness vit ness house bunh the 1885 year 4 v f SKOW was the she was roar ried to lorenzo snow in jhc has four children h oldest it ten and is three montara old mr snow with at her alino in brit liam city tho only of the children and a hired stirl mr h giov has raided with witness during ihu year he haa been absent abigt f ovi n ho was in s lionso has ath mr paw vur since fell waa marr leil to him in the ii occupied at present eh lived in old ia bilter edw witness and defendant ai tho and flipse of ten apara aaa croes burink tho 1885 ahrn lie liaa lieen in city mr snow has not taken his beuls at any other thun at witness li use allt has always slept there also hag apier kluin him to bo absent from houte at night velem he was out of tow he liaa abw iva taken hia with and her family defendants od ico is in tho brick lionso ra deew ilia mail and como to ie aldays inada hia homo him when he haa been in town Is acquainted with thu other ladies alleged all eted to be the wives of mr snow r cy were always at home so far as witness knew when mr anuw was away witness them almost dully ite direct ains never seen defend ant with any of the oilier laduca witness haa charge of 1 is bedroom anil knows alion he sa at hanie boca not know ihal mr adinow has publicly claimed the ladies as his wm 9 during tho benr daca not I 1 hat ho has ever stated to that they are lils j 1 ite crosa by I 1 think you a asked by u would kaw if mr anuw lii awn or not anne i ly hag who after his hanse iia always leavea that to me i m j n i ait fpx sworn he i valli ac ader lie jita tion h answered A na 0 o knew the had previously testified ag alio wives 61 apostalo that lio they called in by alit snow fam ilyas a physician veco ow professional lias known mr snow by for about two years ilaa span hini frequently during the present at ar could not say where adeline isnow lives because lie dis tinpui sh chii ladies by namo thinks she elvei in the cotton thomas house has seen mr snow with aunt sarah thought he had acen him with aunt flarah nud minnie witness haja attended services in the tabernacle at brigham city during the present and heard at ostle snow preach there the quefton whether the witness heard mr fonow preach on tha subject bof plural marriah marr iao was objected to by the defense the actor apy said ho wished to show that by his public utterances alie speaker c plural marriage correct and by his speech and conduct was teaching others to marry more wives than one the objection was sustained cross examined witness casseen defendant in the brick house during alie past car has also seen him in house that ia the house chich lias been called the old home stead itis alie house nearly on the corner of the block and has lareo witness was making daily visits to 1 hatHo attend of mr who was Mcki this was in 1884 lidseen li aseen defendant goins in the pate of the house a number quito a en bod as 0 o the rate and ahe ahouee counsel wished to know if the bad seen snow po into the house witness continued to assert that he had icon him go in at alio pate they finally arrived at an nn der ir when jude d the witness if he had nan ml in any f alie lioumes during 1885 the witness replied that lie had not but he had seen him po through the gate it was in march that saw him at the theater last winter could not tell whether saral was with him daiil not ev than come in they sat left with alie rest of the audience mrs lorenzo snow jowas examined several questions but bad not seen mr snow during the present year jintil ho was arrested alie whole of this witness teb was ordered out F iwas sworn and took a beat in the witness chair he works for lorenzo snow he looks after the tow and alie horse and buggy drives alie ladies out sometimes sometimes he pets the carriage ready and they drive themselves he has to attend to getting in coal and wood and |