Show TRIAL scoville Sc concludes his Arguin argument ont on Guite auls insanity I billich the prisoner oner emphatically lyana and angrily booms examination of Wit witnesses es for the defense ily W U tele mill to the tho q nov 23 the TIe attendance I of the criminal after ing sensibly dimin Hied hed on oil account of arai arain norm horm wa va ilo le G guinean was taking his breakfast it tt the city hall lio lie ex dissatisfaction at the release of jones upon bail when the court opened scoville made a formal request for the papers taken ft from oni at the time of his arrest stating they were material evidence for the defense and since the tile prosecution had not needed them lie could ece no reason why they should be he withheld the tile Dib district triet attorney offered to furnish copies of the papers batsco but scoville insisted tor the originals pending the tile discussion guitrau insisted upon being heard and said I can throw light upon this at the time of my arrest I had forty or fifty editorial slips showing tile political situation in slay may and jane june these slips show the tile action and force that impelled me on to shoot the president they arc are very important as chowing wing the gist vist of the whole matter they were forty or fifty slips denouncing noun cing president garfield it was civill li living vill on n such ides as these that I was finally impelled on to president g with my inspiration col cark corkhill hill interposed again saving if it will favor iti to get through 11 today to day I will send solid for them during the momentary lull in the pr proceedings ings guiteau again tried to make k T a personal explanation saying he be had used the expression yesterday that Ju julius littel was too suggestive of tile the negro race and for that eliat reason he had dropped it from ill hii name C his prejudice was begotten 20 90 years ago lie meant no disrespect to the colored race for they were more highly thought of alip then it the white r race lee n nowadays oava ays scoville ille continued by reading gui gill beatis letters Sc scoville read a letter written by guiteau to ins his father in which he lie spoke of havin having gotten into somo some trouble and in ill which ex ch he be asked for money guiteau explained led the letter saying one of my clien clients tsa a miserable little lyli whelp elp had me arrested on oil account of a little difference ence of 20 between us As soon as the dis brict attorneys attention was called to the I was released I never ought to have been arrested but it got into the papers and d did id me a good deal of harm iliad I biad been in the tle theology olo y business for some time and as usual was out of money all there was in that As the reading of the letter concluded guitrau again interrupted saying I never got much from my father lie ile got down on me mc because I left ti the to oncida community we could never after that agree on that miserable stinking conill comish JA u ului 01 we teat S scoville avi i alre resuming resuming v alluded to gui traus i career a or as a politician and drew the con conclusion cluston that liis his intellect was deficient this view aroused the prisoner at once and ho lie began a series of interruptions pro protesting against villes conclusions as false when reference was madeko made to his running around from ono one committee room to another seeking to be employed as a cam campaign i speeker and his f failure to obtain reco recognition anition was mentioned guitrau u shouted angrily at it because I had no ability but was not known I had ideas but not riot reputation a they wanted bip big guns I like I ke nut gen c n gra grant n t ana and senator conkling men who would draw then in direct contradiction to his counsels declaration to the jury yesterday that guiteau was a man alio never made a joke in his life he lie looked up tip with an amused smile and added I presume id draw now this provoked agena a gen cral laughter which was vas promptly suppressed up pressed by the judge judg e who who struggled to disguise a smile upon his own features scoville continued upon the same line and criticized guiteaux Guite aus speech entitled Garri farrield eld vs II Il ancock 11 he ile said etwas a in mere ere jumble of ideas collected from newspapers rs and from froin speeches of others no one but butel a crazy man mail would have imagined as guiteau did that this speech possessed sed any became more and more restless and in the th e most excited manner in an yet shown by inn him shouted to scoville I object to your our theory on that score se ore and when yea you try to make out im a fool I am down down on n you L I want you to tell the truth button zut yo 11 try tr to make me no out a fool I say the deity inspired my act and he ile ull will take care of it I want the truth tru th and all there is is about it col corkhill arose to protest against the interruptions of the tile prisoner pris oner ft hen Guiteau waved wn cd his big hand hall anil said its not necessary necez to make like any remarks colonel just let tile matter drop scoville was willing to agree to any measures res the district attorney might inight suggest to restrain the prisoner davidge desired tosu to suggest asta a way bopre to prevent vent tho tile outbreaks he ile attributed them entirely to Scovill cs course co urboin in commenting on the evidence already submitted and his attempt to arguo argue from it mental infirmity on the part of the pris prisoner ner guitrau listened intently and d striking n g his clenched hand upon the table gablein I aront of him exclaimed I agree with that all through and I desire J asire to thank tho t to prosecution everyone of them for the liberal liber al I taink col corkhill Cork bill made mado a fine opening opel jiing there any bit bitterness bitterne terne ss at all in his speech and I commend him for iu it guiteau continued to interject inter eject liia observations upon u pon Scovill villes cs theory t beor that ho lie guiteau was deficient in in intellect and protested lie would not allow hia his counsel tounsel to make him out a fool guiteau subsided and premised promised the tile court he be would keep quiet qu let Sc scoville concluded his opening without further interruption or incident at the request of the district attorney the witnesses for the defense wore were excluded from the tile court room with the exception of mrs scoville th the e prosecution pr me cution at the request of mr ir scoville so oville mada made an exception in her case the first witness for forthe the defense II 11 N burton was then thin examined he ile testified ho lie di did d not think the prisoner so deranged d aa as to b be irresponsible lie thought him not deranged but very badly arranged no cross examination ol 01 of this witness testified to hi ill knowledge of tbt the insanity of ono one of guiteaux Guite aus aunts thompson of freeport Freo port III knew Gulte aus father and do doi i a ascribed scribed ins peculiarities I john A rice of minton wis a praet practicing icing physician physic inn for 20 26 years testified that lie ne had examined the prisoner in and come crime to the conclusion that he lie was insane hia his insanity ana emotional rather than intellectual represented to be an impairment of judgement jud gement but not mt much tell if any a ny I impairment of oft the lie intellect lie told his friends guiteau foupht to be secluded the witness treated gui traus father but did not consider him insane iteck Ite cs |