| Show fc V DRAWING TO A CLOSE the testimony in iho dudley murder trial all in of alio for alio llio ri by At torner beatty following is the continuance of ahe cross of josepn from alie point report chewed up to tho leour of adjournment journ ment on I did not beet under neither of us were under I know be was trying to get his pistol to kill mabe J causo of liia threat did the first thing that occurred to rn supposing lie intended to assassinate anny I had my pistol with ditc to grab him by the arms to keep him from pulling his pistol iro took leold of my clothes somewhere it took but little time to get to the dont know how long it ans before I drew my after getting on probably two or three I had liia right wrist in my left hand siw of the parties in the houe till I had reloaded chrt pistol did not tell raymond elaml baan I can take care of that dont why I reloaded no pistol in Wad mana hand think of getting hi pistol of excitement I thought alio coroners jury would find tho alio then stated that lie did not thin klo out was excited and could not collect his thoughts I felt m wad mans right hip pocket m his overall dont know that ho biad pocket certainly cint tall how or eliere I baruck wadman briick probably with one hand but dont know suppose I struck butt I bred three shots into tho liely as fast aa I could I cin c in cock and the pistol fast bid not shoot more became bec aue I supposed when lio stopped kirkirt kic kirt ha was dead did not kilt liim the krilow I had iiii him then or not alia distance was two or feet I think it was done so quickly I could hardly estimate I had was dead when I stopped birin fi rin I id not him out I birard no bisp or word after hit hint with the revolver when ho said do it well joe don t know thit lie had given up eitl nce adjourned till thursday morning at t daya thursday am i the defendant came into court euly but some little delay was occa by tha tardiness nesa of atno 01 tho jury mrs dudley was not present when alie jury were all in the boox the roll was called and JOSEPH dadley reamed the stand groba exa mined by van vas living at spencer at alie timo of alic killing had been there uince tha separation from my wife am not there lowi I had been in alto house attoul two houra on the night of the killing before intended to stay all night bid not understand harry was ready logo to river to seo anni about a hors abde i blieu it ats to talk about a horse trade dont know that I daiv liin every day call at Vad niina to bea liviu on thursday I know harry was surprised at seeing stevena presena at raymond or h u guage lie ditl Sl ovens believe linroy liml hia cut but bont il was cut oil and ll 11 are r eliud by n arriage when aaa at willoit creek ho told 1110 had said I ie eliat I would be on alie watch huts nil I remember at the time talked about after that sp aikin of hia ac told hiim I giuld be on tho alio ecat of tho chiri ictor my brother and me r td efroin lo 10 ill arli an hour or an hour antl n halt we were atto J e going coining it was about when we plin city know joseph of our alicc might two or three adya dya buforo the killing dont I wis alter i ic turneLl froin cruper joseph Si nill told iny fortune with cardi lo 10 timit of a special occasion three or four days before the kuling I expressed sympathy to him funny wilc und children great benl about her and I knew aho was anio to and loved elc and M ie was us u s a bif ii evev libeu if her gane ment arts truo bh was rhodi dont remember mentioning in that ion told libin harry Vt dini was a good trusty batyi lie a ad I aid let loihl win u pcr son hut thiu waa with him mid it VAA one I thought hat been a diena to o as but hu car eipl the eliat it matt hail uc it is wo than I lanil no lierd was I to anil w w be fute going to ojito walh hauw no of to actor inai lotho it n bow in court in draper tn or ddn to o bliwn mid left iliin city abo anie day curly it was areek froin iving that killing took place tt tino laufe hilling it was an chip I took aind it w her eanls thought i too kr anu ctet reil jl lini kroie whit in in tho butt of it cliris diun tiun ol san on or thip killing linao avon in alio dont kiy in to lap WM M good OT a brov atin it iiii a thing to defend a pento will henry caie to me and aul alio listol back that I got fo chrt iw the arit ulious d year aab I gat tl it on alio cup no iw e for it when iw catine to gt it calil him he calil halve it he took it valri harry told moi bout my wil it va 01 thre alifi going I roni ria in city to andert tirui or four adyn of lofti going to ib ii afe dont know what alluded to alier ho de that I take U baak animo d rier that he duthu hand bi annil at if to a paul cm was ip tu lionil never B UV jtb put lul boc a cioce cut fruin iho aul froia ala wiy jiva i kraii ii fai ti i n n i hia hand it wa a very slight cut it i the left on wife cut before my was is a fortune first arv teller was at bis house trad or tareo wife left told my my it beloro I WAS and true and I to gearu pretty in was to tho cabaca of ariy bitae la montan ot apuin oace und v ith one uy beut aa far a sitti onn placelia willard went on from n the night and took cl cleio iio of the and hairy went luck to my team place I have not been in the of being sworn in court wast recalled I saw wadman on before tho killing asked liin about hia anu ho sigid ala well now I suppose clarry jross lie camo to es my uncle nothing no about having been abent for john know ma previous to the killing PRESTON blaar asu called but did not respond ho was sent for and cacno in waa sworn and took the stand elul conversation with harry the lie WM killear talked with him ut ile nicked ine to luah linn motley hut I biad none I told him dudley owed nio could get it I would let him have it lie in trouble about this airier airi ir I suid I wonder what bucl lie had with liis wife at draper and asked if alio waa coining buck ire baid no by god not it I can help it WAS biere is a witness by alio prosecution land talked with harry about liis going to duda leys house so often and accused liliie ot sleeping dudlets dudleys Dud leys wife ha denied WAA on friendly larina with liim live roda from dudlets dudleys Dud leys observed at dudlets dudleys Dud leys when joe I abit he stayed at beitl davd beeri laitu liboro the alie conversation I had Wad inart was before dudley tind his wife sc pai decd six or when went to dudley and two others returned hilll int declined to ride with lile judge at point an that alie desense had noth ing further to offer and called CHRISTIAN in rebuttal I live at plain city know the defendant live fifteen rods from raymonds lie defendant on alie morning of february laati I was talking with him at Kay mouda cor ril between eight ailta nine clock dudley said to itie that the was better than a pistol said the butt cost him four bits that it win a kd thins for a man to defend himself with in freighting if attacked it would be a weapons witness identified the whip in court cross examination I lave known dudley two or three ye ira I aas eliat liy aal dadley was alid whip t his horbes I stopped for about five minutes took no memorandum spoke with several on that day cant tell what I saul iliad two other conversi tons with dudley that day and talked with tareo aniu who WM one of them remember what I said to others I raw tho whip in alie evening and that turned my mind to talk with dudley I talked with wadman about the conversation once alio with win knight have talked with the attorneys atto ineys JOHN was recalled I nm one of the parties eliat went home with Wad mans body I saw a pistol in the lionso on lop of the cupboard dont knarf what pistol crosa examination tins was two or alnee hours after tho shooting I dont know if john wadman was ut the inquest I saw him that night at spencer raymonds he went home with the body skeen said theros a pistol on the cupboard was alio llio beason I noticed it was recalled I know the pistol spoken of as the dummer kintol got ion of the pitol about ft week after tha killing the pistol would not revolve welt alter leil it bilto some one crom I got alio pistol walter got it in ft for I sat in a wagon in front of 11 II 11 and Dutu inor went in antl goi alie pistol it WM not loaded I did not seu it before bought it come I be I didbro it a year before know aliat its condition was I almost any any it inist be used by turning cylinder when it failed to tho joskin ES hii I live at twit city never knew take the body home I saw taic pistol in the lionso on top of the cupboard I examined it it was in n very dilapi daiel condition and unloaded examined it e it ta nio annl cakl it would not kill any one alie eaon it waa taken down wa beci beroe one about dudley killing clarry in self defense cross it was not one yf wadman a boya who culled my attention to tho pistol because he aia til the stable it the litno remember tho pistol be ins ait tho houe hou e w top cupboard it was chrs two or tario wore tin kilting buring tin my son tl wot it about ho Iron leil it to dog ant did not defit in loaded jie took it off and put it in ilia trunk after took it out and fired t ait oit i it back and it on cupboards it was tle day and edwing of alid in ciure of it alio clothe which deceased and afi pro t the foy ii emif who wept when aliey avye lir arr then iter i ho cou courtl eort chiy taken ar tho mccau bwy aboy had w ce or abade ivr he itata the alor of thir ay iy ja roper he wore yin hat caffre fre but wa e wit w none of ewt alny other thana alio OTO of crami iby biow did not liko tho abt dinv Jp cr llyl ivr n piol edid idid arx liis sut dont think ire had ono cap ar rit ft pistol iny eted amm ana of it bwy it could bo cn ti ayi the arre not cheit when henry killed t ta hiex been worn baca lue I ahm rubout aw wore ihfe I MW him when he vent lo 10 ituk aid tha the cupboard while lie wittness wept bitterly gone tilford referred to the judge when loft the bianu wailing lays from fhe was conducted lie ruyng AS sworn an mrs Dudl fallier wa dudleyy visit tt bur digoro lid dionio lio anid lie and ilia ivi laid concluded to overlook the pt t and do better in future daiil as pos sililo lio take ho back or abend for her croaa SMITH briw worn I live at plain city known dudley eix or beven heard liia about years telling liin fortune aliree or my four anya prior to the murder dud I told iaia ley called on me there he said ho had as good a lived eliat wife a ever fehd a friend tc lii inho bad no ard feelings against anni I am a common laborer dont tell fortunes as a profession tell fortunes by cards ho naked me to tell his fortune had done eo several before do it for others without pay dont know the day of the week it WM the ath or etli of the about that tinie dont know how I fix the time dudley saw me ciglio daya before eliat time to hiiva ll 11 n told did not tell alic latue satue fortnum eccli time lia tile caida on me Tiie dirk complexion eil inn I told liim afi found out y cards it eliat caused me to flunk of it soy it was a artian who had been friendly to hini cau pil ibid trouble it waa or friday bufore the killing I alivn about three mocks from southwest aw the yun lay leaoro alio killing he was not at biame ho down the pistol and it to me it WAS nn old one dant see him clein it lie held it probably five or len I told lud leys fortune several kirnos bont know eliy he saoko of W ullian alien he lost came to my till p m mhd court resumed session at p m airs ff ADlIA was dudley called at my house on the evening to the killing and or henry he said he saw linn ill oden I dil not know he waa in oden when he was gone fifteen henry came told him joe had been there he sud s ud it was sti anee he had been at raymonds mid jue wa not thare allany nestr feht out of alio foiw leiai arois this was between and the prow ution here rested their case in wr rebuttal was called by alio ri I live at aimi city haw ann on saturday preceding or the killing I was going to my sisters when uncle came he went along ns far as preston Blai rss sart no one till I got to blurt city WAI liim three quarters of an hour ho went to mr raymonds direct we passed ad man s I did not stop nor did joe it w about a little before sundown sundo wu joe and I stayed at mrs raymonda dc that night we went over to old mrs in a short time it was a abort distance away recollect I saw wadman crosa we did stay at spencer raymonds all the time biad been there fifteen minutes when we went to the other hauae cant state all who were there mr and mrs their daughter and think my uncle joseppi audley were am about joe joe rod to spencer and walked by him talking dont know low ions it was after joe left raymonds before aft perhaps a half or ahree quarters of au hour alavo told no one of this before claar recalled A ellsworth left my bouse with ahidley jo was a little ways walking ehlt was ther thursday spoken of THE no more testimony being he witnesses on boch sides were discharged and counsel handed in their requests to charge to the court J of the prose coti on addressed the jury lie to the duty of abe jurors to alio people anil udA nl was to do justice to both he thought no chance for a doit lt and he could eo only that defendant WAS guilty lift then reviewed the case going oter the testimony and ex pla ining it fronat hia standpoint lie analyzed the seduction theory at somo lenyth endeavoring to show hat it wai fallacy lie believed that dudley wad the amt buo the seduction and bui interfiled inter filed nesa for joe llo could not urfa stand how a engage m unlawful rul a inui and say of it and ho believed lie wt li forced wunema wUn eia llo fon her cao with that ff lAi fretia in thai of her husband with and ridi caled the idea of he haenig home and 00 oo lie from spier testimony to show th dudley edg the and ali asid triin if connected with it tatti aynn only this theory wa not thought of till this ahn isono atad to bo hii naf and thedeas wain de order that tle living be toted lie amul from compiled bliwn ejection iams in relation to homicide it and what diw uniti this wian ot lie then reada lengthy cabo people va male fra tri michigan re kihne reviewed the for tle defend occupying time ho exhibited th clotee cl otle of imal awl showed alit there waa fnlund pocket in the overalls ove ralli aa tc by witnessed wit nessem a being the place where they raw a pistol he tho fauby of th thit by from Wa dinan si afler tho killing which would wily bac do to auko amo aaen t ul n would IB thought of he thear in relation to the killing asel vevva parties who to mr K a one alder of the room while tho other were arad culled attention taftt tho mind VM dhawn buck awl to ps anit liblit to oh alsoto lement ata that when she baw biilly go ont he turn arousal to awk t tho window add to fact they wont in front of tho liht wore the dian aulty look artil not look it had been nm ned blat iivo light in aln h to dot i bloody bein a it tint Da daay Uy to aty ct t il at raymond all night at J with chrt whip in liia hand fur two hour iven taking it out doors with him unless ho expected to use it counsel explained thal the baw on W admans and nwe w anade with the null of the whip aind behind n it aliat dulley was atvas struck he fiade ft lentlie lent liy re virva of the death eliat the words do were not those of a min who biad A frichtl out to kill hainli tie referred to cool durina and after the killing in the reloading of the pistol in the light and his alieh up beatty concluded by an appeal to the jury to do quilico jui lico to all parties and if was not guilty to abuit hirt lie tha jury for tha attention they had givert the whole cap and retired gurt G urt teiei adjo until friday morning |
