Show GIRLS TRYING TO PROTECT FATHER Attitude of Thomas Vance Vances Daughters Undergoes Rad Radical Radical ical Change I Witness Says Aunt Threatened Her With Imprisonment if She Told Different Story SALT LAKE Nov O fi That tho thiO at al tt tude of Lena Vance 15 years of age ago and amid Florence Forence Vance 10 years of age ago toward their father uther Thomas Vance charged with the tho murder of or their mother bus undergone a radical change chano since tho the former trial is be lie becoming becomIng coming coining more mere evident as ns the time second trial progresses Florence Florenco was on omi tho time stand for over OCI an au hour this morning morn In and amid In spite of her llor tender years year proved to be the lime best liest St witness yet et examined by b the tIme defense Florence told practically tho same story stor as her Imer sister sL er Lena Sho She testified fied that her father did not heat beat her mother with his clenched fists nor did he kick her hor but bitt that he ho had hall only pushed her down The Tho little wit witness ness said that Mrs Amanda Vance Ward AVard had told tol her that if Ii she did dill not say sn that her father Cather beat and kicked her Item mother sIte she would be sent sento to o jail Girls Story asked by Judge T D U Lewis Lowis t d X to lu tell nil all u that happened at noon noonon noonon noonon on Nov 27 i the tho time of the alleged beating and kicking she said I Papa Palm came caine home for his dinner when ho had boll drunk one ana cup of or coffee ho lie asked for another Dont nil fill It he ho said Mamma might rot pol have understood him When she bho brought tho the cup papa sail said I Itell Itell Itell tell you ou not to fill nil the tho cup Clip so full fulP Mamma salt sail something about not hearing and then said Do you mean menu to Li say that you 01 did Jid not hoar Then lo le e threw tIme the coffee coffeo at her After that he lie picked up a chair and inam mam mamma CUt ma said aid Tom Torn dont you ou hit me ruc with that and amid then she elm started to um lIm out doors While she Rhe was out tried to lock tho thu door but she sho got In through another door thai was not locked When sho she came camo In ho Ito pushed her Item down and she ahe be got up and andIo Io 1 her down iown again and then papa diduL do anything else They ii l j t l I r I said a few ew words to ono one another and thou then pupa papa wont hack back to work Could Not Remember Judge Lewis asked the witness If her father had hall said to her mother while the time mother was lying in inon on the time floor Tho Time little girl hesitated for lor Just a n moment and anti then said I 1 dont remember Did thin the quarrel between your our pa papa papa I Ipa pa and antI mamma cause eau c you ou to cry cr naked asked the tho court Yes i cried a little bit answer answered ed ell Florence Tho witness denied however that shin she had screamed at that time Dr Albert Hansen first witness called this morning for mor or the defense was van au asked In a hypothetical ques Uon of about words covering the entire history of tho rho case whether or er the tIme patient died of or mercurial pol I and lUd he Ime gave ga vo It ac no his opinion it that she aho bo did Uti dJ not He was waB asked al all alS l tJ lJ L 2 I S so o If the beating had hat anything to do o with Mrs Vances rances death and ho he an No Mrs 18 Clara who fled fied fie previously for fOI the state was re called by hy the defense and asked with regard to the tho bottle of or oil of oC mlle savine that was wn found In the Vance Valco homo home o oil Nov No 27 with a n view to Identify I ing the bottle bottlo offered In evidence by b the time defense defenso Sho said that tho bot hot tie tle had hail a color I such as tho oho in evidence |