Show TINGLEY HAS MAS AS GAINED A POINT San Diego Cal Oct 22 W WR wR R Guy in the superior court court yesterday yester yesterday day sustained the demurrer of urine rin Tingley head of tho the Universal Brotherhood nail and Theosophical soci society sod ety et ni nt Point to the tho contest con lest filed by George L J Patterson of New Newcastle Newcastle ew castle Pa to the will wll of oC his hll mother Mrs rn Harriett Patterson Thurston Mrs Mn Tingley scored floored a victory In the first proceedings In the contest conte l of the lie will of Mrs Thur Mn Involving an nn estate valued at and aDd of f which Mrs Mr was waR mm named m cd resi resl residuary res I duary legatee The rime petitioner was wad given 15 days 3 In which to file an amended complaint The court COUlt held In effect that not sufficient cause was shown for fOI the tho action brought blOught by h Patterson patt who ho al nl alleged undue influence on ou the part of t Mrs Tingle Tingley over his mother molher Mrs rs Thurston was the wife of Clark Thin Thur Thurston ston stow a member of Mrs 11 cab ca inet met and the tho mother of Mrs Its Julia P i Quinn who it was as erroneously stat stated stated ed cd in a n dispatch on September er 30 I had Iw boon been released ed by y order of oC court Jurt c front from the custody of Mrs Mrs Mm Quinn it appears apIc lr never novel was as In Inthe Inthe inthe the custody CUl tO of or Mrs In Dr Dorla Dorin F Wood senior al at the Point Lorna Loma homestead test tied fled at the time hearing that according 10 to l her Mrs Quinn for or some seine years carH prior I to having been heen brought to California had been heen in III several sanitariums nail and It was with tho this hope of o a n possible cure that she had hind placed her under life his care carp Mm Mrs Quinn was 11 1 declared an aim incompetent In Incompetent Incompetent competent in jn the tho superior court in San Diego In 1903 1908 and her mother r i iwas was appointed as i guardian of oi her h r per person I Ison I Ison son and estate A year litter later her mother married Clark II Mrs Irs Thurston placed h her r daughter d under u 11 I the tho care of Dr Wood ns as a nr I I ale vate patient and with a nurse Mrs I Quinn occupied a place a Milo mile from I the tho Point Lorna Loma homestead purchased I Iby Iby by lJ Mrs Mra Irs Thurston In its order to have Kaye her h r daughter near her I III Mrs II rs died at Newburyport Mass about three months ngo ago Mrs Mm Quinn remained under the caro care of Dr Wood but hut was waR permitted to oc cupy CUP the home of or her mother on tho time thoI I ground of tho the homestead h leased 1 hy by v I Mrs Mra IrB Thurston from Mrs Tingley I At Al the onto that Patterson r on Mrs I 7 Quinns brother filed flied his contess to the tho will of his mother another ho lie also brought broll ht habeas corpus proceedings to got bot his sister SHer whom he lie alleged ho lie 11 had hind not been allowed to see alone or permit permitted ted to take her outside e of the home homestead stead grounds Judge Lewis LOWIS in rendering his de decision decision cislon In the matter held that the testimony te showed that Mrs Quinn was being restrained ol of her liberty In the tUe sense that lint she could not nol Jo or 01 go o as she pleased Unit that her hor mother molher her legal guardian being dead slag sho sh had hail now no guardian with authority of law to 10 restrain her therefore the ther restraint r she was under was wag not legal The Tho court said ald There Is nothing In this case cast to indicate to me that limit Dr DI Wood is h the person authorized by bylaw byla bylaw law la w lo to II Mrs Irs Quinn nor 1101 the theother 1 other parties mentioned If they the have any an part In it il Xo No 0 evidence wan wm as introduced tend tending tending ing lug to show that Mrs ills Tingley hind hall any anything an ang thing to do with the alleged ll restraint of Mrs Irs QuInn or 01 had restrained her Dr Ur Wood testified ll that he lie had hall used only ml Such Mich precautionary measures as asan any an reputable physician would have done in a case caBe such as Mrs 1 r Quinn |