Show Experts Pick Stars All-Stars I Four Yanks On 1st Squad y 1 11 j J l' l jf t J rf t I fA J 1 NAO J 4 1 v VI 1 G C 1 III f fw I w r dO i r JIo if 7 Sewell J it W erl 1 A J 1 f o t C 9 r L' L LI Lea eague I Ir gueI ir f Lyons LOIl 1 nO t l V t i S S. S I. I 7 1 J Simmons Ruth Hull TWO STAR ALL AMERICAN LEAGUE TEAMS First Team Position Second Team Cochrane Athletics Catcher Sewell Sewen Cleve Clevo Ruel Wash Lyons Lons Chicago o. o 0 Pitcher Pit her Grove Athletics Hot Hoyt New York Pitcher W. W Moore Noore New York Gehrig New York First Daso Baso St. St L L. Judge Wash Lazzeri New York Second Base Harris Washington Kamm amm Chicago Third Base Dasa Hale Halo Athletics J. J Sewell Sewen Cleveland Shortstop Koenig New York Goslin Washington Left Lett Field New York Simmons Athletics Center Field Combs New York Ruth New l York Right Field Hellmann Detroit Dykes Athletics Utility Rothrock Boston Doston By Dy BILLY DILLY EVANS E WHO W iI HO HO are the leading performers in Inthe inthe rv the American league at their re- re respective positions Seeking expert exp rt opinion on the sub- sub subr t jest I put that r question to 20 per per- persons pert perSons t sons actively con con- connected conee ee with the thel l American league i Y i This baseball Jury 1 L was as composed of 1 managers players f ind md umpires S iM fir On only three fh xi were ere the thc theS S iY 1 core score of experts a a. unit They were r A unanimous in the j belief lIef that Babe J 5 S Ruth Is the tho best b t S' S S. S right fielder Lou BILLY EVANS valuable Gehri e first Nt the base base- baseman b baseman most oest man and Tony Lazzeri the class of the thc second sackers I I In jury i consulted three catchers stand out In Iii n the American league Mickey Coch Coch- Cochrane CochI Cochrane Cochrane rane of the thc Athletics Luke Sewell of 01 Cleveland and Muddy Ruel nuel of the Nationals National Cochrane received eight first choice votes roles while Sewell and Ruel were tied for second at six each The veteran Wally having a good year with the St. St Louis Browns also received ed consideration Since it is customary to have at I least two t pitchers on an star all-star team ream Ted Lyons Lons of Chicago and Waite Walt Hoyt of New York were elected to the hon hen or Lyons Lons received 12 first choice votes Hoyt 10 Since Lefty Letty Grove was outstandIng log ng among the thc southpaws In the thc Amer Amer- American AmerIcan ican lean league he was a good third The Thc fact that Wiley Moore In his first I year ear as a big leaguer should be placed on tho the second team is quite quilt a a. tribute to the Yankee pitcher The Thc had no trouble agree agree- agreeing agreeIng agreeing ing on first and second base the thc being unanimous for Lou Geh- Geh Gehrig Gehrig rig and Tony of tho the Yankees Joe Judge and George Georee Staler were tied for second among amon the thc first base base- men Stanley Harris was rated next to Tony Lazzeri Lazzell among the second sackers seekers with Charley Chancy of 01 the Detroit Tigers prominently men men- mentioned For years when sneaking of the third basemen In the American league Joe Jos Dugan Invariably got the thc call It ItIs ItIs Itis Is different this season eason Injuries have havo greatly handicapped Dugan and he has not been at his Isis best As AI a mat mat- matter matter matter ter of fact outstanding players at the difficult corner hive have been rather scarce this year ear Billy Kamm of ot Chi Chi- Chica Chicago cazo cago ca o 1 it is fleet first choice with eight votes vote while Sammy Hale ranks next with six While hile Joe Sewell has had better years at a t shortstop he lie still ha has first call by bv a wide margin With the Cleveland team in th tuck ruck all sea sea- season son lion Joe hasn't had the Incentive e of 01 former Years hut but ut even at that he Is Ia still r r ranked the best nata at his position lio Mark Koenig of New York a brilliant player despite a tendency to be er j er-j cc- cc is rated second best with Jackie Jackl Tavener Ta of Detroit and Joe Boley Doley o of Philadelphia having haYing their share of ad ad- If jou ou are willing to take the wor word ord cf of the 20 O experts the tile best b t outfield In Inthe Inthe Inthe the American league would be bs com corn composed composed posed of Goslin of Washington In left Simmons of Philadelphia in center and Ruth of cf New York in right An An- Another Another other outfield almost as well liked has and Combs m of New Y York are i I in fri left and center 1 respectIvely and Hellmann of or Detroit In right Jimmy Dykes of Philadelphia is placed at utility man on the first and Jack Jaci Jac Rothrock of 01 Boston on the second Now you ou can start disagreeing with ith the so called expert opinion of or 20 of the leading managers players and end umpires of the thc American league as shown by these two teams |