Show GIRL AWARDED SHOVEl KING Miss Cald Caldwell Caidwell well Chal Charged Brea Blea h l of Promise m md and d PITTS PITTSBURG BURG Dec lO ByThe 10 By Associated Ire MiS press MI Miss Anne Anno Caldwell New York show girl was Vas awarded 10 D by a fed fed- federal federal fed federal eral court Jury court Jury tolay today In- In lher In SOO- SOO brOach breach h of promise promise suit against John W V Hubbard wealthy shovel sho manufacturer The Tho suit of ot the musical corned comedy actress was based upon al aiji that Hubbard propos proposed d marriage o toh r In Atlantic City IP In 1922 1921 repudiated and repudiated the Ue th engagement I two years later after her return from a 3 venture in iii notion ollon picture work orl in ln California She Sh also s seduction HUBBARD AHn I IJ hubbard do led there thore ther was liny any engagement or mention of mar mar mar- mar riago In 11 his hi relations with tIes Silas Cold He testified tes tb thy y came cameto to- to toa a 11 purling parting of the Ways Wayt a Just be ore the tho th actress writ w st wh when n she told him that 1 Norman orman Ge Goddes and ond signer signer eigner had had promised parts In movie production Both Miss ss Caldwell Caidwell and Geldes te they train on the were on on the same trip to the th coast TO Br Dr WIFE MS II C Caldwell ell testified d that hat lowin fol- fol following lowing their Hubbard Induced her to Io leave leay her job In inan Inan on an A Alantic City modiste shop and go to to 10 New N York York where she took a 0 a course In a 0 school to 10 educate herselt herel to- to tobe to be- be coniC Hubb cds wita tI tb th- th 1 maker pain pa the bills the bills Hubbard told the the tho Jut jury he was very fend Of Miss l Caldwell and supposed ho loved her said d he gave cave her money and presents present but InsIsted there was was no en but t to wed cd Trial of oC the case oc moro more than a week JI wn 81 to jury yesterday afternoon and agreement rea reached l led ed early arl today after nearly 12 1 hours delibera deliberation tion lion lOr 90 |