Show COOLIDGE'S NOMINATION OF WARREN fOR CABINET POST REJECTED AGAIN 46 TO 10 39 Move Launched To Keep Senate In Session To Thwart President t Borah Takes Lead In Fight Against Confirmation Debate Grows Bitter WASHINGTON W WASHINGTON ASHINGTON March 1 16 6 The The senate today rejected for the s second cond time the nomination nomination of Charles B B to be attorney general The vote was 46 to 39 and compared with the tic tie vote 40 to 40 on which the nomination was first rejected last T Tuesday C Cory E ery ory ono one of ot th the 39 senators toting for tor were ere Re- Re Re Republicans publicans The opposition was t combination ot of Democrats an on I 1 Republican insurgents insurgent President Coolidge hart had art art- an he will offer otter Mr III Warren Varrell Warrena a re recess es appointment put pul the nomInee has not Indicated he be will still accept The roll Call cill follows s IOn I OK OR COM 1 n republicans Butler Cam Carnton ron Capper Cummins Cur Cur- Curti Cur ti Dale D neon Du Pu Pont I ern lid 1 I es est ess Gor Goft Good Good- GoodIng Good Ing Ing lithe Hale Harreld Jones of oC Wash Wash- Washington Washington ington Kees Ke es os Lenroot McKinley McLean n r Means Mians Metcalf loses lose addle Oddle Pepper Pine Sack Sack- Sackett Sacked ed ett hort SmooT Spencer ad v atson and 39 Willis 39 ST M IT O Bol republicans ah Brookhart COIl n I ra ier host ell elI Johnson Ladd Li Lt Follette horbeck 1 and amid orris 10 andI I Democrats Ashurst Baard Bratton Broussard Bruce Caraway Cope nd Dill I erris Fletcher George cerry Glass Harris harrison Harelson Heflin King hing J IJ Ma- Ma Ia- Ia Ia ld fl fI laid ld Neeley Ralston Randell Reed of Shep- Shep Shepherd hord hep- hep hepherd herd Simmons Im mons Smith S Sanson anson TOIl v t h al-h and andt t heeler 35 heel r 35 35 1 l t Labor l Labor 1 Total 46 Total 46 Palis were acre re announced as fol follows oh- oh 10 lows Republican for liens lt against corl J I hipps for tor Pitt Pitt- Pitt PItt-inan PItt mUll moan Democrat against I arlen St anon anen Republican for tor Over Oser- Overman man maii Democrat Ilg Against Reed Heed of ot Pennsylvania Republican I I can for tor McMaster J Republican against Gle n n Republican for tor Jones ow 1 ew rc ico Democrat against Senator L n 1 Democrat Alib ma rna is In B lid arid was a pair There was as no hon hoe hoh h Ii would ha hate toted CLO rD C si IO After ACer acting on lh th tin nomination the senate held a short e session and arid then adjourned until noon ro Sense borne I ate e 1111 eat ne l to prolong the In order tu to pre prevent ent tire Iho president front from mah making n a I appoIntment ti With lIlt a number of oC walling nailing the Iho th e session con con- confirmed confirmed con confirmed firmed the Iho of ot a postmaster and kept hept I the llio he wiy open tom fOI further sessions by leaving leasing on onUs Its Hs the Iho nominations of oft t tao 0 assistant attorneys 9 generals I and othel 1 a appointees e e e have hate several matters matter of importance porta left 10 lo smilingly smIlIngly I Oman tort alor it aIsh I ICon Montana tans a leader leather of tire the opposition to J Air Lr I IS barren RS as ashe he left leCt the tho senate chamber The vole tote ote by the I ho opposition lion tion lod y v eio CI 0 those thoo of or Senator Dill I I d da a de Gerry Kendrick hendrick and Smith and 11 and Li La Republicans Tire Tho allon forces gained the tote ote of oC Senator Lenroot Republican can cair Wisconsin but lost that of b senator Reed need Republican Penn Penn- alto ho was paired stub lib Senator McMaster Senator Mc- Mc Mc er 10 previously voted toted ted against tho conCh matlon The lion lion also aloo lost loot the tho ot vote solo of ot Senator I Porth Cro Un Caro lint who alto last rue voted toted for lor confirmation but bilL a v as paired ho- ho hoit div lo-div lion tion it in Iii opposition 0 o the lire nomina nomination 10 1 1 ORIC IRL The fhe debate was sins opened I ly y Sea Sea- Sen-ato Sen en- en aton atol Golf Goff Republican Vest el VIr- VIr Vir a who ho in itt hi his i pech In iii the tho senile sold Id Ire lio would bp b derelict It If he lie did not det dd nd a aIna inn Ina man so fit tit for Cor the tire office as Mr w ai am ron rent Citing his in lie he lre Be Be- Be D rl rifle sea ea seal fisheries case as asan asan asan an example ot of the nominee legal he lie Mr III 1111 Oil Ia 55 is 5 not employed in lit nil case cao ns as a clerk cIerI as his hat hal omm Poe Page SeTen SENATORS SPEAK PLAINLY N MATE DEflATE BEFORE THEY VOTE TO REJECT CHARLES B WARREN Continued ITom Pa ODo charged but a as one ono of tb the th- leading counsel i RI ni conn IP USO I Thet The t esl ot Virginia tor en also IlIo pointed to Mr Ir Warrens ann up appear appear- appearance anco pear pear- ance at The Hague In th hi North fisheries cue case ca o qs li another of or hi his hia legal lecal capacity Declaring that through h in to the th case was liS settled nettled to the of ot nil all of vt tho the co irm 10 In- In s lolled oh ed Mr Ir Warrens Warren's diplomatic work lit ht J r In tn a cancella cancella- Cancellation cancellation tion of or the Iho Lansing agree agree- agreement ment ment and hi his Ie In Mexico a a o ambassador were ere di 00 red and by Senator GnU Gott to be he In themselves a proof of ot hi his abilities Ilu Hu lOad lead leada leada a lell from President I I to toG Ml II Garren Warren orren him for his hla services In Japan Similarly the senator then thelt pr- pr pre presented rented a letter from President Coolidge to the tho nominee conrat him on hi his Be leos In InIe Ie which the tho chief chlo characterized a as constituting a notable achievement Concerning Mr Warrens Warren's conn con connection with the tho sugar ugar interests Goff Gott asked I VI TO TRUST Are t all ail Id laniers era expected t hold contact with all the different e through which thy they puss Senator Reed Red Missouri agreed a Ith the West Rest est Virginia senator that I Ir arren Warren had had been faithful to his hi trust and added But But his trust was as the sugar I trust He declared Mr Warren Worren I had represented the sisal as itle n us as 1922 Senator Bruce Democrat Mary Mary- Maryland Maryland land walked over O and hIApo ed to Senator Reed ned to In speak sharply on the tho speaker Senator Reed replied d dI I am ant speaking loud enough nough to tobo tobo bo be heard all oser Or th the tho bloc block J Keep quiet and listen UE RE SED IL ED Senator Reed Peed went over again the charges he has brought against os Sir tr R Warren arren arren in two previous pre son son- sen en senate ate at speeches reading reading- at ot length from the records of the govern government moms ment s sugar trust trust case and pointing out nut the relationship Mr Barren arren had 1 with Ith tho the sugar com corn companies panic This record Senator Reed contended showed that the nomi nomi- nominee nominee nee was aas dS an Integral part of a plan to control the tho sugar ugar Industry In of the Sherman law Senator Gillett Republican like Senator Gorr Goft Gofta a ne newcomer comer In the senate took I Ia up the defense of 1 Mr Ir and Warren Warren In his maiden speech declared It Itan an an e extraordinary proceeding that thata a a was denied the tho right to choose a member of ot hi his own cabinet The Tho caso case against Mr orr Warren Warrn he said sold was as that everal cars care ago he represented certain Interests If H Ht t that bat was wag to bar bir a man from office ho declared many able 10 will III be e excluded Re e W e have havo no proof pere her iere Mr continued that that Mr War War- Warren Warre Warren ren will become 11 re ud Iced It he becomes attorney general S S COLLE COt JI OBJECTS Senator Couzens Couzen Republican Michigan Mr Warrens Warren's arron home homo tate state Interrupted to suggest that Michi Michl- Michigan gan ran house members did not want ant 11 1 AL Warren confirmed l then thee to the tho to former Attorney General Mone to bo be associate justice of or tho the su- su supreme fiu premo preme court Senator Gillett said there was wag a the desire to wound without the courage to strike The Tho country would Infer from the present pres pres- present ent situation ho said Eaid that some senators were seeking to return the mortification whIch tho president gave them last No No- No November No vember ember This brought a protest from Sen- Sen Sen Senator ator Reed of Missouri In to response to which Senator Gillett read from froma a New fork lork Times Time editorial ask ask- askIng asking ask asking ing what the country would think ot of asenato a senate enato that swallowed Harry Daughrty Daugherty end nd strained at Charles Charlea CharlesB II B W arren I It I is we swallowed l Har- Har rv Har-rv rv returned Senator Reed need that that we are oro straining at tW Vt arren Adverting to Senator Gilletts Gillett's to what the tho country 1 would think Senator Bruce asked Mr Ir Gillett Ir If 1 he ho did not think his 1 own 0 n statement showed A desire to wound without the courage to strike BURST Or LAUGHTER fh There re d was a burst of or laughter In the galleries and Vice President Dawes Dawe rapped sharply for order I will II ay say th this thia resumed Sea Sea- Senator lator ator Gillett that one man on the theother theother other side he of the chamber eald ahl tha that I I he was aas a acting as ag a partisan an He changed hI his vote ota ot after stating that hi party did not want Warren con con- confirmed confirmed firmed Tho The reference was to Senator Democrat North Caro Carolina line lina who ho noted for tor confirmation t I on last roll roIl call and then went ent over o 0 er to the tho opposition It If a Democratic president should I bo be elected four years benco hence Son Son- Sen Senator ator Gillett declared he would support his cabinet selection even evenI It they thoy should be opposed by b 11 I other Republicans He argued that P w was waa justified In returning the nomination after aCter It had heen been rejected because this re- re rejection re ro rejection had been by a tie llo vote voto and the president hoped partisanship could be submerged It It has been boen suggested that the statement that the president would rise him u a recess reces recess appointment a use nn an Insult to the senate said ahl the senator I think It I Ii i Iq unfortunate that the opera co cooperation cooperation tion that should hould exist between the senate and the president has ia been but It was use 08 first broken by bytho bythe bythe the tho senate donate that refused to In confirm confirma a cabinet nomination and broke broko a aI precedent ot- ot 60 years I UTAH TAKES HAND war war-I Senator Gillett declared Mr War War- Warren Tin ren had hen boon recommended d to j President larding HardIng for tor tb the tho attorney attorney ney generalship In hi his cabinet I by K Lane Interior seem secre secretary tary under Wilson Senator King Democrat Utah I I announced ho would place in th the record a n resolution proposing re- re reI return return re return turn of o the nomination to the ho pres pres- president I dent ident Senator Borah Borab Republican lao lao- laa-ho laa ho bo told the tho senate was wa wn not con concerned with charge charges and counter countercharges countercharges charges of Tho These Thesa matters aro are better for tor dl culon In another body bod than here Senator Borah Bald ald and will III ha bate hae hato ha eto e to be settled In porno omo tribunal other than this thia There Thero Is a 0 feature ho ever that must be here horo one and anti for tor all aU time lime I the Jho president hd has the light to nominate an and the senate must muot ad- ad advise vise aa-vise II ad-II vise and consent to nominations Ho has hafl the tho power er to appoint onlY to fill 1111 up III vacancies during a I roo re- recess re recess eo cess of tho the senate enate In this Instance h ha be has only the power ower to nominate The question le 10 what Is his hla duty duly It if II a a majority of the tho senate senata h has faIrly airly ro reached ched the conclusion that It If ought not notto notto to advise and consent to a nomi nomi- nomination nomination nation I Is the obligation that rests upon us u only a II perfunctory on one I Is not the obligation a solemn one Conditions h base ha been ben brought recently the Idaho senator con con- continued con continued which It would be b un- un un unpleasant pleasant to review but which could bo be largely attributed to the sen- sen senate sen senate ate falling failing to carefully scrutinize cabinet He Ho suggested that Senator Gillett familiarIze I himself mor more tully fully ully with th the intent of the framers of th the constitution and added I I appo appeal from the tho senator from Massachusetts to a former senator from etto cotte Daniel Webster and leave It to the country and end the senate to tomake toI make comparisons REVIEWED REVIEW A hundred ears ean ago aro said ald See Sen- Sen Senator ator Borah Senator Webster op- op opposed op 01 opposed posed the nomination of Martin Van Buren to be ambassador to the court of St James Jamea and In do- do do doing ing tog so 0 said he ho had not opposed a nomination of a president e except for cause but that that I consider Mr Van Buren an unfit and improper man for tor the tho places Did President Jackson give Mr Van Buren a reco recess appointment 7 asked Senator Walsh Democrat Montana No No he made mado him president lent of othe the tailed Stator State Borah replied It I Is much easier In Washington to In go along than to disagree went wenton wenton on the Idaho senator It If If there thero Is anything that weakens a 0 titans nan backbone It Is ta the atmosphere In w ashington Senator Gillett Interrupted to uk ask askIe It Ie the iho senate disposed of the Van VanBur VanBuren VanBuren Buren Bur nomination without parti partisanship I I 1 am afraid the tho senator from Massachusetts knows s I less about the history of Daniel Webster a s actions ac- ac ac actions here hero In the senate than thon he h ought to retorted Senator Borab Sir Mr Webster was ass not a partisan He did not belong bolong to that breed won It came to deal with Ith tb these Important questions of ot govern govern- government government ment POST POT I I F Senator Borah declared that In circumstances now confronting the countr count there was aas no office kith kith- n In fn th the appointive 10 power er Of ot the of more Importance than that of o the tho attorney generalship possibly that of The attorney generalship I Is not I nn office calculated to Induce sen- sen senators sen en senators ator to be disregardful of o their duty dut he be said aid Thero are those thoo who ho beltete Mr Ir Warren Is fully qualified for tor the office and I ha base hae hano ha e eno no quarrel with them The only mon man I quarrel with Is the man who thinks Mr Ir Warren arren Is unfit and Set et surrenders his hla judgment After Arter reading the correspond correspond- correspondence correspondence ence between H n 0 std and Mr Warren arren regarding tho the su- su sugar su u sugar gar consolidations the Idaho sena sena- senator senator tor added ho he could draw no other conclusion than that toot Mr Warren arren these men mn should es- es escape es NI escape cape the tha I law w If It It were ere possible for them to do s f What senator sena- sena tor nena-tor tor he bo asked would permit Mr Ha or to write him the let let- letters let letters te he wrote rote Mr Ir Warren orren 7 Reverting to Senator assertion that the opposition to Mr Warren came from Demo Democrats rats and 1 Senator Borah de de- de de cared a proper definition of o n a radical today would appear to tobe tobo bo be a man who believes In the con eon constitution constitution It If that was the definition of Senator he add add- added added ed ho he would have no objection to being so classified Senator BIngham Republican |