Show CITES DEFECTS OF I U Iii S U ASi I I Less Ad Ad OtiS Than Ihan II EnglIsh Musicians u Says CrItic I Players rIa ers in J Americas America's great sym sym- symphony sym sym- symphony symphony phony orchestras are less lees adventurous adventurous ou ous than those of staid London so eo testified the famous English music crItic Ernest Newman who his been sel solving as M guest critic for tor or the YOlk Evening Post Poet Mr Ir New New- Newman Newman man was das asked to give hi his of American o orchestras These DI aio 0 based upon hearings on I lot of the New York Philharmonic New York Symphony the Philadel Philadelphia I ph phia In Orchestra and the Boston Symphony Of Ot these four our Mr Ir Ne Newman man considers the the best best- best chich best which bleh re ro recalls calls a similar statement from I Richard Strauss during his last to America However Mr 1111 considers the lie Philharmonic I monic motile a close cloge second In giving his reasons tor for the mroe inroe adventurous quality of ot the tho London n placing pIa Mr Newman J In InI instances Instances stances the Initial advantage or of the American orchestras in be beIng being being I Ing economically secure whereas the London orchestras are not sure suro of their existence from year to Ithe ear As a 8 result tho London or- or orchestras orchestras or orchestras engage a 8 number of ot visit visiting lIng ing conductors during a season season- season the Queens Queen's Hall Jail being I the only one that 01 R s plays un under under der the tho saMe conductor As a con COD consequence consequence 1 sequence the London pIa ers seem to Mr Newman more quickly CODI I adaptable than the American Tho Londoners are oro gamblers says he and they dev elope a s vir- vir virtues vir virtues tues lues and defects detects Among the for for- former fornier former mer nier are an unusual sharpness of apprehension and quickness of reo re- response re response It Is that sense sene of ad adi on en ture that gives their pIa Ing a nerous ner ous ous Intensity that Mr Neman Nedman has not often met with In T 1 ork In all the finest playIng that he has heard beard In New 1 loik 01 J the Impression has been one not noto o of nen ous ad adventure but hut o of steady confIdence confIdence-a a feeling that the mag magnificent machine could not posSIbly go rong w rong |