Show SENATE GETS SHOCK FROM mm WHITE HOUSE i President Says He Will WillIame Iame ame Warren Even If II Rejected GREAT SURPRISE I Democrats Declare Chal Chal- ChalI Challenge Chal- Chal Challenge Challenge I lenge of ExecutIve Must Be Met 1 Y JY Y I I W Milder S of o Ian a avva a as nominated 10 lo be n i of nf pension lon Philip of ew ew 1 or minister of ot IS as nominated to 10 o be l o Jl nl-Ier nl to ln The senate nale put oft orf Until a vole otc on tin iii Jill Jill- nallon ot or o Charles II 11 Mail Mail-ento 1 be bo attorney y gent Th Tin senate K sern scenes in III u 1 t n mci Iho tho controversy between and ami Senator bC n President c it II is made nade nall know known 1 at al the bite will vili In ii 11 arren a ft r recess U If tit the tho lIa Ie tails rails to 10 i linn hJ nomination W WASHINGTON WASHINGTON- March 14 14 President will Ill offer oter Charles B 13 Warren arren arren a recess ap- ap ap op appointment as attorney aLtory general central In Inthe inthe the c event ent that his nomination Is rejected a se second time lime by the sen- sen senate sen senate ate II- II it Unas as officially announced to- to today today to day today at the White House Houe Upon I ecel III this information the senate deferred deterred a n vote vOle vot on the nomination until 2 30 p I m MoU- MoU Mon Ion Ion- Monday day after arter leaders had declared the senate must meet and decisively the challenge to Its lt constitutional authorIty which they sty tho ex- ex exI ex cx executive I had hail thrown thrOn 11 down The White House pronounce pronounce- pronouncement pronouncement ment made mado on the presidents president's be half behalf by Secretary came as asa asa II a complete surprise to 10 leaders leader on In SIdeS both In the th senate who sho ho had recel ed word ord earlier In the tho day that the Iho 0 was a as considering the selection of ot another tor fot the post DC DEBATE TE IS OPENED I to this effect wel wele e dr I generally in the th chamber alter after benator Curtis of ot Kansas l the th floor leader had bad re returned turned from a conference with Mr Coo Coolidge lido at tho th and had consulted with a II number of oC oChi hi colleagues In an effort to ob- ob obtaIn ob obtain tam tain an nn agreement to deter defer on the nomination un until III 1 Monday Senator Walsh or of Montana a 11 leader In the opposition to 10 the appointment refused d to 10 con consent consent consent sent to that arrangement and tie tie- de debate bate bale wa a opened The White House statement Is- Is IsSued Is Issued sued after arter the tha publication of ot re r ports 1 by senators said sall T T t O various arlon re re- re rc pOriS tid nd rumors a l the is 15 mating ec ever effort to 10 secure the of oC Mr arn arren s s 5 the lime it Ii Iino no hort anti and lo to the lio ha lies has consulted senators an as to 10 hat hat cour c should hould f be pursued in III inease Incase ease ae Mr Ir Warren l Is b not 1101 mu- mu Ou lie He has decided filed on no other lie will offer hint him a recess alpo appointment J iii IL hopes however hOl that llio Ilie no- no un unbroken broken praNk practice of oC three gen orations gen of ot mitt lag I he to 10 choose hoo o c lit own cabInet a will not slot now be he and that llio Iha opposition opposition tion to 10 o Mr Warren areen upon tur- tur fur further ther tIr consideration will III ho ba R In order that Iho may inny halo lae the tuc ot of lila his qualities and amI the president ma may be unhampered ered 1 In choosing his Ills own on TOTI ineth- ineth od inelli-od od Ct of oC executIng the Ions fter this tills statement ha had l been tead In the tho senile sonto Senator benator Robin Hobin colt aOI on of ot Arkansas the tir Democratic leader lander declared the tha president thus bad the tha power lOwr and right of ot the senate to 10 do Its lis duty tinder Ur tue that constitution constitution that of ot ad Ising and consenting to 10 nomina nominations omina for tor high office OULI OUID TC TI Tl Cn Crr I LESSO's The The Th e must bs be b taught to recognize be adde added that no must be Indulged In thAt this bodY beds In performing Its constitutional dut Iut I Is transcend transcend Inc tog its lt II authority and Ibs lh hta right rl hta of ot the tho executive ling the tho th opinion that not In all the tho th annals nal of ot history had IRd there been such z d of at the th senate Senator h al al h said s ld that body vas as confronted with lIh th ques- ques question ques question tion of at whether hether It 11 shall hall be dl re by tho the president In the fu tu future ii ture tore In 11 the matter of ot the th selection ot of men for hIgh hith office Sentor Reed Democrat ot of o llis- llis asserted that Ur Ule president as In effect saying that h ho he would would ii i by ting ling Into luto office a II man rOan the senate I In It Its authority under the constitution hid hd said was 08 as un- un unfilled unfitted un unfitted fitted filled tor for the tir position S 'S SUu RY QUESTION There was WItS no reply to 10 these statements from the tha side ot of o tho th chamber but some someI friends ot of o the th president said Mid that I In proposing a recess appointment to Mr Warren 1 ho lie ouId be M holly Ills hits rights by bytha bythe bythe the tha In lii th passage of ot the act prohibiting ment of ot salary to officials appointed after ner th lb reo re- re ot of t nomination by the These friends also said uld that Ilat the thc president as aae as ah I ed as to re rei opinions handed 10 n doi n b by attorneY In lii the t I-t p t lust I 1 e had lull full authority to ContInued on Oil the C Ine I CALVIN GIVES SENATE SHOCK Coolidge to Name Warren I Even If Solons Reject Him Continued Irom lage l'age t I 1 make mak recess appointments under the pres present at circumstances There was w s noord no word ord as to whether Mr Mr Warren would accept a recess appointment if It tendered The Th man who ho ha has hns the th storm center In an open fight bel between een the pros pres president ident and amid the tho th remained In seclusion at tIme the White As tho the sen e assembled the tho pr president held last minute eon con conference con conference ference with smith Senator Curtis Curti Ian Ian- Kan Kansas sas s and Senator BIngham Republican lican lIean Conn Meantime hi his lieu lieu- lieutenants lieu lieutenants tenants on the lh floor were In cion with some ot of o the Republicans Republicans who previously oled against confirmation urgIng th them m to support the administration In InI I what hat now nO has become the tho first big Issue between n the Iho 0 and the s senate nate LW EW POLLS roLLs MADE DES N New w po ls ot of the senate were ero leaders on both sides aides but they were ere said to ho hoe hav e sho shown shon n no change in the th situation with an Indicated majority against con con con- confirmation con of oC from from Crom three to sl 51 pendIng upon the ucc success ss In ob- ob ob obtaining taming pairs for tor abs absent nt Republicans can cans Senators Gooding of ot Idaho and Spencer of oC Missouri administration administration administration tion supporters who were back acl In their places had been beers recalled d to Washington ut On Ott the opposition sides aides ides oles iotes hid h be been n added with Ith the return ot of Senators Smith or of South Carolina Dill of oC Washing Washing- Washington Washington ton E Edwards of ot N New Nw w Jerse Jersey and Gerry of Rhode Rhodo Island Senators Smoot ot of o utah Hah a War War- Warren Warren Warren ren supporter and Howell of oC N No- No Ne Nebraska braska an opponent were absent because of ot Illness but arrange arrange- arrangements arrangements ments ments had bad been made mad to bring them to the senate If it there was waa a loll iou call cill The rhe senate galleries were filled and hundreds waited outside In iii Inthe inthe the hope of oC witnessing a a drama as ax stirrIng as that ot or list Tuesday h when n the th was as reject reject- rejected rejected ed cd on a tb ioto ote to whilo Ico Pres Pros PresIdent President ident was as hurr hurm In to the tho thos s senate nato Ii om his hla hotel In a n fruit fruit- l sj effort to arrive In time to cast the tIme declaim deciding ballot WES D IS Mr Dawes es was on hand early arly toda todal Senator benator Walsh Ics presented the majority report of oC the judiciary committee which contended that the president had ec exceeded eded his hi constitutional authority in tn resubmitting tho the nomination of OC Mr Warren to the tho same session of ot the senate senale aj af af which it had be been n re- re re rejected Even though time the constitution constitutIon- constitutional al at authority existed and tho time rules dl die not forbid the th said It It a would be bo in tIme the last unseemly In the absence of ot any sho showing from Crom an nn foi fot the tho thos s senate nate at the m mere re r request qu st of ot the the president r sl ent of ot the United Stat States to reverse Its action In ucb a mat mal lei ter The power o his groat roat office Is slid stid to bo be in excess ot of that by any constitutional mon mon- monarch arch The wisest and most patrIotic among the th founders the tho h hf hg g gov- gov eminent cov-eminent enJo and the II 1 ot of f our co harbol cd anxiety ty about entrusting him with the power ower to appoint all federal of- of officials of officials and dreaded the influence It would p permit his to exercise 0 oser er the action ot of either cither or both bolh houa houses s ot of congress ss Time The The distrIbution distribution tion ot of what hat has bus come corn to be call called d patronage was as r reluctantly placed 1 Ills his hands use bec no safer or more practicable method could bo de demised Is d The peril of ot permitting him ln again and again s ain to endeavor to Impose upon the people a n nomi nomine nee flee ne unacceptable to t- the tho th senate particularly In a cano case in which as asIn asIn asin In the l the th Ole sOte Ot taken upon the nomination Is la need not ot be enlarged It ItIs ItIs ItIs Is thC opinion of oC tho the committee o that tho the nomination should be promptly r rejected S Senator n tor Pepper paid hIgh hish trib- trib tributo trib tribute ute uto to Mr loIr arren outlinIng his hi and readIng numerous tel tel- telegrams tel from Crom la yeu and bar as- as association associations as associations attesting hi his fitness for Cor Corthe forthe forthe the cabinet appointment Chairman Cummins Cummin of oC the ju- ju judiciary Ju Judiciary committee then then- put Into the re record ord SL IL from Jle me Detroit Union League club x TX x pressIng a great majority of ot the th Republicans ot of Michigan and the tb nation nUon endorsed the action of ot the president In reo re- resubmitting re submItting the Senator Pepper resuming took exception to the th contention of ot the tho majority of ot the tho th committee that the president had exceeded hIs authority in resubmitting the th nom flora nomInation nom Tho Tile Th senate must consider this u as a n new w e act he h said and and must mut mu t proceed to consider It W o ULD Declaring Mr Warren arron had won hIs spurs spur In iii active practice ot of othis othis his profession proCession In his home com corn community In time tim becoming an outstanding outstanding out- out standing figure In his state Ben Ben- Benator Benator Sen Senator ator Pepper r read ad a telegram from Crom Walter alter s alter S foster Jooster of ot the tho MIchigan Bar association stating that that lawyers la me Michigan are aro astounded at tile the th statements that have bc been n made mad questIoning the ability and of oC Mt 1011 Warren Worren Mr Warren Is ii eminently fit til tilted ted for the he th attorney General lp the tel telegram gram said S Senator Pepper declared Mr Warren s Integrity lIeHr hind had been Impugned and that the th fundamental tal tal Ia question was w 1141 whether hether lIe he h had such uch a slant of ot mind In favor tavor of ot big ble busIness as to make hIm unfaithful to tho lbs trust of oC at- at attorney attorney at attorney torney generl This qu question Senator Pepper answered ered In the e |