| OCR Text |
Show END TO ALL CORNERS i Important Decision Against Chicago Board of Trade. STRIKES INSTITUTION HARD Conclusion of Court Is Far-Reachlng Dlrcctota Have Had Their Towers So Curtailed That They Cannot Longer Adjudleato Upon Ptoperty j Rights of tho Members of tho AssociationJudge As-sociationJudge Declare There Is no Ttovlslon for Succession of Membership. Chicago Sepl 11 most Important decision against the Chlcato Hoard of I Trade was rendered Iodic b) Indue Axel Chytrnus In the lul oats corner ' Injunction enses Not onlv does Ihe opinion nf the court. If sustained by higher tribunals put an end In all earners ear-ners In commodities qn this exchnnge, but It strikes nt the verv life n( the Institution In-stitution ss linn organised The directors direc-tors for all lime have bad their powers so curtailed tint the) cannot longer ad-Judlcnle ad-Judlcnle uioti i ropert) rights of the menders of the association Judge Ch) Iraus goes even fuitliei and sn)s Hint undei the charier of Ihe Hoard of Trade theie Is no piovlshm for succes-ceselnu succes-ceselnu nf inembeishlp and asks the pertinent quesiinn What shoiil 1 become be-come of the corporation when persona now composing the r ris.Hi it Iward would lm dead'' CASH AT ISHI'i: The case In question was one brought Ii) the commission linn nf Walte Thor burn .; Co npnlnst the e'lilrngn Hoard of Trade ihe Jimk of Montn il and several imminent members of the llonrd or Trade In which n lempninr) Injunction wan granted tn prevent margins mar-gins tint were put up by the complainants complain-ants finin being Inndcd down lo the contracting defendants The claim was mide lint the defendants had mil a corner In Jul) 'standard' oils The complainants who hid sold ehort ' let the defendants while not den) Ing their contracts ami white dcclirlng llnlr pur pose to in ike gool these same contracts con-tracts made protist against having Ihe cute adjudicated b) the Itoircl of Trade as provlbd In the b) liwa of the aesoclitlon The 'stand ml' oats In question weie on a grade and line nesn nlmnst Impossible to obtain In suf. Ilclent eiunnlltlen In till contracts during dur-ing lul) because of delay to crops by ralii) weather In the pit on 'change blghl) fictitious prices had been put on Ibis commodlt) and the complainants nkec the court lo set a fnlr price be-twecn be-twecn vvlile Ii jrhe nnd the one nt which the) had contracted the d I (Ton nro might be paid. This was lib d Jul) 30th, one di) before se Itlemenls weie re-quired re-quired Shnrll) after this twent) three other cases were llled bv the same com-plilnantn com-plilnantn ngnlnst various defendants; ten ensen b) Pratt, Hiirkle) Co, six cases b) II C Avery .1 Co andonoonso by .1 Henry Norton. II) common consent con-sent nil ensea weie affeited h) Ihe same ruling RULING OP Till: COURT The court said In ruling that ns far as tho merlin nf the case were concerned con-cerned it did nnl matter whether there wns a inrner, fnr It wis taken for granted lint an honest price wan In tended Thin part nf tin milter cin be decided nt n further bearing which will be bad The decision makes the In-Junction In-Junction In force until this hearing nf fnrln Is had The losing parties have appealed but this docs not prevent further hearing The gist of tho decision In that a spe-clal spe-clal committee, which, according to the toard rules shoul I be appointed by llio president In a IJudicate such dlfte lences, has not nuthorlty tn net In matters where prnperty rights nre Involve 1 Tho righta nf the dlrectorn of the board to preserve the Integrity nf Its rulea so far as disciplining members Is rnncorned by line suspenslnn or expulsion Is upheld up-held by the court ns their proper rights but he rules ngnlnst tho eiuesllon that 'against Ihe will of tho cnmplalnniiln Ihe power nf disposal over that money which In ft srnsn hns been i laced In trust nr escrow exists lu n seject committee com-mittee nf Ihreo ellslnterestecl persons, members nf the association, to be np-polnled np-polnled by Ihe president 1 e, whether the money can be npproprlaled b) such n. committee to Ihe inntractlng defendants defend-ants " IS AGAINST puni.tr POLICY Regurdless nf tho fact th it the com-plalnanta com-plalnanta agreed to be bound b) tho rules which provide fnr settlements nf disagreements, Ihe court ruled that they were not bound, lhat Iho arrngat-intr arrngat-intr of such tower lei such n body was against public pollc) nnd ' tint It would be Intro liiung ioierclgntlcs within ft sovereignty fnr tho function of construing constru-ing the law," Ihe court goes Inln great detail to learn Ihe merits nf the rase, speaks at some length of Ihe opentlons upon tho Roird of Trade of the benefits to the community from the Institution and the great Inllueneo It exerts on Ihe commerce com-merce of Ihe world It holds that as ft corporation not for profit It possesses governmental and dlsclpllinr) lowers over Ihe memlriH Hint nie not i Assessed As-sessed by slock corporations, where money or prnrerly rights nre directly Involved The general lower to pass ut on the right nf prnperl) In tho nnr gins In question however Is held a Jti-dlclal Jti-dlclal imwcr which never can be considered con-sidered to have been delegated or confirmed con-firmed by dubious Implication ' The ordinary courts of Justice " slid tho court constituting nne of tho branches nf our Government ought not to be nnd shnull not submit to being excluded nr ousted of jurisdiction hy Intendment " SOMRWHAT SARCASTIC With some sarcasm the court ad Is Th" master!) Ingenuity or the plan contrived to prevent appeal to the om-mnn om-mnn law courts nf ! State rnminnnda our admiration '1 htnlt nf the long time nf operation that has rrnvml the scheme a rue censful nue The loser vv ho ma) feel himself nggrlovcd unci who may know himself to have been wronged by Ihe operation of a corner or otherwise nt I iw cm onl) sue to get his mone) back Rven that rrmed) Is by Ihe resource fulness nf the scheme abridged Por It Is rosslble fr him to do even that only after he had an award or adjudlrutlou against him hy thin Hoard of Trade committee or tribunal ' |
