OCR Text |
Show AGAINST BUCKET-SHOP. I Unlteil States District Court, Kixuns City, Qnnts Kcstrnlnlnff Ordor ravorin Hoard ot Trade. Knnfl Cit Jul 7-JmtB'1 Honk tn the I nit. 1 Mntps Plslit t t Mirt toUj In huitliiK Unn a ilOitntm In tho nilt broi Klit li th? Chli ,h llonnl nf Trnd milium the ChrlMtr (Irtitn A Stock com pany of KanMd Cs t prepnt Iht iiw of th Cht ugo boitnl n ti toliitlnnn h M Hffnli.tH thr buckut Plvn n almost prry ol I n Hppriil t (hf I nlit.l Stutci Su.tnmc toiirt ntll Ik- lak.n in Un suit tiled a .ut huo Ihr ChkBKO Hi anl f 'Irnil t In I in a oroprlrt ir rlcht In Its (luntiitttnt and umler the m luck, t nhop liv ohkIu to t)tiit'l miiin priulatorH In .Uffercnt At Una to pa fr iht uao nf thrm Tin Ohrlattt ompanv fmitht tho trtito on thi irtouiiit that the hUuuo Moard of liudc Itirtf wan a tiiiLltet ihoii vlthnnl rttitndlnR nnd rnr-tlur rnr-tlur that Us quolutlons won public pt p-tTi p-tTi The null was tn I ho form of an ap-PIKutloti ap-PIKutloti hi thr Board of Trade foi A tt mimrnn Injunction Tiidjn Ho tk Rruniul tho tpmprarj in-Jumtim in-Jumtim t'hrlatl attoriioH announend th it a ouiiorx dvua hnnd w mid I p kIhi whiih woull opirult to utm th cxtcii ti n of thp tlporocp i ti linn appuil With the InJumilun atird It MI1 If noKii.hh for iiirl)tlo to lontinuo Kitting llin (iiiotatlona b titt nirun na he han Iwrn doln wlth.it n mlorlnff him-ft him-ft liable for contempt of tnutt Tho auit a! 1 t nJ tin tho cslorn I'M mn TNoirrapli comimnv nnd the I'ont il Trlograph innipati from ilUtrtlMttlnff or Klvlty tho t hlciiKo iMiiird a iiuotattona to th. rhrlxlfr inmpum Iht tourt lontrmlK that It ti unnpora-Nan unnpora-Nan In thli ihso to dirtno tho rxm t llm-ltattnna llm-ltattnna of thla proprrt right or to an ciritiln the full extftit of the control whUh the Iloutd of rrado hat over tta Quotation It la lu Id to It mifrtilcnt If thr hoard poaaefxea n ntramtro of owner ahlp and control On thla liaao of tho question lurigo Hook arti Tho quotation an tho naultn of train--nctlona lictwcen tin tm inhora of th Itotrd nf 'I rudi til on the ll j ir of in fXihatigo hall own.il hi It and malntalmd I'V It nun cxpino lUr uto Kuthoinl l Ita own rinpln-oK Tho iiormm a paltlo cominrrclal aluo Hlu n Intanlanti'iidly anl mntlnunut tranatnltfd mid dtntrlh-nt'd dtntrlh-nt'd lu tho cltj of 1 hi auo and thmuKli-out thmuKli-out tho eountr. and an a potirro of auh-atnntlal auh-atnntlal roonuo to tin lomplatnaut It la compdiil that no 1 ail obligation roat upon tho Hoard of Trndo to eather on I (11-trlhiito the i)iiotatln' ll tna ahandoit tho Katherlnu and iluurlhutloi. of theni while contlnulnz the transaction of Ha tiual luiilneae ' Of tho contention of tho Christie com pan thnt tho contlnu ma markt t quota-tlona quota-tlona are of siuh a character that they hne become clothed with u P ibllfl In i roi ami moi un lona; aa in" imini run-tlmios run-tlmios tn tho hunluena of collecting mi 1 furnlxhlnff thm to the puhlh tt inuttt d no wt tho ut un.1u-t illarrltnlnntlon Judra Honk anvn The oondtllon Imposed am not irrhlbltlo or unronnonahh, and they nppU to nil persona nltkf who dcslro tho (liiotatlonn for lawful purpoaea lURardlmr the (ontintlou that th) lloird of frado dooa not oinn Into court with clean handi in that It I ttxrlf en page 1 In the constant Motion of the II 1 1 no la law rifculnet huckrt sbni a nnd that tin titiotathma nre th rifiilts of Kdinlntf Miituna tho court aaa Whllo tho oldcnii which hia been prtHcnlol Klca rlae to u aunph I n that In man; of men traniutlotn a Mhnv of tin proi erty bounht or aol I wna not contemplated bv nn of th pnrttea then -to It la not aulttclent to Jiiir n reneral tleerfo of outlaw rj nifiiinat the Ho ml of Ttade und tho ttunlneriN conducted h tta number Tho rtitea of that IhmH cxi rean. I denounco tho irnrtlce of denllm; tu dlf-ferencfn dlf-ferencfn on the Ihictuattma In the market mar-ket price of nny commodity nn 1 without a Ion i tide purchaao anl aaln for ncttiil dellxerj and provldo for tho cxpulrlon of offend lug members Theso rules tmpone upon tho seller tho obligation to deer tho property fold nnd upon tho purchaser the obl.tratlon to rccelvo It" Tho decision wa aomcthlnir of a stir-rrlxo stir-rrlxo to Mr Chrlttto anl hln attornes It had been exported thit it would bo In line with the nil hum of thi Vnltetl htnles courts nt Cincinnati nnd Indlauapo-j re cenlli whleh tUtlared that tho Chltto Hoard of Irndo wna without stoudlnc In court beriuso of Its own lolatlons of the nntbbucket shop law The question of property rlsht wna not decided In those (.uses. |