Show SAYS MARGETTS MAR ETTS IS EXPERT IN ODORS r L Attorney Daly Declares Horseless Horse Horse- J less One Can Detect Nuisance Nuisance Nuis- Nuis f t ance Off Hand S HARD DAY FOR DR STEWART 1 Witnesses s In r E Evidence on III by lIy City C Health Ih Detriment j 3 The main event In the trial of Dr V. V f. f Stewart health commissioner charged f. K with maintaining nuisance f a day a was was the Die effort on the Die part parl of oC Attorneys Attorns At- At AtI I L torn s 's and Daly to prove C 0 that Horseless Bill Margetts health t Inspector was an expert on tin o odors ors and v f smells and antl that thai he could coul prove a at t if fin smell a mile anile oft Just by toy looking at It H not to mention the Iho way WRY In which he L shone when he weighed wele-hed It V V V There were vore several Ie tills lilts between the gb V I attorneys attorneys' for tho the two sides yesterday 1 r nn and the nu magnificent wa way in which Jj V and Daly slaughtered d the law V was a n revelation to themselves ln s and keen Iwen enjoyment to the spectators VV even Judge Smith bt being ln compelled to lo r V V laugh h a great greal many times limes at al th the asa aser as- as a V V er lOll they made macJe V V V Sev Several beveral Ial witnesses 9 wore were examined V V during the those on the stand In InV Inthe Inthe V the Rex w. J. J II Worrell Wor Vor V V roll rell Charles W. W Edwards and aini his wife V who live at 1052 West Vest Third d South and Q Ireland who resides at 1036 0 S West Pest Third South The rhe testimony of V these Diese witnesses ses was to the effect that thai V the odor emanating from froni the dump was something extremely offensive V V especially when the Die wind wafted ItIn flIn it fl itIn L i In the direction of their homes They V all testified to the th fact that thai at al evenIng evening even even- ing lug it was necessary ssan for Tor them theta to re ret retire retire re- re t tire Into their thell homes and close all the V V V doors and windows Mrs IS J Edwards Edvards J testified that Dial she first noticed the theodor i V od odor r about live JIve or six weeks ago V V He lie Dumped Garbage There fhI V In the afternoon Claude Rogers g i. i V V who drives city dump a wagon on No Ii 5 6 V V V was the first witness He lie testified to tot It t i- i c V V the fact tact that thai he hc had b been n dumping t r- r V I about two loads londs a da day the loads bails containing con con- 4 taming ashes papers usual garbage vegetables and antI the the- like He saw w wr r V Jones Tones and Banks Danks two other oilier drivers rs V of of- city wagons al also o dump stuff there V Ht had ceased to lo dump ump garbage c there V. V about two Iwo weeks s ago o b by order of the hoard board of or health He did not think there was wa ver very much odor I V Mrs Isabella Ireland of 1036 West Vest Third South said paid she had lived hived there V V over o eight years and arni began noticing 1 but bul that the tho odors about six weeks ago V V V it seemed to grow less about ten days V V ago o Th The odor was WilS vel very foul roul she V stated and In tho the evenings she had c to leave the front porch and cl close s 0 V the doors She saw a number of V wagons dumping stuff among them V being city garbage wagons On Aug V 3 nho went to Hurs Horseshoe shoe bend and V V V saw city wagons wae-ons dumping stuff and V refuse but could not get close enough h V to see anything clearly on account of V the smell She never smelled nn anything any V V thing thereabouts until the city began using the bend for or a 0 dumping place and never nc saw an any refuse In lu there V before the city started it She said aid 4 she he had to leave Ica home a great deal dealon dealon eal ealon on account o of the foul toul odors odor Mrs Ir rs Worrell wife of or the complaining complain complain- ing Ine- witness said til she could cOllI l detect the bad had smell binell during the past five weeks i V and that It was WS a ft aIle vile Ile naU nauseating V V V smell It made her sick she said mid causing cn headaches and a feeling reeling of oC V sluggishness slue She called calle up the the- thede thode department department de de- ICV IC- IC V and complained t about It on T July 25 26 6 and a week later laler Had to lo O C Close Q l House c. c V Mrs Irs Charles Chorles of ot 1034 West Yest V Third South said she had hat lived there lor six years The terrible smell began In July and she found round it necessary essary to close cloe the tho house up tight lIe to keep It out For two weeks it lied had been ben very ven strong but it stopped last week V V Lincoln Jones driver ot of garbage V No S S. S said he had bee ben n driving eight months and antl during Jul July and anti V f part of August Aue had dumped in the theco co Horseshoe Jor e bend lIe He had hall never talked the Die dumping dumping- with Stewart as to j. j t grounds but the Die Inspector ha had told V V him to dump there until further or or- ders Other wagons had received recel the His Ills order to stop same Instructions from the board ot ol dumping came holth V V inspector Inspector Margetts Iare was then called lC V- V V and nd testified ed that he hail had ordered tho tue I wagons to dump lump at nt the Horseshoe V bend as he had received Instructions from Stewart and owners of or the prop pro V V V VV V crt erty orty lIe He had hall been leen an inspector ctol two V V VV V years ago he stated and antl was WIS a j coins com com- of at smells s- s potent judge jude V At this point Joint Dinnin introduced a aI permit from the property owners In Inthe Inthe I 1 I the vicinity which permitted the dumping of ot refuse and it wa was vas on th the V V strength th o of this permit that the mayor VV VV had hall instructed Stewart to lo go ahead and dump V. V V IMI Mr Hanson Hnnson attorney for tor the prosecution prosecution prose prose- Hose cution cullan maintained that the permit did not Hot give the right to maintain a public V nuisance The matter malter was paSe passed and Margetts Margetts Mar Mar- I. I lIe He lieV lier getts proceeded with hl his te testimony r V said the tho rel release was to be in force orce V until ordered to stop When told to he stopped dumping at dice nce V Dal Daly asked the witness In uIn In your JV V opinion would an anything dumped there thereA be bo a n nuisance A Mr Hanson objected maintaining 4 V that It had not be been n brought out on onI f V I C examination cross that Margetts was an expert on smells ana anc odors s Daly We Ve ve wish t to show that other parties have ed dumi ashes cans and c so forth J Mr Hanson Especially Especially the St so S so 7 t forth rth Daly Dal- Dal Not Daly-Not Not ot particularly i Ex Expert rl On Smells Dol Daly said that Margetts l was an ex expert ox- ox A pert on smells that he can tell anC ances arices H by smell In fact that he was wasa V V a champion smeller V V After Afler some somo further evidence alongI along along- the same line Margetts was waa excused I and Mrs Irs Luc Lucy Anderson who lives lI on onI Ninth West t between Third nd Fourth I South was called caned Mrs Anderson gave V clear direct evidence In spite o of th the V I efforts of at Dininny to entangle her He tried evasive queries which Mrs Anderson Anderson Anderson An An- derson met in kind He tried to lo fix 1 smells In other places than at al the I Horseshoe bend hend but Mrs Anderson al always always always al- al V ways gave O testimony referring to that thai I 1 locality Asked by hy Dininny You I cant can't get et awa away from th the Sol smells ens of I V Horseshoe bend can you Mrs A Anderson Anderson An An- n- n derson quickly responded Unfortunately Unfortunately I can not V VV VV V V While Mrs Anderson was still on the tho stand tand court courtS adjourned until 10 lc this morning V I o. o I k tJ h d |