| Show oJ liEN fiEN DEBATE ENDS CAREER IN SENATE Amendments to Railroad Bill Will Now Be Taken Up For Vote MR FORAKER AT FINISH Tillmon Tilts TillS With Spanner Bacon on and Bailey During Ills Tirade Washington May IClY 3 The fhe The general debate In the senate on tho the railroad rate bill which has been In progress for over a month closed this afternoon after after- noon Tomorrow amendments will be he betaken betaken taken up for tor dl discussion under th time the rule rulo limiting each senator to 15 minutes discussion on each one There are arenow arenow arenow now 70 iO amendments Each day swells the time list By a strange coincidence the debate was vas closed b by bIr Mr Ir Foraker 0 O who began bee the discussion on tho the floor loor weeks weeks' before beCore the rate bill was madu mado the unfinished business Mr 11 Nelson Minn also spoke Mr of South Carolina pointed out specific cases of alleged Indiscretions by federal judges to enforce enforce en- en force orce his position that thal I if con congress les a rate te re regulation bill the bill hill should Mould prohibit federal judges judge from suspending the rate rato pending a full rull hearing caring of or tho the case o 01 on appeal Ho spoke poke unsparingly ly of ot some of or them Spooner n He lie became very ven bitter and amid at on one onetime time Ime a rather acrimonious interchange with Mr Ir Spooner WIs made male the galleries tremble It was d during the South Carolinan's criticism of or Judge Judg Jenkins Injunction order to of the Northern Pacific railroad 01 of whIch Mr Spooner was at the time one OIK- of the receivers A disclaimer of or InI in intention In- In I to insult was vas entered by Mr Tillman Mr 1 Spooner withdrew tit the word wod Indecent which he had u used tl e-tl to characterize Mr h conduct and arid good humor was restored Prospects of or more trouble arose when whelm Mr Bacon Ga In defending the tho courts deprecated wholesale crItIcIsm criticism crit crIt- of the Judiciary upon one sided test testimony tE-sUmon Mr Tillman warmly defended h 11 h- h position In which ho he was later Inter upheld upheld upheld up up- held by bv the D Democratic leader Mr 1011 Bailey Tf Tex x antI and Mr Mi Teller roller Colo The galleries were vero crowded durin during the debate ii Ul Cites Cases Mr Ir Tillman Tiliman cited the tho case cae of Judg P who hmo tried to 10 o iT tt t editor of or tho time Charleston and amid Observer Observer Ob Ob- i server t for tor criticism of oC his decisions dc n and nd then took tool up imp decisions of Julg Judg j Pardee of ot Florida who vimo he lie said slId f bo be impeached The Time senator said there had hall b bet bee cases of tyranny outrage e and almost l every form of ot Judicial indecency I in his own state tate But the tho judge I. I I I- and amid ha has to settie settle set set- dead lead h he said gone tie tle his case eJ elsewhere find anI Ill I'll let him bum alone He said Bald he lie had heard of oC cases o of s s and criminality In Kentucky and Georgia but ho he had not minI time to Investigate them In In III commenting upon the time refusal al of the senate to Impeach Judge Judo of oC Florida he wanted to know leno how ho the time people of or the land could ha have 0 con- con in the courts when their only means of getting n. n corrupt Judge orl the bench proved n a failure allure Why h So Much o Objection bj I I Mr Mu- II Bacon Ga Go Interrupted to ask wh why there was great gleat objection to time the issuing of a temporary injunction when the same Judge was wa to finally pass mss upon the question of a n permanent Injunction Mr r. Baile Bailey interrupted to reply that under an Interlocutory decree Inter Intel dela delay was permitted in time the final hearing of oC the case whereas ater after af- af ter er the Issuance of or a permanent In Injunction Injunction In- In junction unction an appeal could be bc taken at once Mr irr Spooner insisted that tho the law would now no permit an appeal from an Th interlocutory decree Mr Mi Bacon urged legislation that would expedite the time trial of tho thu case ll after r the suit had been bc begun un as W well wella a af as to hasten appeals and then stepped a aside to deprecate general criticism of the time Judiciary Judicial lIe He thought It unworthy un un- worthy of any senator to 1 time the Judiciary Judicial Ho lie said there were ere pos possibly ca cases eg of oC harshness tyranny tym and cruelty cru crU- ot city elty but that it Jt was as a mistake to at attempt attempt attempt at- at tempt to magnify the Imperfections of ot ofa a u few judges He lie that the courts were the great she sheet t l anchor df de conservatism conserva and when the time came that thai they were no longer to be rc regarded I I that light It mattered not whether the thc executive and legislative branche of or tho time government were conservative consor Hewitts Criticism Mr 11 Tillman Tiilman emphatically emphatiC resented what he considered to 10 be bp criticism of or his remarks lie He thought H It to put lut ut I the tho lie country upon ll its Ih guard amid time the Judiciary upon notice that It wa- wa watched He lie referred to 10 Mr Bacons Bacon's attitude altitude n ns as nice sense e of proprIety propriety pro pro- and almost squeamish regard regard regard re re- gard for the tho proprieties oo Mr 11 Bacon declared d that the s cnut lt was vas Invested In with time the power lower to tu sit In itt Impeachment but It IL had harl not the time to originate OIle such trial and he lie thought It Improper for fol tt it senator to from sided one testimony a case which ml might ht later be brought before before- him t t. it s-it In judgment upon Ills tribute t t. t the Judiciary was loudly applauded IA II the Republican side of oC the chamber Mr Mm- BaIley declared that while ho bc held the judiciary In the highest es esteem esteem es- es 0 teem tem ho could not nol be bo blind to the time fact rac that there were many Incompetent men upon the bench He lIe said mid he lie ili Tild lit not h believe that the time people W Wi blind to the fact either When dK- dK covered h he thought h they should b h. h In touching on the time Swa Swayne mie ne case h l lie dt that an as long as a man man cat sat on the bench whom he had voted to impeach im impeach un- un peach he w would uld not rot favor I that would enable enable-a. Judge to lo set d by Injunction and decree n and aid benefit the corporation at It the expense of ot tin th individual Must t Observe e Constitution lie Hc said that h 11 hp ei did l not believe t Continued o on Page Pas T Two o. o GENERAL DEBATE ENDS CAREER IN SENATE Continued from Pl One I the he supreme court of the United States would respond to public opinion ion and amid sustain a rate bill if 9 did not provide e for fOl its constitution After Mr 11 Foraker's le legal al presentation presentation presenta presenta- tion the arm army bill was vas tal taken cn up and passed after an nn amendment was wasn as n agreed reel to appropriating for forthe forthe forthe the Improvement ement of the Fredericks- Fredericks bur burg Va boulevard boule to the National cemetery ry |
